L charges admin. fee to avoid deposit protection

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    L charges admin. fee to avoid deposit protection

    Please excuse me if this has already been discussed and i've missed it...

    There is a growing number of landlords in this area taking 'admin fees' to avoid TDP schemes and leaving behind the 'why bother' it's concerning that the deposit protection could be making thigs worse for tenants.

    The 'admin fees' taken are anywhere from 300 - 600 and non returnable. There was, i'm told, a local solicitor who challenged a landlord about this in one case and it was ruled in the landlords favour in court as the tenant 'did not have to accept these charges and could have gone elsewhere' and the DJudge expressed concern that the contents of the fee could not be broken down but there was no case for it being a deposit as it was non returnable.

    Is this correct and if so has the new laws actually made in worse for tenantts in some cases??
    Always double check advice... not just mine!

    #2
    Nothing prohibits L and T from agreeing what they like in Tenancy Agreement. See definition of 'deposit' below [s.212(8) of Housing Act 2004].

    "tenancy deposit, in relation to a[n assured] shorthold tenancy, means any money intended to be held (by the landlord or otherwise) as security for:
    (a) the performance of any obligations of the tenant, or
    (b) the discharge of any liability of his,

    arising under or in connection with the tenancy.

    So anything not "as security" is not a deposit.
    JEFFREY SHAW, solicitor [and Topic Expert], Nether Edge Law*
    1. Public advice is believed accurate, but I accept no legal responsibility except to direct-paying private clients.
    2. Telephone advice: see http://www.landlordzone.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=34638.
    3. For paid advice about conveyancing/leaseholds/L&T, contact me* and become a private client.
    4. *- Contact info: click on my name (blue-highlight link).

    Comment


      #3
      So as it's not being returned it doesn't count. I can understand the reasoning and have no doubt your correct!

      I'm concerned this will spread, become the norm, and put tenants in a worse financial position than previously as it will be as if every deposit is not returned. (although it's not technically a deposit!)

      Doom and Gloom
      Always double check advice... not just mine!

      Comment


        #4
        I think we need to know the full facts and what was pleaded before we can decide whether the learned judge "erred in the law".

        Comment


          #5
          I would like to know in which court this was held as it's an important case.
          The advice I give should not be construed as a definitive answer, and is without prejudice or liability. You are advised to consult a specialist solicitor or other person of equal legal standing.

          Comment


            #6
            I don't have the full details of the case as i wasn't directly involved. Was told the outcome more than the story which was that it was held a fee paid at the beginning of the tenancy to set it up which was non returnable could not be held as a deposit. It was held in 'Greater Grimsby County Court'.

            There is apparently also a case ongoing in the same court against a landlord who took either 4 or 6 months rent in advance. Think it a little more invoved than just that! The solicitor saying it was being held 'as security' so i'm waiting to see what the outcome of that one is too.
            Always double check advice... not just mine!

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Impartial Advice View Post
              I don't have the full details of the case as i wasn't directly involved. Was told the outcome more than the story which was that it was held a fee paid at the beginning of the tenancy to set it up which was non returnable could not be held as a deposit. It was held in 'Greater Grimsby County Court'.

              There is apparently also a case ongoing in the same court against a landlord who took either 4 or 6 months rent in advance. Think it a little more invoved than just that! The solicitor saying it was being held 'as security' so i'm waiting to see what the outcome of that one is too.

              Paying six, or even twelve months' rent in advance is the only way some international students are able to secure accommodation without having a UK guarantor, so that's not a new development.

              The sky-high admin fees, I suspect, will just not stand up to market forces. It's a dog-eat-dog world out there among the agents and unless every landlord uses an agent who charged a ludicrously high 'admin' fee, tenants will desert the 'sharks' for LLs who let their properties out privately without using an agent, or for those wiser agents who have stuck with a 'reasonable' admin fee. Tenants are not stupid. They don't particularly like parting with £300 as a deposit even when they know they will get it back. They will be even less willing to throw the same amount into an agent's bank account with no prospect of seeing it again.


              No-brainer
              'Pause you who read this, and think for a moment of the long chain of iron or gold, of thorns or flowers, that would never have bound you, but for the formation fo the first link on one memorable day'. Charles Dickens, Great Expectations

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by mind the gap View Post
                The sky-high admin fees, I suspect, will just not stand up to market forces. It's a dog-eat-dog world out there among the agents and unless every landlord uses an agent who charged a ludicrously high 'admin' fee, tenants will desert the 'sharks' for LLs who let their properties out privately without using an agent, or for those wiser agents who have stuck with a 'reasonable' admin fee. Tenants are not stupid. They don't particularly like parting with £300 as a deposit even when they know they will get it back. They will be even less willing to throw the same amount into an agent's bank account with no prospect of seeing it again.


                No-brainer

                I would agree it should work like that except there are, unfortunately, a whole bunch of uneducated tenants out there! and it appears the most vunerable are the ones that end up with these problems. in this area there is no shortage of housing but horrible shortage of landlord s willing to let to LHA tenants... not that thats suprising with the stupid rules
                Always double check advice... not just mine!

                Comment

                Latest Activity

                Collapse

                • Reply to Tenant misleading everyone
                  by DPT57
                  I think the NTQ may be your best option. The tenant could defeat it by returning to live there but that would at least enable you to get the rent payments reinstated. If they dont return, the tenancy will end. You can serve the notice at the property, but make sure its also sent to wherever the tenant...
                  16-06-2021, 22:08 PM
                • Tenant misleading everyone
                  by bertha
                  I have a tenant who is been difficult I think due to health/mental problems,for the last year I have not been able to carry out epc,gas inspections.It seems tenant has been staying elsewhere ,I informed housing I could not enter the property and was advised by landlord liason officer to get a locksmith,enter...
                  14-06-2021, 13:20 PM
                • Reply to Inventory help
                  by DPT57
                  I based mine on an old RLA template. I think NRLA still have one. You could try that....
                  16-06-2021, 22:00 PM
                • Inventory help
                  by Helvie
                  Hi, Can anyone point me in the right direction as to where I could download a good quality inventory check list and guidance form, thanks.
                  13-06-2021, 14:56 PM
                • Reply to New Tenancy
                  by DPT57
                  Your questions are too wide ranging for a forum. The answers would form a long article. Asking questions on here is not a substitute for reading. I suggest you join the NRLA and read all their guides and checklists....
                  16-06-2021, 21:54 PM
                • New Tenancy
                  by SpringGreen
                  After the property is ready for advertistng what does a landlord need to mindful of.
                  1. what are the pros and cons in terms of tenancy agreement CONTRACTUAL AND STATUORY ?
                  2. applicants - how do landlord usually vet them ?
                  3. inventories (what comments or descriptions to use ? )...
                  12-06-2021, 09:11 AM
                • Reply to County Court Bailiffs 1 June
                  by Perce
                  Slackjawedyokel - my tenant does not seem to be in the property. I have no clue where he is or whether he will return.. The neighbours said that police were looking for him but when I checked with the police they could not find anything on the system. The police were very nice and helpful and asked...
                  16-06-2021, 21:20 PM
                • County Court Bailiffs 1 June
                  by Perce
                  Hello

                  I have a warrant for repossession, the ban is over tomorrow. How long does it take to hear from the County Court Bailiffs ? 1 week ? 1 month? What is the process ?...
                  31-05-2021, 11:30 AM
                • Reply to Pre action protocol
                  by flat27
                  Thank you for all your knowledge!! I’ve been reading about part 36 - they haven’t said it’s part 36 and they haven’t explained the basis of their figure. Also they have only given 7 days not 21.
                  I assume therefore it cannot be taken as part 36?
                  I’ve read that part 36 cannot be...
                  16-06-2021, 21:07 PM
                • Pre action protocol
                  by flat27
                  Hi - my tenant has moved out and has caused extensive water damage due to not reporting a leak and just leaving it to cause damage. We have tried to claim damages but he does not want to sort this amicably- does anyone have a template pre action protocol letter to start the court process? Any advice...
                  15-06-2021, 17:06 PM
                Working...
                X