Custodial Scheme - deductions during tenancy, not at end.

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Custodial Scheme - deductions during tenancy, not at end.

    A hypothetical [almost, anyway] question:

    Tenant moves into house. Deposit is lodged with the custodial scheme [1].

    Tenant blocks the drains up by pouring fat down the sink. Landlord sends contractor out, who clears the drains. The landlord pays the contractor and tells the tenant that if it happens again they will pay for it.

    The tenant again blocks the drains and the contractor goes out again. This time the tenant is told to pay for it. Tenant does not have the money to and is happy for it to be taken out of the deposit. Landlord would normally deduct the money from the deposit, however now the money is lodged with the custodial scheme.

    Does the landlord instruct the tenant deposit scheme to return part of the money to him? Would the custodial scheme allow for this given that the tenancy has not ended?

    We run into this scenario fairly frequently and wonder how this would work with the new arrangments.

    [1] Providing it starts on time!
    Liability statement. My liability to you is not to exceed the amount you are paying for my recommendations or advice.

    I see a bright new future, where chickens can cross the road with no fear of having their motives questioned

    My gut reaction would be that you would have to wait and get it from the deposit at the end of the tenancy; perhaps get written conformation that this is ok with tenant.
    All posts in good faith, but do not rely on them

    * * * * * ** * * * * * * * * * * * *

    You can search the forums here:


      Originally posted by Bel View Post
      My gut reaction would be that you would have to wait and get it from the deposit at the end of the tenancy; perhaps get written conformation that this is ok with tenant.
      Or T could authorise reclaim from deposit even earlier, I guess- but then deposit is depleted and perhaps insufficient re further arrears/breakages/etc.
      JEFFREY SHAW, solicitor [and Topic Expert], Nether Edge Law*
      1. Public advice is believed accurate, but I accept no legal responsibility except to direct-paying private clients.
      2. Telephone advice: see
      3. For paid advice about conveyancing/leaseholds/L&T, contact me* and become a private client.
      4. *- Contact info: click on my name (blue-highlight link).


        why not tell the tenant its their fault the blockage was caused therefore they have to instruct a contractor and that way they have to pay the bill?


          Or tenants do £1000 worth of damage, dispute it, the agent has someone moving in a few days time, the money is has to come from you the L/Lord...the Agent has sent the disputed money off to the ICE man and no agent is going to use his/her pot to repair said property..(if there are ARLA) they apparently are not allowed to under thier accountancy procedures ( we may have a situation now where the agent may withold the last months rent from the L/Lord knowing if they ask him/her for money they are going to lose the property to a non-ARLA agent.....what a mess this new law is

          (according to Shelter and Govs website) only 17% of people have had complaints about wrongfully witholding tenants deposits. I wonder what percentage of people complain if they get a parking ticket even if it was deserved..
          "Better an empty property than a tenant without a guarantor"


          Latest Activity


          • Tenant has disappeared and left all belongings
            Hello all, I am new to the forum and looking for some advice or help if anyone has been in a similar situation.

            My tenants paid 1/2 of November's rent and told us they were going away for Christmas. They didn't pay December's rent nor January so are two months in arrears. We have tried...
            17-01-2018, 11:06 AM
          • Reply to Tenant has disappeared and left all belongings
            Well it does kind of matter because I am already out of pocket, have to find the money to pay for the rent while the court process is going through as well as the refurb of the house and only have enough money in that account to cover 3 months of rent due to having to pay self assessment recently. And...
            18-01-2018, 08:36 AM
          • Damage caused during DV
            Hope that this is allowed here as it’s a very tricky subject and not one that’s on the internet already.

            I’ve been renting a house through an agency for just over a year now, I have never met the landlord. When I first moved in it was the middle of November and the boiler was broken....
            17-01-2018, 20:35 PM
          • Reply to Damage caused during DV
            I sympathise with the tenant BUT its their responsibility, I would ask why move in to a property when it was in such poor condition, no boiler,, crap in the garden etc, but I also recognise some people don't have a lot of options,

            to be fair to the tenant, she does accept responsibility...
            18-01-2018, 08:04 AM
          • Contingency Fund Query
            Letting Go
            Have been letting a flat for nearly 30 years. Many years ago we owners bought the leasehold of the block. We’ve been through many managing agents over that time and have been with the present ones for several years now. The service charge has remained fairly constant for a few years, but this January...
            18-01-2018, 07:36 AM
          • Reply to Contingency Fund Query
            Letting Go
            Thanks for this. I’ll speak to the other owners and contact the agent armed with these questions.

            I am definitely considering the option of selling (bearing in mind capital gains tax implications). I guess it sounds selfish, but if I do sell I’m not really going to be bothered about...
            18-01-2018, 07:54 AM
          • Whos responsible for slow draining bathroom sink and black grout? Landlord or Tenant?

            I was wondering if anybody could help me and tell me who could be responsible Landlord or Tenant?

            One of my properties, the tenant has been in there about 2 years and normally has always called me direct for any little problem.

            I then went through months where...
            Black Grout they want me to get redone...
            17-01-2018, 21:53 PM
          • Reply to Whos responsible for slow draining bathroom sink and black grout? Landlord or Tenant?
            the discoloured silicone might be down to lack of cleaning by the tenant. a build up over time of dirty water/soap/shower gel etc could be the cause - you should try cleaning it first/bleach etc - not too strong though

            showing them how to clean properly is the best solution, but expect...
            18-01-2018, 07:51 AM
          • Reply to Contingency Fund Query
            why do you need roof works? I assume its a flat roof? as for the agent. if you all 'own' the freehold having bought it some years ago, then you all have a say in how the service and repair charges are arrived at.

            planning for roof work 12 years in advance seems sensible, though are they...
            18-01-2018, 07:45 AM
          • service charge
            I am now living in a one bed flat owned by a housing association, for the past year the communal boilers that provide hot water and heating to all flats and the sheltered housing block has been frequently faulty leaving us without hot water or heating.

            So the HA have replaced the boilers...
            15-01-2018, 21:26 PM