contractual tenancy and deposit

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    contractual tenancy and deposit

    My previous tenants are disputing my withholding £1400 of their deposit for damages on a tenancy agreement of >25k. The contract states that the agent will hold the deposit but when commencing the contract I convinced the agent to let me (LL) hold the deposit.

    The tenants are disputing the damages, and I am now worried that they will take legal action - what can they do and what is my position? Have I breached any laws by holding the deposit?

    #2
    When did the tenancy start?
    Did you get it protected in a deposit scheme.
    Allow tenants to protect their own deposits. I want free money when they do it wrong

    Comment


      #3
      tenancy started in april 2009. I did not get it protected in a deposit scheme.

      Comment


        #4
        since the deposit was for a tenancy of more than 25000 pa. you did not have to put it in a deposit protection scheme.
        I offer no guarantee that anything I say is correct. wysiwyg

        Comment


          #5
          I don't see what law you could have breached by holding the deposit instead of the agent.
          Allow tenants to protect their own deposits. I want free money when they do it wrong

          Comment


            #6
            The tenants are disputing the damages, and I am now worried that they will take legal action - what can they do and what is my position?
            They can issue a county court claim for return of the deposit. It would be allocated to the small claims track, so you don't need a solicitor to defend yourself. The deposit is the tenant's money and you would have to provide evidence to prove a loss of £1,400, thereby entitling you to keep the tenant's money. Ideally, the evidence would include a check-in inventory report (signed by the tenant) and check-out, and receipts and/or quotes for the repairs. Without such evidence, you'd be likely to lose the claim.

            Assuming you could prove the damage, the court would also look at the reasonableness of the charges - for example, if you charged £500 for a repair which one would expect to cost £100, then you will probably not be awarded the full amount, even if you had a receipt for it.

            In addition, the tenant is not liable for fair wear and tear (the minor knocks, scratches etc which happen with everyday, non-negligent, use), and the landlord is not entitled to 'betterment'. An example of the latter would be charging the full replacement cost of a damaged, five year old fitted carpet. In this example, you would only be entitled to a portion of the replacement cost of a similar quality carpet, calculated on the expected lifespan of the carpet - if you'd expect it to have lasted 10 years, then you'd have lost five years of use, therefore you'd be entitled to roughly 50% of the replacement cost.

            Have I breached any laws by holding the deposit?
            No.

            Comment

            Latest Activity

            Collapse

            • Reply to Rent Rises in 2020
              by DPT57
              Well if the market rent for your properties has increased and you think that there would be a good prospect of re-letting quickly and there is a low risk that your existing tenant will stop paying rent altogether then from a business point of view, it makes sense to increase the rent. Having said that,...
              22-09-2020, 14:57 PM
            • Rent Rises in 2020
              by jpucng62
              I cancelled all my annual rent increases when Covid hit. Since then some people have really suffered financially and others haven’t. In addition LHA rates have increased substantially for anyone needing support which appears to have had the knock on effect of increasing the rent of properties now...
              19-09-2020, 17:48 PM
            • Reply to Rent Rises in 2020
              by jpucng62
              Where I rent properties (Beds / Northants / Nottingham) rents have risen substantially and availability has fallen. So my question is still, 6 months on from everyone being told to stay at home and with normality of work returning for many tenants (I accept not all) and many people not unduly financially...
              22-09-2020, 14:44 PM
            • Reply to Tenants possessions left in abandoned property
              by MR M
              I did consider approaching a Tracing Agent to try to obtain the Tenant's current whereabouts or updated information about them but the feeling is that it is not worth initiating this yet as its too soon. They may not show-up as having set-up elsewhere yet or have generated updated information about...
              22-09-2020, 14:10 PM
            • Tenants possessions left in abandoned property
              by MR M
              The tenancy is a statutory periodic tenancy after the original AST ended. The tenant has rent arrears and a S21 was issued around 3 months ago. There is no deposit and an EPC, gas safety certificate and how to rent guide were all issued previously to the tenant.

              I believe that the tenant...
              16-09-2020, 10:03 AM
            • Reply to Renovation/Improvements vs Repairs / Maintenance
              by newtenant9011
              You can prevent the landlord from entering, as you have a right to quiet enjoyment, you can even replace the locks if you would like.

              In turn, the landlord could issue you a section 21 notice, but the notice period is 6 months currently plus the court backlog.
              22-09-2020, 14:08 PM
            • Renovation/Improvements vs Repairs / Maintenance
              by thesleepingdog
              Hello,

              I am having A LOT of trouble with my LL who is continually asking to carry out improvements on the property. It is literally nonstop and it has got to the stage where I am utterly fed up and want to leave.

              During my tenancy he has replaced all the windows in the house,...
              22-09-2020, 13:22 PM
            • Reply to Rent Rises in 2020
              by DPT57
              In my part of London there is no market justification for rent increases and imo increased individual landlord costs is not a reason to raise them....
              22-09-2020, 14:07 PM
            • Reply to Rats
              by ChrisDennison
              These are very interesting comments, one of my councils (South West) told me they had to stop these services unless in public areas.
              22-09-2020, 12:35 PM
            • Rats
              by ETB
              I have a tenant who has reported that he can here rats in the walls and ceiling of his 4th floor apartment. He says there are other complaints on the tenants facebook group. I have messaged the maintenance company (Name removed) but they are not replying. Just wanted to check who is liable, I'm assuming...
              21-09-2020, 22:15 PM
            Working...
            X