Broken fridge - Landlord or tenant responsible for removing?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Originally posted by thesaint View Post
    I shall leave the discussion, as it is going nowhere at the moment.
    Please feel free to return with actual elements to back up your opinion...


      Fridges have to be 'safely' disposed of. If tenant were to dump it in a near-by back alley, I wonder if the owner of the fridge may suffer consequences if he hadn't ensured it was safely disposed of?

      IMHO replacement (including the removal element) is not covered by tenancy law but is instead covered by contract law. Therefore, if the deal was for a house with a working fridge then failing to supply the fridge on an ongoing basis is a breach of contract.

      Can't wait for thesaint to follow Westminsters lead & become a Magistrate


        This is Phlash last month:

        There is no statutory requirement but there is an implied contract term if the fridge freezer is in the inventory and if it is in the AST then there is an express term of contract.

        Why you would want to argue about this with a tenant is beyond me. Good luck to any landlord who wishes to take this kind of short narrow view.

        'In my view', if it's broken from wear and tear and it was provided by the landlord then the landlord should replace without quarrel. If one of my landlords refused, I'd ask the landlord to leave my management - Whether supported by statutory requirements or not, I will not work with someone who can't come to that kind of simple conclusion.

        If the tenant took the property on the proviso that if the fridge broke down then it won't be being replaced, then game on.

        I believe some things shouldn't need to be written in statute, they should just be what a reasonable person may conclude. That's how we manage our property, and I'm sure many may disagree, but we get great results.

        Personally, if I don't want to be responsible for replacing it and there happens to be one I make giving it to the T part of the covering letter with the contract.

        Refer Mad Regulators to Arkell vs Pressdram.


          ML, does that not expose you to problems with The Electrical Equipment (Safety) Regulations 1994? The legislation covers 'supply', not 'sale', so giving away would still be covered.


            I've read that before regarding an 'implied term' regarding repairs.
            However I was never provided sources to back that claim.

            As mentioned above my understanding is that at there is no obligation to repair unless expressly stated in contract, but there is an obligation to replace if beyond repair.


            Latest Activity


            • Reply to New landlord needs some advice
              by DPT57
              She wouldn't be able to rent it straight away anyway if you carry out referencing, (which you should), as this takes a few days. I get people to complete an application form too. A lot of prospective tenants are flaky on OR. Some promise to call you and you never hear from them again, even if you try...
              13-05-2021, 17:38 PM
            • New landlord needs some advice
              by wenqi
              Hi, I am just a new landlord who is renting our first property using openrent. I do need some advice from you.

              We had a very lovely lady to view our house. She looked love our property and wanted to take it straight away. Because she came alone (her partner was working), my husband advised...
              12-05-2021, 19:56 PM
            • Reply to 'Replacement tenancy' issue
              by berliner
              "If the new tenancy is for a lesser rent, the tenant will remain liable to pay an amount equal to the difference between the original rent and new lower rental figure up to the end of the original fixed term."

              I read in a similar post that such a clause might not be enforceab...
              13-05-2021, 17:38 PM
            • 'Replacement tenancy' issue
              by berliner
              Good afternoon and thanks for taking the time to read my post.

              Back in October, I found replacement tenants to take over my joint AST (without break clause) which would have run until this July. Because of Covid, I could only find someone who was willing to pay about Ā£400 pcm less than...
              13-05-2021, 17:22 PM
            • Reply to 'Replacement tenancy' issue
              by ash72
              What was the wording on the legally binding contract you initially signed, this will state exactly what your position is, I would state you are still required to pay the shortfall, as you are still jointly responsible for the rent, it would be the same thing for a guarantor they would be liable. I would...
              13-05-2021, 17:32 PM
            • Reply to Early change of Landlord
              by islandgirl
              Indeed thank you. I don't think the agency is to blame but the owners have ducked out of their fully managed service (presumably to save money). No idea what is going on behind the scenes re the contract between the agency and the landlord! Anyway the agency are not doing things correctly and we have...
              13-05-2021, 17:27 PM
            • Early change of Landlord
              by islandgirl
              Would be grateful for thoughts on this. Daughter signed student tenancy for next academic year on Monday this week. LL shown as an individual with the same name as the letting agency. Yesterday she was told that the LL wishes to self manage and to change her standing order payment to an investment company...
              13-05-2021, 09:52 AM
            • Smoking tenant
              by renting25
              Please can you offer us advice as to whether there is any action that can be taken to stop a very serious situation of anti social behaviour.My wife and myself own 2 maisonettes a upstairs owned by me that we both live in and a downstairs that is owned by my wife and she has rented the property out...
              13-05-2021, 17:17 PM
            • Reply to You think your tenant is bad?
              by jpucng62
     are saints, LLs are sinners. I read it on Shelter's website so it must be true!
              13-05-2021, 17:04 PM
            • You think your tenant is bad?
              by KTC
              Ex-tenant on the run after being convicted in absence for attempting to frame his landlord as a terrorist

              13-05-2021, 09:29 AM