Onus of proof for tenancy start date prior to Automatic Assured Shorthold Tenancies

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Onus of proof for tenancy start date prior to Automatic Assured Shorthold Tenancies

    I am aware the law changed in Feb 1997 to bring in ASTs. I moved into my tenancy circa that date, I believe couple months prior to but I have no proof. Never been any tenancy agreement. For certain reasons I think Landlord probably unlikely to have record of when I moved in or have a clue how long I've been there.

    Check of electoral register doesn't proof I was or wasn't there upon that date. Landlord has indicated he would like to sell now with vacant possession (I offered to buy but he wants price considerably above market value). He has not issued Notice to Quit yet. I would argue that I am an assured tenant. In that case Landlord shouldn't have any grounds for eviction as I have been model tenant throughout. Question therefore is the Judge likely to declare me an AST due to me not having proof of start date or would it be down to the landlord to prove I wasn't there prior to the law change? Does anyone know of any cases that have dealt with this issue?

    I hope to be able to move out within a year anyway once I have saved up enough to buy and made arrangements for relocating my business etc. I'd rather not have to move in the interim as it would be highly difficult and distruptive for me to do so for various reasons. I thought of mentioning to him that I'll plan be gone within a year but I am reluctant to do so as I am concerned that if he wants possession sooner then that might alert him to the fact that I haven't got proof of when I moved in and thus give him confidence to initiate the eviction process (and he might not believe I plan to move out). What would you advise?

    Also should mention just in case relevant, landlord has never done things like gas safety checks (not a single one I had to pay a plumber myself to do it) and requests for repairs have always been fobbed off thus I have ended up maintaining the property pretty much myself as best I could throughout the tenancy. This is also why I wouldn't want to stay in the longer term as the upkeep is getting too much for me and finding I am spending too much time on maintenance tasks dealing with damp etc when time would have been better spent working on my business! (Of course I never pushed for repairs to be done for fear of eviction seems as I didn't have proof of moving in date).



      Think you need to keep finding evidence - maybe bank account addresses, utility bills, letters you may have written to others, friends testament etc etc etc.

      Neighbours? Work records? BT account? Anything.

      Landlord can sell - your tenancy stays same just a new landlord.

      Landlord would need to issue s21 that you would challenge - either get a specialist landlord/tenant solicitor or call Shelter 0808 800 4444.

      S21 needs at least 2 months so no rush.

      Keep finding that evidence! Some landlords might lie in such circumstances....

      I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


        Thanks. The problem is I watched one of those reality programmes about hoarders a couple of years ago and unfortunately that 'inspired' me to clear out years worth of the old paperwork I had been 'hoarding' up in the attic! So little paperwork remains, I can get close to the date, about a year too late though! Might possibly be able to get the ex who lived here with me for the first year to sign something to say when he thinks we moved in. Wasn't working way back then, benefits etc in his name at the time, so that makes it difficult getting proof from authorities.

        I think that its most likely to come down to landlord saying I moved in after and me saying I moved in before that date. In which case will the judge rule for me or him, which one of us is supposed to prove when I moved in? Or is it just down to the judge's discretion who he believes/feels sympathy for? I did go and ask a solicitor recently but she couldn't tell me what the likely outcome would likely to be.

        I wouldn't mind having another landlord, I am sure it would be an improvement! But current landlord obviously wants to get as much from the sale as he can.


        Latest Activity


        • Reply to Flat rental bathroom query
          by Landyman
          Are you saying that the toilet and basin are out in the open, adjacent to the kitchen? Or are they in a separate room?

          Does the room have a window? Or a fan ventilator?

          It's had to visualise exactly what you mean. Could you sketch a simple floorplan and upload that here p...
          16-01-2022, 23:47 PM
        • Flat rental bathroom query
          by NewGuyOne

          A rented flat with a toilet (of course) and basin next to the kitchen, and a bedroom with a quite small en suite - shower/basin/rail for towel ... Is this acceptable in a flat - with no additional separate bathroom?

          Flat consists of 1 bedroom en suite, hallway, lounge,...
          16-01-2022, 20:13 PM
        • Reply to Problems with tenant getting work done and not paying me rent
          by axil23
          Thank you Lawcruncher.

          Just so I am not reading the lease wrong. Executed as a deed means that it has to say that and be witnessed by a 3rd party right?...
          16-01-2022, 23:23 PM
        • Problems with tenant getting work done and not paying me rent
          by axil23
          I have rented my house to a {name removed} who use it to house Asylum seekers from a govt contract. In June the flat roof developed a leak and they asked me to fix it which I did the next day. 6 months later I get a bill for £1900 for scaffolding, asbestos survey, party wall agreement & for some...
          13-01-2022, 12:05 PM
        • surrender of lease charges
          by jshire
          I'm trying to assist a family member who is in the process of surrendering a lease on a shared flat (all tenants moving out). The landlord agreed as the reasons were reasonable. He's sent an email stating that there will be costs that the tenants have to meet, charged by the letting agent...
          16-01-2022, 20:49 PM
        • Reply to Gas certificate fail
          by MdeB
          But if you had a valid certificate when the tenancy started but failed to give it to the tenant, then I believe that providing them with a current certificate before serving S21 will be OK....
          16-01-2022, 20:30 PM
        • Gas certificate fail
          by ReginaPhalangi
          We've been renting out our property since 2017 and now have given notice to our tenants to leave. However we have just realised that we have failed to get a gas certificate during their tenancy. Is it possible to get the gas certificate now? Would we need to give notice again after we issue the gas...
          15-01-2022, 20:05 PM
        • Reply to No Tenancy agreement
          by MdeB
          There are a number (of the order of 20) of grounds under which possession can be sought. See the Housing Act 1988.

          The claim is for the period for which they were paying rent whilst there was no required licence in place, up to a maximum of 12 months. Getting a licence ends...
          16-01-2022, 19:32 PM
        • Reply to No Tenancy agreement
          by MdeB
          That depends on when the tenancy started.

          Or, possibly, the one in place when it is given to the tenant. The regulations are ambiguous...
          16-01-2022, 19:18 PM
        • Reply to Wales: New Legislation – your roles and responsibilities
          by steaming
          4. Antisocial behaviour…..a fair and consistent approach to everyone. No. 4 is then not mentioned in the extended information (click link). Surely this needs explaining in detail or, maybe, they haven’t actually thought further that the nine words used. No surprise.
          16-01-2022, 19:17 PM