Unprotected deposit dilema

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Unprotected deposit dilema

    Any advice appreciated

    I have an old deposit that I did not protect and I am in discussion with the tenant over the refund of it. I have calculated deductions which are mainly in the form of shared cleaning and maintenance costs. I have already waived the cost of redecorating the tenant's room due to wallpaper and blu tac damage, but the tenant is insisting on a full refund of the deposit. All the other tenants have agreed to the deductions which are very fair in my view.

    I have a number of options as I see it:

    1. refund the deposit in full
    2. continue to debate the deductions and repay what I think is fair, with the chance that legal action could be taken for the difference.
    3. Instruct the tenant to accept my, or start legal proceedings.

    If I repay in full, can the tenant still issue legal proceeding, if so what are the chances a court will find in a tenants favour?

    Should the repaid amount continue to be disputed and legal proceedings started, what is my position even if I have an inventory check-out video and signed check-in inventory to support my claim for landlord costs.

    The deposit is £300 of which I am claiming about £150 (over 3 years).

    Thanks for you help

    If the tenancy is in England/Wales, and started after April 2007, or was renewed at any time since then, the deposit must be protected.

    If you fail to do this, your tenant can apply to court for the WHOLE amount back, plus start a claim for 1-3x the deposit value as penalty for your failure to observe the protection rules.

    By failing to protect, you have effectively lost the right to retain any deductions, and by forcing the issue you may push the tenant into claiming the full amount plus penalty! Indeed, even if you pay the full deposit back now, tenant can still claim the 1-3x penalty afterwards, but obviously, you have shown willing to refund them, so this will look favourable on you if it did ever get the court.


      If you have not protected the deposit then my advice would be to refund the whole deposit. For the sake of £150 is it really worth the dispute with the tenant.

      The law will be on the tenants side because you have not protected the deposit when you should have. If the tenant does decide to take legal action the the judge is more than likely to fine you 3x the deposit 3x £300 (£900).

      If you pay the full deposit back then the tenant is happy, hence no legal challange.

      Therefore for sake of trying to save £150 is it really worth the liability of legal fees + potential £900 fine


        Ihe tenancy is in England/Wales and after 2007.

        If I repay the full deposit, is there any way I can protect myself from the tenant subsequently applying for a penalty?


          I would just pay the deposit back and not worry about it. The tenant is unlikely to proceed with any legal action as the chances of the tenant being able to claim anything would be slim if you paid the full deposit back!


            Thanks for the advice.

            It matches what I was thinking too. A lesson learned to say the least!


            Latest Activity


            • Reply to Section 21. When can a Landlord no longer use this?
              by Gillyann
              Thank you Hudson.

              I seem to have been a landlord for 100 years! I feel I have provided excellent and well maintained homes for 21 years and worked my way through the recession with much difficulty like everyone else and now is the time to retire. I’ll continue to put my tenants interests...
              16-05-2022, 00:03 AM
            • Section 21. When can a Landlord no longer use this?
              by Gillyann
              I've looked extensively over the internet, but I cannot find the actual date Section 21 is no longer viable.

              I have only 3 properties left, having sold 5 over the years, all with long term tenancies, and I now wish to sell them, mostly due to my husband's death in 2020 and I'm not exactly...
              11-05-2022, 14:13 PM
            • Reply to Outside car park lighting
              by DoricPixie
              What kind of contract do you have for the shared accomodation and what does it say about chargeable services?...
              15-05-2022, 22:53 PM
            • Outside car park lighting
              by Busman18
              Hi I am a resident in a shared accommodation block of 40 people and one of our car park lights is out of action
              our manager says this is service chargeable on our rent but we think the landlord should pay instead ,who is right please.
              15-05-2022, 22:42 PM
            • Reply to EDF - how is it possible to inform tenant has left?
              by DoricPixie
              You don’t to close down the tenant’s accounts you need to open your own accounts. I don’t have any experience with EDF but it did take me months to sort out an account with eon and I’m months into a complaint with Scottish Power. Make sure you have photos of the meter readings from when the...
              15-05-2022, 22:45 PM
            • EDF - how is it possible to inform tenant has left?
              by Flynn
              So my tenant moved out, and had debts, they have given me a false forwarding address. But that’s not my problem.

              Problem is that I need to close down their utility accounts, and set up new in my name while the property is empty.

              Should be a straightforward process?
              15-05-2022, 13:19 PM
            • Reply to Buying a tenanted residential property
              by DoricPixie
              If you’re worried about interest rates rising then clearly you are buying with a mortgage. Your mortgage lender will require the property to be vacant at completion which it won’t be if the tenants are still living there. The vendors solicitor would be crackers to allow his/her client to complete...
              15-05-2022, 22:40 PM
            • Buying a tenanted residential property
              by itsthomas
              We are buying a residential property to live in
              Now that everything is ready for exchange we are told that the tenant has decided not to move out.
              The tenancy agreement is already expired two months ago and she has stopped paying rent since.

              Now we would like to know what happens...
              12-05-2022, 19:37 PM
            • Reply to Advice Needed
              by ash72
              You should consider speaking with the case worker, they can sometimes help re-house someone without going through the stress of going to court etc. May be another option to explore.
              15-05-2022, 21:59 PM
            • Advice Needed
              by Confused2022

              I an trying to get as much information and advice for someone whom is very vulnerable and has many health problems.

              The issue is they have lived at a property which they’ve rented now for 2 years just over, never missed a rental payment and never had any issues,...
              15-05-2022, 15:45 PM