Electrical safety inspection and report - Remedial costs

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Electrical safety inspection and report - Remedial costs

    Have two flats in London. Just got an electrician to carry out Electrical safety inspections and reports. It cost £145 each property.

    The came back with a quote for remedial works....


    Property No 1:
    To removed existing fusedboard and supply and fit new rcbo fusedboard and rest labour plus Matrials £1'020.00
    Matrials cost
    Rcbo plus fused board £500
    New certificate £70
    Labour cost £450.00


    Property No 2:
    1/new fusedboard plus rcbo £500
    2/new certificate £70
    3/to join existing cable plus move to new positions also to fit on wooden board to allow cables to pass from behind also installation of new pvc trunking to concel all joint cable etc etc
    Labour plus Matrials £1'320.00


    My questions are, does a RCBO cost £500, and labour $450? Seems quite high at £1,000+ per property. Does this sound about the right market price, or am I being quoted too high. So just want to check his quotes are fair and above board.

    Any feedback, advice appreciated. Thanks in advance

    #2
    Why do you need a RCBO board?
    You could use something like a Hager VML910CO and add 2 RCBO's for a lighting and heating circuit.

    I rarely fit RCBO boards due to cost (I do not have one in my own house)
    I use Hager- cost below on Screenshot from CEF online (Hager is - in my opinion- the best you can buy) Screenshot (168).png




    What make is he using?
    Attached Files

    Comment


      #3
      Yeah thats high. A metal 18th edition fuse box from Tool station is £120. And as above I would ask why you need new RCBO. It should be half of the cost quoted in my view. Get some other quotes in.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by baldelectrician View Post
        Why do you need a RCBO board?[/ATTACH]


        What make is he using?
        Thank you for your reply. I'm not sure, he hasn't said. I'll ask him. And he hasn't said what make either

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by davidmartin_uk View Post
          Yeah thats high. A metal 18th edition fuse box from Tool station is £120. And as above I would ask why you need new RCBO. It should be half of the cost quoted in my view. Get some other quotes in.
          Thank you for your reply.

          Since I got the inspection and report done by this electrician, am I required to use him to do the remedial works?

          Can I show another electrician his report and get them to quote. Or would electricians only quote if they did the inspection and report. Which would cost another £290

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by Diversity View Post

            Thank you for your reply.

            Since I got the inspection and report done by this electrician, am I required to use him to do the remedial works?

            Can I show another electrician his report and get them to quote. Or would electricians only quote if they did the inspection and report. Which would cost another £290
            In addition only my personal view the govenment clarified that if the fuse board was fitting prior to 18th regs then it does not need to comply with 18th regs, only the regs at the point of fitment, so I would be tempted to get another electrician to take a look at the reports.

            Agree with others. RCBO is an expensive way to go,,,personally I would be looking for a very good reason the current boards are not ok.....

            All the best Stew.

            Comment


              #7
              What consumer unit is in place at the moment?
              It maybe that the current one is sufficient with a code3 on the EICR

              Comment


                #8
                Here is the part I refer to

                Here is the part - BS7671:2018 Requirements for Electrical Installations was issued on 31st July 2018 and is intended to come in to force on 1st January 2019. Installations installed after 31st December 2018 are to comply with BS7671:2018.

                The Regulations apply to the design, erection and verification of electrical installations, also additions and alterations to existing installations. Existing installations that have been installed in accordance with earlier editions of the regulations may not comply with this edition in every respect. This does not necessarily mean that they are unsafe for continued use or require upgrading.”

                So you may get a C3 or similar for not having a metal consumer unit but this won't fail the test so I would question carefully why you need new boards.

                I think if you took a picture of the existing boards and showed another sparky the reports they may give advice if they would recommend a second eicr.

                Equally there is nothing to stop you submitting the report to whoever were the the certiifcate member was elecsa etc and if the report has quoted and failed wrongly you will be entitled to your money back. Make sure the sparky understands the regs,

                Just my personal view

                All the best Stew.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Just had an estimate of £2404 for mine in London.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    I have a very exacting electrician who would rather eat sand than break the rules but he passed a fuseboard installed in 2017 on the basis that the room in which it was located is fireproofed

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Advice here in this pdf
                      https://www.electricalsafetyfirst.or...-4-issue-4.pdf

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by flyingfreehold View Post
                        I have a very exacting electrician who would rather eat sand than break the rules but he passed a fuseboard installed in 2017 on the basis that the room in which it was located is fireproofed
                        Not an expert but looking at the regs even if the room was not fireproofed it probably should not have failed anyway, I don't see an ealier fuse board breaking the rules.

                        Looking at the doc above which seems quite varied, it even shows old rewireable fuses with a highlight that it's a problem only if the fuse carrier is present which suggests that old CU's are fine.

                        And it mentions only if unsatisfactory connections are found on a CU would it be a C2.....

                        The whole ECGR seems to come down to the persons interpretation of the regs it seems and a lot is down to the install.

                        I am sure this will all come out in the wash with many clarifications and updates,, as far as I see it's due to be passed in June and not yet approved as it stands with many bodies having oustanding queries as to it's implementation..... I like the bit I've seen about the contractor needing two years experience which suggests it's experience that counts as to what is safe and what is not.

                        Only my personal view

                        Comment


                          #13
                          In Scotland you do not have Part P (scheme that lets non time served people in to the electrical industry), to a large degree.

                          Here you really have to be time served and then get your approved electrician status- for example you need to achieve what is called ' Approved Contractor - or 'full scope' status.

                          That is one reason that a Greenfell calamity is less likely up here - Scotland banned most of that types of cladding here in 2007.

                          I digress- the Scottish Government have an excellent pdf on landlord requirements for electrics in rental properties- see link

                          It may be a good idea for others to take a look and compare.

                          https://www.gov.scot/publications/el...ed-properties/

                          https://www.gov.scot/binaries/conten...appliances.pdf

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Stew View Post

                            In addition only my personal view the govenment clarified that if the fuse board was fitting prior to 18th regs then it does not need to comply with 18th regs, only the regs at the point of fitment, so I would be tempted to get another electrician to take a look at the reports.

                            Agree with others. RCBO is an expensive way to go,,,personally I would be looking for a very good reason the current boards are not ok.....

                            All the best Stew.
                            I'll ask the electrician. Thanks

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by darkstar View Post
                              What consumer unit is in place at the moment?
                              It maybe that the current one is sufficient with a code3 on the EICR
                              Not sure, I'll try to find out

                              Comment

                              Latest Activity

                              Collapse

                              • Electrical Work and EICR
                                by popotla
                                I own a small flat in the East Midlands (rented out) and am told by the management company that electrical work needs doing.

                                I was given an estimate and then asked for another. Between the two estimates, the costs, as regards four items, vary hugely. A new fan, for example would cost either...
                                13-06-2021, 17:55 PM
                              • Reply to Electrical Work and EICR
                                by Neelix
                                My advice to you is not to use the management companies sparks

                                a flat would be between £120 and £150 but remember that’s just to inspect and test, if you get C1 or C2 codes then remedial costs would be on top

                                as for your quotes - £100 for a fan replacement is probably...
                                13-06-2021, 19:47 PM
                              • Consumer unit
                                by billl
                                Hi I have an issue come up when I had a new kitchen fitted, the builder brought in an electrician to connect the kitchen wiring and he had the attached comments. And is asking for £180 for a condition report which includes Electrical inspection, Electrical testing and Full report with certificate ECR....
                                12-06-2021, 12:14 PM
                              • Reply to Consumer unit
                                by Neelix
                                Back to the op, £180 in London isn’t much for an EICR so before you give the go ahead to the spark ask him how long he will be in the property? If he says about 1 hour then don’t use him....
                                13-06-2021, 08:09 AM
                              • Reply to Consumer unit
                                by jpucng62
                                There is quite a lot of time / work involved in the EICR so I'm not surprised at the £180. He can't know the scope of the problem without doing this. What comes next will depend on what he finds. It sounds like you could be in for a large bill bill you need to get this sorted and what price safety?...
                                13-06-2021, 06:08 AM
                              • Reply to Consumer unit
                                by billl
                                Thank you both for your advice, I just went with what the management agent recommended builder. This is the second time and has not worked out well. I have asked the current electrician if he is a full scope Approved Contractor, Thanks

                                The electrician is insisting to have a condition...
                                12-06-2021, 22:10 PM
                              • Reply to Consumer unit
                                by baldelectrician
                                I agree- I get most of my work from word of mouth and existing customers....
                                12-06-2021, 21:02 PM
                              • Reply to Consumer unit
                                by baldelectrician
                                Use a fully approoved contractor.

                                Part P only is not fully time (apprenticeship) served usually

                                I would suggest a full scope Approved Contractor (either NICEIC or ECA)
                                12-06-2021, 21:01 PM
                              • Reply to Consumer unit
                                by Neelix
                                problem is there no guarantees with trades people , they claim all sorts of things BUT as somebody who gets nearly all their work by word of mouth recommendation, I would say this is the way you should go

                                remember some trade sites do not publish bad reviews , and as you can see from your...
                                12-06-2021, 19:40 PM
                              • Reply to Consumer unit
                                by billl
                                Thank you Baldelectrician, what check should I do before instructing a electrician?
                                12-06-2021, 19:13 PM
                              Working...
                              X