LL refuses Surrender while flat is unfit?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    LL refuses Surrender while flat is unfit?

    We've had enough of years of problems with a flat and want out but the landlord is being awkward in our view. We want to negotiate surrender on the tenancy and offered 30 day's rent from today 9th Feb, but he is insisting we pay up until the end of March.

    Me and my partner have rented the flat for 3 1/2 years now. We started out on an ast through an EA on a managed let but have been on Statutory Periodic for some time as the EA was negligent. We're reasonably good tenants and never in arrears.

    There have been various problems over the years and we have been very patient, and tried to help the overseas landlord deal with these things. I have about a hundred pages of emails back and forth and I've felt quite exhausted by the whole affair at times, feeling like an unpaid LA-by-proxy!

    At the moment I consider the flat barely fit for habitation as an ongoing rat problem has gotten to the point where power cables are getting chewed through and we have endured rotting stink and flies several times. This problem can only be fixed by considerable work to underground pipes, once the council finally discover exactly where the problem is.

    I am not prepared to wait around any more for my abode to be repaired to the standard I have been paying for for so long. The fact that the LL flatly refuses to compromise is a kick in the teeth.

    Any advice? Can I get out without the standard notice due to the health & safety concerns? I wasn't going to claim compensation but maybe I should. If so, How?

    btw 1st post, hi!

    It seems to me you have a number of options.

    You could leave early and risk your landlord coming after you for the final chunk of rent, (you may reason that this is unlikely, since he is abroad, however, it is not impossible).

    Or you could put up with the rats and sit it out. (I wouldn't!)

    Or you could leave as planned, but pay the rent up to the end of the tenancy.

    Or...if you have not already contacted the Environmental Health Officer at your local council, you could do so immediately, and he could legally force your LL to get rid of the rats....however, if your tenancy agreement holds you responsible for the cost of any infestation control which might be necessary during the tenancy, then that might not work in your favour.

    What does you TA say about pest control, by the way?

    Plan E : email your LL advising him that the rat problem has got to the point where the house is a risk to health and safety (which, from what you have said, it sounds to be). Tell him that you will be moving out until he complies with his legal obligations under the Landlord and Tenant Act. Tell him that if necessary, the EHO will issue a statement relating to the property and will require him to comply with notice to effect repairs. This is often enough to make a LL see sense.

    Move out; pay no more rent, but put the money in a separate account so that you can demonstrate to a court if you need to, that you did not intend to default. Take photos of the property on the day you move out, showing the extent of the rat problem. Post the keys by recorded delivery to the LL's UK address. If he does not have one, he is breaking the law; notify him of that by email. If you rented the property through a letting agent, hand the keys in there instead and get a receipt. Handing in the keys is not in itself a guarantee that your LL will accept that the tenancy is over, but it's a sign you are serious.

    Please be aware that if you follow the above course of action, your LL may take you to court and you may end up paying for the pest control and the last rent payment, and his court costs.

    You may wish to consider getting legal advice at his point as to your chances of success and of getting compensation.

    Did your Ll take a tenancy deposit when you moved in?

    Good luck, whatever you decide.
    'Pause you who read this, and think for a moment of the long chain of iron or gold, of thorns or flowers, that would never have bound you, but for the formation fo the first link on one memorable day'. Charles Dickens, Great Expectations


      I dont think you mentioned if he has a deposit of yours.

      This is not advice...

      If I were you, from what I have read, my chosen option would be to gather as much evidence of the state of the place eg get an assessment from environmental health, document all the incidents etc

      Then I would leave at my convenience. If he holds a deposit that would become last months rent, so I would keep my rent money.

      Right a letter of your intention saying what laws he has broken and what parts of the tenancy agreement breached, what the EHO said, that you are due compensation of £X because of this; if he takes you to court to get full rent owed you will counter sue for compensation.

      You won't be able to rely on getting a reference from him for a future let though.
      All posts in good faith, but do not rely on them

      * * * * * ** * * * * * * * * * * * *

      You can search the forums here:


      Latest Activity


      • Reply to Stock Market - Yes or No ?
        by landlord-man
        Yes, they have a demo account where you can play with £75,000 ($100,000)

        I did put $10k into one copy on April 4th and its now on a profit of $4,915, so nearly 50% in just under 4 months.

        I guess as Im only playing, I should "invest" all the funds and see how they...
        24-07-2021, 13:28 PM
      • Stock Market - Yes or No ?
        by landlord-man
        I will post here but it may get moved - but at least it gets a bit of exposure to begin with lol

        I've used a platform called etoro for 2 or 3 years to hold shares in some cruise stocks (don't laugh) - mainly because we do 4 or 5 cruises a year and the shareholder benefits can be quite handy....
        24-07-2021, 09:50 AM
      • Reply to Very difficult tenant issues
        by landlord-man
        Has he paid the rent on June 15th and then again on July 15th?

        Sounds obvious but have you double checked you have done all the correct paperwork and deposit registration/certificate - triple check it !!

        Personally, going forward I would not liaise with the tenant in any way...
        24-07-2021, 13:19 PM
      • Very difficult tenant issues
        by Helvie
        I'm going to keep this short as its a long story. I have a tenant who signed the new tenancy contract on 15th June and then on 27th June I received about 20-25 messages and pictures the evening saying the flat was unliveable due to pests and that he had only moved in the night before. I went round to...
        24-07-2021, 12:46 PM
      • Reply to Changing Lease Clause to Permit Letting
        by Hudson01
        Even if you were my opinion would stay the same, i think that given it is a converted house the noise isolation and other issues are not the same as separate purpose built flats, so having one as a rental will have far more of an impact upon the other owners who live there. It really is a one way street...
        24-07-2021, 13:12 PM
      • Changing Lease Clause to Permit Letting
        by witsend55
        Not sure if this is the best section to post in, so please move if it is considered best place elsewhere.

        I have had ownership of a flat, one of just four in a converted house, for many years. There is a simple flat management structure; the four owners are directors and have one share...
        24-07-2021, 11:53 AM
      • Reply to No Fault Eviction
        by jpucng62
        This is not my understanding - perhaps others can clarify. I thought you had to give your usual notice if you were leaving before the end of the LLs notice period....
        24-07-2021, 13:09 PM
      • No Fault Eviction
        by Gdunwell
        Hi All, I have been living in the same house for 7 years and have just been served a form 6A giving 4 months notice to vacate. The owner is returning from overseas and wants to live in the house. Whilst disappointed I get that this is one of the perils of renting but it has raised a few questions. ...
        24-07-2021, 07:54 AM
      • Reply to Stock Market - Yes or No ?
        by doobrey
        Yes, there are some who seem to have fairly consistent positive performance over a period of years. I would be skeptical, though. Could be explained by them having holdings in a few companies (e.g. Amazon) which have done very well over that time(?) I would suspect survivorship bias.

        24-07-2021, 13:00 PM
      • Reply to Very difficult tenant issues
        by Hudson01
        I suspect he is a professional scammer, i do not believe anyone can be such a wimp as to be running scared over a few spiders etc, he may be doing this to simply be paid off to leave the tenancy etc. I would engage a solicitor given he will try all he can to get money out of you, offer to end the tenancy...
        24-07-2021, 12:55 PM