My upstairs neighbour cut power cable, who is liable for the cost?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    My upstairs neighbour cut power cable, who is liable for the cost?

    Hi all, I'm a newbie landlord and own a ground floor flat. My tenant has already called me to say she has no power in the living room...So I took time off work and check wall switch/light fixture etc. Nothing. No power source found so I called my electrician at a cost of £55 call out and he found that my cable was actually cut by someone who lives above me

    So I called my upstairs neighbour and he said his electrician did the rewiring recently, and that he only cut wires underneath his floor on "his side" and that my cable shouldn't be on "his side". In his analysis, the floor is made up of:

    His Floor/void
    Concrete separating layer
    My Ceiling/void

    My neighbour said one of my wire has been drilled through the concrete separating layer and channeled along his floor. So my neighbour's electrician arrived and had a look and said "yes, I cut that wire", and then reconnected the cut wire so my tenant now have power. I then asked my neighbour to pay me £55 for my electrician ti come and take a look.

    BUT...my neighbour said it is my responsibility that "my" cables are routed on "my side" so this wan't his fault, meaning he won't pay the £55 for my electrician to come out. In fact, he said I should pay the £55 AND the new/additional cost of HIS electrician to come out etc.

    Questions

    1 - Does anyone know who should pay for the £55 it cost me to get an electrician to come out?

    2 - The electrician simply reconnected the cut wire using a connecting block, but my electrician said I should really have this fixed properly, meaning a whole new cable from the wall switch to the light fixture and never via a connecting block (as it is more prone to failure).

    #2
    I agree with the neighbour - you shouldn't have wiring running in his property.
    And the connecting block is a risk.
    When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
    Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by jpkeates View Post
      I agree with the neighbour - you shouldn't have wiring running in his property.
      +1 - if indeed there's a discrete dividing concrete layer as described. (I've lived in old properties though where under the floorboards it's not at all clear whose wires are whose...)

      Lucky the electrician didn't get a belt from cutting the live wire, after having switched off the power to the upstairs flat... I wonder if the OP would have been liable if he had?

      And the connecting block is a risk.
      Well, in a ideal world but I wouldn't be losing too much sleep over it, especially if the alternative is hacking a new channel out of the wall. There are plenty of junction boxes in my house!

      Comment


        #4
        Thanks, I haven't done any electrical work on the flat and I bought the flat 11 years ago like it is so I didn't know how the cable was channeled etc.
        Do you know of any law that specifically states the boundary responsibility?

        So on a similar line, if I dug up garden and hit my neighbour's mains, it's not my problem?

        Comment


          #5
          Contact your property insurers and let them sort out liability.
          Neighbour is resp for his electrician fee if he called him out.
          £55 storm in a teacup IMO

          Comment

          Latest Activity

          Collapse

          • Reply to Part furnished
            by Chester Perry
            I posted elsewhere on here and feedback was a mix of its not worth it as nothing will happen (plus police will treat as a tenancy issue) and its worth doing to get a crime number.

            Not going to claim on insurance given excess etc. The fridge freezers value second hand / age considered probably...
            18-09-2020, 14:22 PM
          • Part furnished
            by Chester Perry
            Our property was let part furnished however upon leaving the Ex. tenant took it upon himself to relieve us of the white goods and wooden blinds.

            The dishwasher, washing machine, 2 x fridge freezers and wooden blinds throughout were actually ones purchased when the property was our main...
            18-09-2020, 13:34 PM
          • Reply to Landlord refuses to sign inventory
            by jpkeates
            A 15 year old washing machine has almost zero value (and will have less when you move out).
            The landlord can only legitimately claim for their loss if you bin it.

            A mid range washing machine is about £350 (and they haven't changed much in price recently), and imagining one would...
            18-09-2020, 14:14 PM
          • Landlord refuses to sign inventory
            by Bumblebee3000
            We've recently rented a house that from the very start seemed badly taken care of - there were various problems like a mouldy washing machine/curtains, broken curtain rails, etc. When we arrived to meet the inventory clerk, we signed a 2-page document of handwritten inventory notes (we broadly agreed...
            17-09-2020, 20:13 PM
          • Reply to Part furnished
            by theartfullodger
            Trust you've reported the thefts to police
            18-09-2020, 14:07 PM
          • Reply to Landlord refuses to sign inventory
            by Bumblebee3000
            This is very helpful, MdeB, thank you. I will try to relax about the inventory now. In regards to the mould - the landlord has a letter from the curtain cleaning company stating that the mould has been "killed" during the cleaning. I actually spoke with the curtain cleaner when he was here...
            18-09-2020, 14:07 PM
          • Reply to Deposit Negotitations with Landlord
            by jpkeates
            The process seems to have changed recently.
            The landlord claims from the deposit and that claim should have a summary of what they are claiming and why.
            You dispute that and then you both have one chance to explain your side of the story.
            But you do that with only access to what the...
            18-09-2020, 13:57 PM
          • Deposit Negotitations with Landlord
            by Maymiss
            I am moving out of my rented home shortly, i have caused some damage which I notified the landlord of when it happened and they have recently visited to discuss the cost of repairs, which we have agreed. The landlord is now asking that I pay this money to them directly. It is not possible for the work...
            03-08-2020, 11:47 AM
          • Reply to Section 21 issued with new tenancy
            by jpkeates
            Every notice escalated to court is recorded and the figures published quarterly, so breaking out the s21 notices from the s8 shouldn't be complicated.

            Two of the links are to House of Commons research papers, to be fair!...
            18-09-2020, 13:51 PM
          • Section 21 issued with new tenancy
            by fmST1
            When a new tenant moves into a property, I get them to sign a section 21 so that if whatever reason things don’t work out, the necessary paperwork is already in place.
            I’ve never had a need to exercise this yet, but would it work?...
            11-09-2020, 08:43 AM
          Working...
          X