VAT @ 20% on energy bills charged on by letting agent ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    VAT @ 20% on energy bills charged on by letting agent ?

    My agent collects rent from my student tenants along with a monthly utilities charge.as part of their "Bills Inclusive" package
    In the past, the utilities charge to my tenants has always included VAT at 5% (as per normal domestic bills) however the agent has now told me that his accountant has said that he should be adding VAT at 20%
    In other words a 15% increase on what we have charged previously.
    I cant find anything on-line to confirm if the accountant is right or wrong so what does the panel think ?
    Thanks

    #2
    If you cannot find it online I do not expect I can. Unless someone comes along with a definitive answer, I think you need to ask the agent to ask his accountant to say what his authority is for his assertion.

    Comment


      #3
      I'd be interested to see how the accountant arrived at 20% VAT on energy bills because it is currently 5% and there is even talk of the government reducing VAT amid soaring energy prices. I might be being unfair but my money is on the letting agent misunderstanding something or not relaying the information properly. I am a bit cynical when it comes to letting agents these days.

      Comment


        #4
        Could it be classified as a business account? We were paying that higher rate for common parts but we changed to domestic with the power co.

        Comment


          #5
          It would be correct in the case of a commercial building that was elected for VAT. But this isn't.

          Residential lettings other than furnished holiday lets are VAT exempt. Costs deducted by your agent are disbursements. Charging VAT here sounds wrong to me.
          There is a fine line between irony and stupidity. If I say something absurd please assume that I am being facetious.

          Comment


            #6
            Wow,
            thanks for the quick replies.
            I think the accountant has advised incorrectly wrt the treatment of VAT in this case so Im going to challenge his advice on this.

            A couple of years ago I had a similar query wrt VAT however in that case an accountant was instructing his client (freeholder for a flat I l own/ease) to charge VAT on the service charges he passed on to leaseholders.
            I pointed out that those charges should be exempt from VAT and haven't paid them since. No word on recovery of the VAT that I had previously paid though.

            Moral of the story - Accountants take a lot of pain away but are not always right

            Thanks again

            Comment


              #7
              That's not correct, and I think the agent has either misunderstood or the accountant has been misinformed about what the agent is doing.

              And it's going to be costly to the agent.
              Output VAT is payable to the state, because it a tax.
              As the agent isn't actually adding any value to the transaction (because that would be illegal), normally the input VAT would offset it, so there'd be no tax to pay.
              But in this case, the agents paying 15p for every pound charged.

              They're going to lose a lot of money.
              When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
              Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).

              Comment


                #8
                I'm not saying that it's correct for the agent to add VAT (because it's a disbursement not a supply) but if they were adding 20% to the net price they wouldn't be losing any money.

                The sums would be
                purchase £100 + 5% VAT = £105
                sale £100 + 20% VAT = £120

                Agent receives £120, pays £15 (£20 minus £5) to HMRC and is left with £105 which is the same as paid for the total purchase.

                Comment


                  #9
                  You're right, fuzzy thinking day.
                  When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
                  Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).

                  Comment


                    #10
                    From what you've said, if the amount of VAT being charged is incorrect, then the agent would be in breach of the Tenant Fees Act

                    Comment


                      #11
                      The electricity bill at 5% VAT should be charged at cost ( as a disbursement ).

                      The agent charge 20% VAT on his own services.

                      Comment

                      Latest Activity

                      Collapse

                      • Reply to SDLT and first time buyers
                        by DoricPixie
                        How old are these children if they have yet to go to university?...
                        04-07-2022, 22:50 PM
                      • SDLT and first time buyers
                        by mpppen
                        Hello again.

                        Just wondering if someone can advise.

                        If I sell a BTL to my children who do not own their own property, I understand that they'll get the stamp duty relief.... two questions then.

                        If they're buying the £350,000 jointly, does the relief count for...
                        03-07-2022, 21:52 PM
                      • Reply to SDLT and first time buyers
                        by jpkeates
                        If the buyers are going to rent the property while they go to university, it may meet the criteria for Stamp Duty Relief but it may not.
                        It would be unusual for siblings leaving university to be able to commit to cohabit in a particular place when they graduate.

                        There's obviously...
                        04-07-2022, 15:14 PM
                      • Reply to SDLT and first time buyers
                        by AndrewDod
                        Apart from anything else, if you are selling the property to the kids, you are getting cash and they have a 100% mortgage - and then they are not actually paying a mortgage on 100% of 350K you will be paying it -- it is not a classic GROB, but risks falling foul of GROB rules - so when you die, even...
                        04-07-2022, 14:45 PM
                      • Reply to SDLT and first time buyers
                        by mpppen
                        Thanks.

                        Yes, the lender is happy to lend them 100% the purchase price so not gifting on our side. In essence, it's just removing it from our name into theirs as he is also our lender.

                        It's unusual I appreciate but it's a private commercial lender - if that makes sense. His...
                        04-07-2022, 13:55 PM
                      • Reply to SDLT and first time buyers
                        by AndrewDod
                        A few other comments:

                        Depending where you are HMRC is not going to believe "no increase in value over past two years". An estate agent assessment may not be worth much at all. If challenged and HMRC do their own assessment you may be paying tax on a 20% uplift of 350K = quite...
                        04-07-2022, 13:45 PM
                      • Reply to SDLT and first time buyers
                        by mpppen
                        Thanks both.

                        The intent is for them to live there but they may want to rent it out while they go off to university. That's where I'm struggling as to whether the Stamp Duty relief applies or not.

                        CGT wouldn't apply as the property hasn't increased in value significantly since...
                        04-07-2022, 13:11 PM
                      • Reply to SDLT and first time buyers
                        by AndrewDod
                        Capital gains tax?
                        Who assessed market value?
                        Are they actually paying for this?
                        04-07-2022, 08:35 AM
                      • Are letting agent fees(2 year lease,change of tenant) considered allowable expenses
                        by ss112233
                        This question is about allowable expenses for tax deduction.
                        Are letting agent fees for a 24 month lease(with a 16 month break clause) after a change of tenant considered as revenue or capital expenditure?
                        I use a cash basis for accounting. The fees were paid in two lump sums. One at the...
                        03-07-2022, 13:26 PM
                      • Reply to Are letting agent fees(2 year lease,change of tenant) considered allowable expenses
                        by AndrewDod
                        Absolutely northing at all to do with capital expenditure
                        04-07-2022, 08:31 AM
                      Working...
                      X