Tenant Re entered property using key after handing house back

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Tenant Re entered property using key after handing house back

    Hi,

    Need some advice urgently!

    Here's the background. Tenant gave notice owing arrears but had made some improvements, laminate floor and cheap kitchen, to house. We came to the agreement that the rent arrears of £625 would cover the cost of improvements and her deposit would be returned less 8 days rent (1-8 Oct)so long as everything was leftin place. This was verbal and in text messages.

    Following checkout yesterday, which she chose not to attend, some other issues became apparent, which are going to cost money and time to rectify. I called her this afternoon to discuss these issues and was accused of trying to wriggle out of returning the deposit. Not true.

    Anyway half an hour later my husband went to the house to do a little job and discovered that the tenant and her husband had entered the house using a key that they had kept hold of and had ripped up the floors and dismantled part of the kitchen.

    She claimed she was doing this because we had reneged on our agreement.

    Police attended and said that it wasn't illegal to enter the house after the end of the tenancy, using a key she had no right to have, because she was collecting items that belonged to her. Even though I have it in a text message that she agreed to leave these items to cover rent arrears.

    I find it incredulous and ludicrous that it's not against the law to do this.

    In order to get the kitchen units back my husband signed in the police officers log book that we agree to her receiving £400 from her deposit. We will get £325 which won't cover the cost of floors etc and other remedial work. So she has had £625 rent arrears and will get £400 back from deposit.

    Feel completely let down by the law! Haven't got a clue what to do next or if we can do anything.

    Please any suggestions :-(

    #2
    I believe the laminate flooring - once it is down - becomes a fixture. See this thread http://www.landlordzone.co.uk/forums...ghlight=blinds

    Can you clarify why you felt you had to compensate the tenant for the kitchen / flooring? What flooring was in the place when let, and do you have an inventory to show that?

    Comment


      #3
      Hi

      I felt that it was the right thing to do. Also wanted to avoid the situation we have ended up in. Police just kept saying it was a civil matter, landlord/tenant dispute.

      Carpets were down when she moved in and they were stored in loft by tenant, so they are still there but will have to be refitted.

      Feel so let down.

      Comment


        #4
        I feel your pain - been there, done favours, been **** on.

        Is the deposit in a government approved scheme?
        Did you have an inventory/condition report?

        Comment


          #5
          Yes deposit is in a scheme and we have inventory from check in.
          Just can't believe that this is legal.
          Gobsmacked!

          Comment


            #6
            I would suggest you apply to the scheme for the full deposit.
            The tenant will (presumably) dispute this.
            You will be given the option of using their arbitration service to decide what is fair. You are allowed to decline this. I would suggest you do and then you either sue for all the missing rent & provable damages (including carpet re-fitting) or (if the tenants beat you to the court), counterclaim for the same.
            The tenants will think their policemans statement will give them a watertight case - but I don't think it will if you can present the facts you have given here with proof of everything you have said.

            If the judge finds in your favour, you need to ask him to include an order to the deposit scheme to release the funds. If the tenant has no assets or employment I wouldn't put too much hope on getting more than the deposit off them. If they haven't got money, they can't pay, no matter what a judge orders.

            Comment


              #7
              Did Ts ask for your prior permission to take up carpet, install laminate and cheap kitchen? Next time don't offer to contribute to T's 'improvements', they rarely do a proper job.

              Comment


                #8
                This has left me feeling so disheartend that I'm not sure can face prospect of dealing with all the s**t that comes with being a LL again.

                Previous tenant did a flit owing £1200 in rent, now this one and all c**p she caused. They were both vetted by agent and passed their checks.

                She did ask to make changes, and verbally agreed that kitchen would stay and carpets be refitted if she tookthe floor. Clearly her word is worthless, learned to my cost. Been s**t on from a great height, shafted good and proper. Not only by tenant but by law too.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Just another quick question,

                  Under the original 6 month tenancy agreement signed in Oct 2008 she had a guarantor, is that guarantor still liable for unpaid rent?

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by walter01 View Post
                    Just another quick question,

                    Under the original 6 month tenancy agreement signed in Oct 2008 she had a guarantor, is that guarantor still liable for unpaid rent?
                    Yes, and kitchen repairs also, I would have thought. Was guarantee by way of a deed?

                    Have you changed the locks now?
                    To save them chiming in, JPKeates, Theartfullodger, Boletus, Mindthegap, Macromia, Holy Cow & Ted.E.Bear think the opposite of me on almost every subject.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Depends on the wording of the guarantee. What did it say about the duration?

                      And as JK0 says - was it witnessed and was it a deed?

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Haven't got a clue, it was organised by the agent. So will have to chase that up in the morning.

                        Thanks for all responses BTW. Maybe will all be clearer to me in the morning!

                        Comment


                          #13
                          What are the 'other issues' you referred to in your first post?

                          You admit that you and the tenant had an agreement which you then didn't stick to. It's difficult to have a great deal of sympathy for you as a result. Before making your bargain you had the ability to inspect the property and determine if there were any additional matters that should have been taken into account. However, without knowing exactly what was said between you and the tenant it's difficult to know what the precise terms of your deal were.

                          Even if the kitchen units were a fixture it doesn't meant the tenant has no right to be compensated for paying for them. I would urge you to think about how much they are worth in materials and labour (and therefore how much money you would effectively be getting in addition to the £325 you'll recover from the deposit) before you waste time and money going into a lengthy dispute process with the tenant.
                          Disclaimer:

                          The above represents my own opinion, derived from personal knowledge and should not be relied upon as definitive or accurate advice. It is offered free of charge and may contain errors or omissions or be an inaccurate opinion of the law. I accept no liability for any loss or damage suffered as a result of relying on the above.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Hi the other issues were
                            *she had half heartedly painted original 1930s doors which now need to be dipped
                            *removed and filled in the door keeps when she then removed the above doors and replaced with her own.
                            *on giving notice put the original doors back up, (I have no problem with this as they are better doors), however doors don't close properly now as the keep has been removed and filled in. Also these doors were previously lockable but can't be locked now.
                            *Left a huge clock shaped hole in the wallpaper were a clock was glue to wall.
                            *left house dirty- bathroom cupboards and drawers covered in razor hairs etc, thick dust on paintwork, food and drink stains on paintwork, chewed and spat out sweets on bedroom carpet.
                            Not to mention clearing the garden of established plants, breaking and not replacing glass in outhouse window, leaving behind matresses, bedframes and other junk.

                            Yes as you say I did have an agreement. The terms were exactly as stated in the original message. However, that agreement was also dependent on a satisfactory handover of the house, which she chose not to attend.

                            I find it incredulous that she is allowed to enter a house after her tenancy ended, with a key she shouldn't have and rip out fixtures that had been ofset against rent arrears.

                            Comment

                            Latest Activity

                            Collapse

                            • Reply to Flat rental bathroom query
                              by Landyman
                              Are you saying that the toilet and basin are out in the open, adjacent to the kitchen? Or are they in a separate room?

                              Does the room have a window? Or a fan ventilator?

                              It's had to visualise exactly what you mean. Could you sketch a simple floorplan and upload that here p...
                              16-01-2022, 23:47 PM
                            • Flat rental bathroom query
                              by NewGuyOne
                              Hello,

                              A rented flat with a toilet (of course) and basin next to the kitchen, and a bedroom with a quite small en suite - shower/basin/rail for towel ... Is this acceptable in a flat - with no additional separate bathroom?

                              Flat consists of 1 bedroom en suite, hallway, lounge,...
                              16-01-2022, 20:13 PM
                            • Reply to Problems with tenant getting work done and not paying me rent
                              by axil23
                              Thank you Lawcruncher.

                              Just so I am not reading the lease wrong. Executed as a deed means that it has to say that and be witnessed by a 3rd party right?...
                              16-01-2022, 23:23 PM
                            • Problems with tenant getting work done and not paying me rent
                              by axil23
                              I have rented my house to a {name removed} who use it to house Asylum seekers from a govt contract. In June the flat roof developed a leak and they asked me to fix it which I did the next day. 6 months later I get a bill for £1900 for scaffolding, asbestos survey, party wall agreement & for some...
                              13-01-2022, 12:05 PM
                            • surrender of lease charges
                              by jshire
                              Hi,
                              I'm trying to assist a family member who is in the process of surrendering a lease on a shared flat (all tenants moving out). The landlord agreed as the reasons were reasonable. He's sent an email stating that there will be costs that the tenants have to meet, charged by the letting agent...
                              16-01-2022, 20:49 PM
                            • Reply to Gas certificate fail
                              by MdeB
                              But if you had a valid certificate when the tenancy started but failed to give it to the tenant, then I believe that providing them with a current certificate before serving S21 will be OK....
                              16-01-2022, 20:30 PM
                            • Gas certificate fail
                              by ReginaPhalangi
                              We've been renting out our property since 2017 and now have given notice to our tenants to leave. However we have just realised that we have failed to get a gas certificate during their tenancy. Is it possible to get the gas certificate now? Would we need to give notice again after we issue the gas...
                              15-01-2022, 20:05 PM
                            • Reply to No Tenancy agreement
                              by MdeB
                              There are a number (of the order of 20) of grounds under which possession can be sought. See the Housing Act 1988.



                              The claim is for the period for which they were paying rent whilst there was no required licence in place, up to a maximum of 12 months. Getting a licence ends...
                              16-01-2022, 19:32 PM
                            • Reply to No Tenancy agreement
                              by MdeB
                              That depends on when the tenancy started.


                              Or, possibly, the one in place when it is given to the tenant. The regulations are ambiguous...
                              16-01-2022, 19:18 PM
                            • Reply to Wales: New Legislation – your roles and responsibilities
                              by steaming
                              4. Antisocial behaviour…..a fair and consistent approach to everyone. No. 4 is then not mentioned in the extended information (click link). Surely this needs explaining in detail or, maybe, they haven’t actually thought further that the nine words used. No surprise.
                              16-01-2022, 19:17 PM
                            Working...
                            X