Is this a legal way to avoid the 3% Stamp Duty on a 2nd Purchase?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Is this a legal way to avoid the 3% Stamp Duty on a 2nd Purchase?


    I own a flat that I currently live in and I am looking to buy another flat in another city closer to my girlfriend.

    I would be looking to rent out my current flat (we'll call Flat A), and buy a cheap flat (Flat B). Flat B will only have a value of £50k, so as to minimise any stamp duty to be paid (approximately £1500 in additional stamp duty for a £50k flat). This Flat B would become my main residence for a few weeks while I did it up and Flat A would be moved to a buy to let. Then I would sell this Flat B and buy another flat, Flat C, which has a value of £300,000. Since I am replacing Flat B as my main residence for Flat C, I don't need to pay any additional stamp duty for a 2nd home, thus saving £9,000, because no additional stamp duty needs to be paid when you replace your main residence for a new main residence. My local estate agent, who is also a solicitor, says this is fine to do. I'd quite like a second opinion. Does anyone see any problem with this?


    I think your solicitor is wrong. You will need to pay the additional 3% on when purchasing Flat B which would be refundable if you sell Flat A within 3 years. Likewise if you still own Flat A when you sell Flat B and buy Flat C you will need to pay the additional SDLT


      IT works in theory as you describe it and I disagree with pebbles above. You don't pay the additional SDLT if you are replacing your main residence, regardless of owning other investment properties. However if you really manage to flip flat B in a very short period of time then HMRC could quite easily argue it was never your intention to make it your permanent home or main residence and that (as you in fact are) were attempting to avoid the much higher SDLT on Flat C which you always intended to end up in.

      This sounds like a huge amount of hassle to try and save what may well end up being sub £5k when all transaction costs are concerned. Which in the scheme of things isn't very much when you're talking about owning a £300k property with another BTL in your pocket as well. I wouldn't risk running into problems with HMRC for that amount of money. If you really need to save that amount you're probably stretching yourself too far financially anyway. If you don't IMO it's not worth the hassle.


        Buying a place, doing it up and selling it is treated as a business activity (i.e. the property isn't a residence).
        Any gain is income for tax purposes as a consequence - even if you live there while doing it up.
        HMRC will want to / have to be consistent.
        When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
        Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


          My understanding is the same as pebblepebble


            If you already own a residential property under your name , there is no legal way to avoid the 3% extra sdlt .because your conveyancing solicitor will demand payment before you can register in your name. Ask you solicitor before you give instruction to proceed.


            Latest Activity


            • Reply to Full accounts requested - Treasurer avoiding me!
              by GeeMan16966
              Thanks, that helps a lot.
              06-06-2020, 15:14 PM
            • Full accounts requested - Treasurer avoiding me!
              by GeeMan16966
              Just joined PMC as Director and CS and on checking the documents handed to me for storage, there is a massive gap from 2010 to now! I have managed to find through other directors the meetings minutes for the past 9 years, however I am struggling to be given the full accounts. When I ask, I am told I...
              05-06-2020, 13:30 PM
            • Reply to Full accounts requested - Treasurer avoiding me!
              by Gordon999
              If you are listed as director and officer of the company, you can request any information going back 6 years....
              06-06-2020, 11:57 AM
            • Reply to Full accounts requested - Treasurer avoiding me!
              by GeeMan16966
              The directors changed in 2014 and then got
              Total exemption small company accounts
              Been filing Micro accounts since - as a shareholder and Company Secretary and director am I entitled to see the bank statements if they do not have full accounts?...
              06-06-2020, 10:27 AM
            • Reply to Full accounts requested - Treasurer avoiding me!
              by GeeMan16966
              Thank you.
              06-06-2020, 10:09 AM
            • Reply to Moving Back Into Let House
              by AndrewDod
              No you can't do that. If the tenant actually broke stuff and you sort it before the tenancy ends, then maybe. At the start of putting a property out to rent you can make tax related expense claims - you can't have a double bite, fixing it for yourself at the other end....
              05-06-2020, 21:55 PM
            • Moving Back Into Let House
              by Sentaiwarrior

              I was wondering if anyone can provide me with advice.

              I used to live in my own house. I moved for work a few years ago and let my house (with consent to let).

              I'm planning to move back into my house which is currently still let. I've given the tenant three...
              05-06-2020, 20:16 PM
            • Reply to Moving Back Into Let House
              by ash72
              The wear and tear allowance has been removed so you could expense the actual costs of the items as an expense, on a like for like basis, only if you are then renting it out, if it is returning back to a residential property then you couldn't.
              05-06-2020, 20:30 PM
            • Reply to Accountancy Fees
              by Gordon999
              I think its better for Ltd companies to have their annual accounts done by chartered accountant. Very difficult to get any bank loan without showing certified accounts.
              05-06-2020, 18:33 PM
            • Accountancy Fees
              by mmooney
              Hi Folks,

              Looking for some general advice. I own 5 BTL properties individually and have 3 BTL properties as a LTD Company. My tax returns are relatively straight forward and I was thinking to do my own tax returns this year. My account charged me GBP1500 for the return for my Ltd Company,...
              05-06-2020, 07:23 AM