Lease extension: Corp. Tax/"benefit in kind" implications?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    I'm not aware that companies are generally treated as transparent...


      Some are. Example: service charge income from land ought to be taxable but, by HMRC Concession, it's disregarded for tax purposes if the outgoings on service charge account for al the income (thereby rebutting any assumption of a profit element- just as where leaseholders own F which grants each one a 999yr. lease extension 'gratuitously').
      JEFFREY SHAW, solicitor [and Topic Expert], Nether Edge Law*
      1. Public advice is believed accurate, but I accept no legal responsibility except to direct-paying private clients.
      2. Telephone advice: see
      3. For paid advice about conveyancing/leaseholds/L&T, contact me* and become a private client.
      4. *- Contact info: click on my name (blue-highlight link).


        If you're still reading, fearnebooboo, no we didn't get it resolved, but the issue does/has not gone away and is currently enjoying a revival.

        On the issue of CorpnTax on FHCo, I've not looked exhaustively but am yet to see anything that would contradict the assumption that any revenues due would be taxed as 'trading' income, unless it is the principle that FHCo and LHlders (as directors) are connected persons & therefore, since being akin to 'trading with oneself', would not be taxable (?).

        This question of connected persons is imho a red herring elsewhere, since:
        i/ it appears that the overriding concern is the 'arm's length' principle anyway; and
        ii/ being connected, according to case law & HMRC regs, requires organisational control (which v few individual LHlders will have) or some sort of blood/trustee interrelationship between parties...

        From my reading of HMRC manuals, I'd agree that LHlders would not incur CGT if one of two situations applied:
        1. due to principal private residence relief; or
        2. if the transaction was at arm's length (ESC39) and other conditions thereunder were met

        ... but I'm not a tax expert neither


          When leaseholders contribute to purchase of freehold, the use of company to register the freehold title is just a vehicle to hold their interest ( i.e nominee) .

          They are not putting up contribution money to a company for external trading in freeholds with the public at large. Its not a trading company.

          So they should be able to change the terms of their own leases without being taxed for "trading with themselves".


          Latest Activity


          • Reply to Rent 2 Rent Tax Return
            by jpkeates
            It's legal.

            If you're named as the landlord on the tenancy agreements, your business is rent to rent.
            The amount you pay your father is a business expense, so you'll end up paying tax on the profit, but you need to declare the full amount as income and the payment to your father as...
            03-08-2021, 14:44 PM
          • Rent 2 Rent Tax Return
            by dhoops97

            I'm currently receiving the rental income for my dads properties. I'm currently fully managing the properties for him and the tenants are paying the rent into my account. Once I receive the rent, I pay my dad a fixed amount and I keep the rest. Is this legal? And if so, do I pay tax...
            03-08-2021, 14:24 PM
          • Reply to HMRC Section 36 notice
            by Neelix
            If you were unemployed and receiving benefits and didn’t tell them you may need to brace yourself for contact from the DWP too...
            03-08-2021, 10:01 AM
          • HMRC Section 36 notice
            by KILOCHARLIE
            Wondering if anyone has any experience with one of these please?

            I received a letter from HMRC a few months ago stating they were investigating my property affairs. I was told I could provide documentation regarding it to help but if I didn’t wish then they would complete the check on...
            02-08-2021, 08:50 AM
          • Reply to Advice for DoT 100/0 or 99/1 is there a beneficial difference?
            by spikeg33
            I know it’s 1% difference but was really asking what the legal implications are of either transferring it into 100/0 or 99/1. I’m not an expert in this field in any way shape or form and am merely asking for advice....
            03-08-2021, 09:10 AM
          • Advice for DoT 100/0 or 99/1 is there a beneficial difference?
            by spikeg33
            I would appreciate some advice on getting our one rental property transferred into my beneficial interest as I have recently retired and now have the whole of my tax allowance to use against the rental income. I have researched and researched but would like some clarification about what to do . At present...
            02-08-2021, 14:07 PM
          • Reply to Advice for DoT 100/0 or 99/1 is there a beneficial difference?
            by theartfullodger
            Difference between 100:0 & 99:1?? 1%.
            03-08-2021, 09:02 AM
          • Reply to Advice for DoT 100/0 or 99/1 is there a beneficial difference?
            by spikeg33
            Thank you jpkeates for your advice. I will now proceed with 99/1 and happy that you have clarified the situation for me....
            03-08-2021, 08:51 AM
          • Reply to HMRC Section 36 notice
            by Section20z
            In your shoes I think I would be asking for a personal interview (maybe on Zoom these days) so you can find out exactly what they require. In my experience I have always found them reasonable and helpful and you can always ask for a supportive friend to also be present if you're nervous.
            03-08-2021, 08:06 AM
          • Reply to HMRC Section 36 notice
            by Gordon999
            It may help if your doctor can give you a medical letter stating approx date when you had a breakdown and suffered some memory loss.

            If your job income is below the personal allowance level each year during last 6 years , you are not owing unpaid tax .
            02-08-2021, 20:02 PM