Should my deposit have been protected?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Should my deposit have been protected?


    I have a bit of a complicated situation. I am subletting a room from a mesne tenant that rented the whole property.

    We signed an Assured Shorthold Tenancy Agreement which I now understand is unusual as the mesne tenant has also been living in the property and ASTs are usually in place for exclusive use of the whole property. I believe this was a simple mistake on her part.

    In the contract it states "If there is a dispute about the Deposit at the end of the Tenancy, either the Landlord or the Tenant may refer the matter to the Tenancy Deposit Scheme for adjudication once 10 calendar days have passed.". This leads me to assume that as per the terms of our contract she should have registered my deposit with the DPS.

    I am certain that she has not done so. I am concerned that the mesne tenant does not plan on repaying my deposit as she will be leaving the country before the tenancy ends and therefore I will not have any recourse.

    My question is - what are the ramifications of withholding my last month's rent as protection for my deposit? And, considering this was in fact a sublet in spite of signing an AST, was the mesne tenant still legally required to protect my deposit?

    Any help greatly appreciated.

    Thank you,


    Hmm. If your landlord came here asking about their lodger who was not paying the last month's rent, I might advise him to pack his bags while he is out and leave them outside.
    To save them chiming in, JPKeates, Theartfullodger, Boletus, Mindthegap, Macromia, Holy Cow & Ted.E.Bear think the opposite of me on almost every subject.


      I thought it was illegal to evict someone without serving notice and also I am not legally considered a lodger but a subtenant? My contract would make it seem that I sublet the entire property and not just a room.

      Also, should my deposit have been protected?


        You can't have an AST if you share the property with the landlord (you need exclusive possession of something). If you have exclusive possession of the room, with access to shared facilities and other rooms, you may still have an AST for the room.

        Unless the tenancy agreement says that the deposit will be protected, the landlord isn't in breach. They would be if they have committed to use a dispute resolution process that isn't going to be possible, but you can't sue for a potential future breach.

        Have you discussed your concerns about the deposit with the landlord?
        When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
        Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


          Hi jpkeates,

          Thank you for your reply. That makes sense, thank you. In my agreement it states that it is an Assured Shorthold Tenancy so I assume it just applies to the room with shared spaces and also says "If there is a dispute about the Deposit at the end of the Tenancy, either the Landlord or the Tenant may refer the matter to the Tenancy Deposit Scheme for adjudication once 10 calendar days have passed.". For me that means she has committed to use a DPS. I also verbally requested one at the beginning of the contract. Does this mean she is in breach?

          I have spoken with the landlord about it but she is just very relaxed. Said that she will pay me my part once she has received the full sum from the head tenant. She will have left the country by that point and I feel like I have no recourse even though my deposit should have been protected. I am just worried as in 3 out of the 4 last places I have rented, I have had my deposit taken by the landlord and I am just trying to protect myself against a repeat.

          Thanks for all explanations in any case.


            What do you mean by 'mesne Tenant'?

            It would appear this person is your LL & if living in the same building you are her lodger; no deposit needs protection, no eviction Notice required and she could exclude you from the property at any time (normally 1 rental period).
            It is not unusual for a resident LL to confuse AST for a lodger Agreement. Sounds like she has copied some of her AST for your doc. Just because your doc says it is an AST does not make it so.
            If concerned about your status, talk to her first.

            She may be illegally sub-letting.


              Hi Mariner,

              Thanks for your help. I think she is illegally subletting. By mesne tenant I mean that she let the flat from the head landlord and sublet to me and one other. So even though we signed a document in which she said that deposit dispute resolution would be with the DPS, this isn't true and I have no recourse?

              Sorry for so many questions, I just want to understand the position I am in.

              Thank you!


                It sounds as though you are a lodger and not a tenant and they are most likely illegally subletting.

                Have you any contact details for the original landlord to confirm?

                What notice has been served and by whom?. I'd be inclined to withhold the rent to ensure your deposit is returned also.

                If they are renting without permission then they are unlikely to make a claim against you!


                  If she is leaving the country permanently then she may not care whether the superior landlord finds out about the sub-letting. I couldn't advise you to without rent as its a serious breach of contract but in the circumstances you've described, I would probably do the same.


                  Latest Activity


                  • Reply to Gas Central Heating Included in Rent
                    by Hudson01
                    Given you have an idea of what Kwh's were used before, and if you look at any national news channel there are many predictions on what it will be in April 2023, i would do as suggested above, increase it once, but make it BIG ....... They are looking at an average CAP of £4500-£5000 after the April...
                    14-08-2022, 17:27 PM
                  • Gas Central Heating Included in Rent
                    by patray
                    I am trying to work out the best way to recoup some of the increase in the cost of the gas given that we can only put up the rent once a year but the cost is going to be increased in October and probably every 3 months.

                    It's not possible to forsee how much prices will rise or what help...
                    14-08-2022, 14:03 PM
                  • Reply to Future Issues for LL and Tenants
                    by Hudson01
                    Totally agree..... but has anyone told the govt or the developers who still appear to be fitting no solar panels on their new builds...... no heat pumps...... no rain water retention systems...... i could go on but you get the idea, we are useless as a country at preparing for the future, the future...
                    14-08-2022, 17:20 PM
                  • Future Issues for LL and Tenants
                    by Hudson01
                    Looking at the news today (similar to yesterday and the day before), they are talking about combined energy bills of 4-5k a year...... by April 2023. There are many properties up north where the combined rental per annum is between 6-7k....... that is insane.

                    Could we have a situation...
                    13-08-2022, 22:08 PM
                  • Reply to Future Issues for LL and Tenants
                    by SouthernDave
                    Air con and solar panels is the only viable option I can see going forward.
                    14-08-2022, 16:04 PM
                  • Reply to Gas Central Heating Included in Rent
                    by Neelix
                    If the gas is included in the agreement, what makes you think you pass this on to tenants ?
                    14-08-2022, 15:59 PM
                  • Reply to Future Issues for LL and Tenants
                    by ash72
                    I can see more problem on the horizon...... The more we insulate our homes the better they are in keeping the heat in, the problem as we all can feel during the last month is the relentless heat which then is trapped inside the home and it's cooler outside then inside.

                    - We removed wooden...
                    14-08-2022, 15:53 PM
                  • Reply to Gas Central Heating Included in Rent
                    by ash72
                    You should fix the tariff if you believe the prices are going to increase every 3 months, then you would have locked in the rate for the next 12 - 18 months, it's only then on the consumption of the utility. Are the flats legally converted if not then it's most likely a HMO property.

                    14-08-2022, 15:43 PM
                  • Reply to Gas Central Heating Included in Rent
                    by theartfullodger
                    You are able to propose as many increases as you like as often as you like. If tenant ( stupidity..) agrees and starts paying then that's agreed. If not, stuffed.

                    However you may only attempt to enforce an increase one a year ("section 13 notice ") and tenant is, quite rightly,...
                    14-08-2022, 15:18 PM
                  • Reply to Gas Central Heating Included in Rent
                    by DPT57
                    No it doesn't seem workable. Even if they agree, they could change their mind about further in-year increases. You should probably just increase the rent as a one-off by a fixed amount that both of you can live with, but neither are totally happy with.
                    14-08-2022, 14:48 PM