Tenant claims landlord submitted fake photos in court

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Tenant claims landlord submitted fake photos in court

    I've come across a thread at the following site where the poster alleges that they lost their court case against their landlord for the return of their deposit.

    They claim the landlord submitted photos they took of the property after it was handed back in a poor condition by the previous tenant and passed them off as being a result of her tenancy.

    http://forums.gumtree.com/viewtopic.php?p=1888110

    What are your thoughts on the landlord's behaviour? And her recommendation that tenants take photos at the beginning and end of their tenancy?

    And would submitting false photos in court be a criminal offence?

    #2
    Presumably if the photos are submitted to the court as 'genuine', they would be exhibits as part of a witness statement, and therefore it would consitute perjury?

    Quite apart from the obvious moral issues, it seems an incredibly risky strategy on the part of the landlord -there must be a pretty high likelihood of being caught out, with all the legal consequences thereof?

    Comment


      #3
      In the latest post to that thread, the tenant says that the property did not have an inventory.

      So if that's the case, it blows a hole in the consensus theory of this forum that No inventory=No deductions and that landlords will inevitably lose a court case if they withold a deposit from a tenant without having an inventory in place.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by Beeber View Post
        So if that's the case, it blows a hole in the consensus theory of this forum that No inventory=No deductions and that landlords will inevitably lose a court case if they withold a deposit from a tenant without having an inventory in place.
        Indeed. I have no personal experience either way, but I'm convinced that the above consensus has come about because certain apparently well-informed people have repeatedly stated on this forum extremely forcefully "No inventory=No deductions, under any circumstances, full stop" to the extent that it seems to have become gospel. I'll hold my hand up to having replied to posts here myself with the same advice, in the past.

        In the real world it's down to interpretation of the facts on the day by the court and the individual judge, and as shown in the cited example, it seems anything can happen...

        Comment


          #5
          I am sure Jeffrey or Paul could point us in the direction of some case law of other that states Inventory must be produced.

          On another note, had a call from a friend last night, water pouring from the attic, called emergency guy that LL gave her the number for when she moved in only to be told that the LL did not pay him to make emergency call outs and to turn the water off! .. This woman is tiny and disabled so to turn the water off would mean no heating in a house where the door frames don't fit! Anyway I told her to call guy back and get him out and deduct the fee from the rent! .. Now waiting for the fall out from that!
          GOVERNMENT HEALTH WARNING: I am a woman and am therefore prone to episodes of PMT... if you don't like what I have to say you can jolly well put it in your pipe and SMOKE IT!!

          Oh and on a serious note... I am NOT a Legal person and therefore anything I post could be complete and utter drivel... but its what I have learned in the University called Life!

          Comment

          Latest Activity

          Collapse

          • Reply to Newish landlord queries
            by theartfullodger
            Join NRLA and do courses on being a landlird:. Much cheaper than the alternative (lack of knowledge) in both time and money. Even with agent you remain responsible for everything (but may have a later claim against agent).

            Have you very carefully read your agreement with agent to find...
            07-07-2020, 10:11 AM
          • Newish landlord queries
            by martysparty99
            Hi all, first time here and looking for some general advice.

            Be patient with me as I am a first time landlord!

            Let my property back in feb, used an agent that I used to sell our house last year. He said he could do me a good deal on fully managed. 7% which I think is a good...
            07-07-2020, 09:57 AM
          • Reply to Deposit Issue
            by shoobydoo
            Thank you. I will go for cleaning costs and will live in hope that the adjudicators may allow me something.
            07-07-2020, 10:07 AM
          • Deposit Issue
            by tenantputney
            Q1 – Where is the rented property located (England / Wales / Scotland / N Ireland)? England

            Q2 – What type of Tenancy Agreement (TA) is this e.g. sole tenant / multiple tenant / room only? Multiple Tenant

            Q3 – What date did current TA start dd/mm/yy? July 2017

            ...
            23-06-2020, 12:20 PM
          • Reply to Suing the Guarantor (small claims court)
            by jpkeates
            You need to sue both of them, or just the tenant.
            If you sue the guarantor, they have a simple defence, in that you haven't exhausted your attempts to recover the money from the tenant.
            07-07-2020, 09:23 AM
          • Suing the Guarantor (small claims court)
            by hadiolar
            Good morning,
            Hope I can get some clarity to my issue
            Background
            Tenant left in April 2020 with monies owed (Court eviction active)
            outstanding rent-£8000
            damage to Ppty-£3000
            letter before action sent to both tenant and guarantor -No response and no payment made...
            07-07-2020, 08:03 AM
          • Reply to Suing the Guarantor (small claims court)
            by ash72
            Which form are you using, you should be using the N1 form, or do it online, the max. you can claim in small £10k.

            Success depends on your claim and how much supporting evidence you. Does the guarantor own a property? If so, I would be inclined to go for them, there is much more success...
            07-07-2020, 09:07 AM
          • Reply to small claim court
            by islandgirl
            I had a similar one - had a (non rent) business debt, did money claim online, person admitted debt and offered a stupid £5 a week which I refused. Had a physical hearing and was awarded the full amount. He did not pay - I put a charge on his house (he was a home owner) and went down the High Court...
            07-07-2020, 08:54 AM
          • small claim court
            by Uklondoner
            My tenant owes me rent. I read about this small amount claim court. Anyone here has made such claim and successfully got money back ? Thanks for your attention....
            06-07-2020, 21:05 PM
          • Reply to small claim court
            by Uklondoner
            Thanks for sharing your experience. How long did it take to get the CCJ?...
            07-07-2020, 08:49 AM
          Working...
          X