Oil leak & deposit return

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Oil leak & deposit return

    Hi all,

    I had a look through past topics but struggled to find anything that quite covered it. Hope this is OK to post.

    My tenant had an oil leak on the drive during lockdown 2020 which ended up in quite a sizeable and deep stain. I never saw the original stain myself but was sent photos via the estate agent. After my tenants spent time cleaning it, I was sent photos of the drive and I confirmed I was happy with the condition and told them the issue was resolved. However, they gave in their notice within the next 2 months and by the time they left the stain had returned!!

    I had asked them to put a cover sheet down to prevent it happening again, which they said they did, but they must have had another oil leak! They said they didn’t and the car was fixed. Now the surface of the tarmac is crumbling due to the damage caused by the pressure washer used.

    They want to fight me against taking money out of their deposit, saying that although they admitted the original oil leak was their fault, they say it was no longer their responsibility as I had closed the issue. I’d argue that the drive is still their responsibility until they leave.

    Who would the DPS people side with? Do I have to prove they had another oil leak? Would it be enough to say it was a continuing problem from the original spill and therefore it could be reopened? They did come back and clean it on my request again after leaving but I still wasn’t happy and it just made things worse.

    What do you think?
    3
    Siding with the tenant
    33.33%
    1
    Siding with the landlord
    66.67%
    2

    #2
    Your claim is for compensation for a loss beyond fair wear and tear that happened during the lease.

    You don’t have to prove who caused the loss, just that it exists and there is a reasonable value being attributed to it.
    The deposit company adjudicator. will decide on that basis.
    When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
    Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by jpkeates View Post
      Your claim is for compensation for a loss beyond fair wear and tear that happened during the lease.

      You don’t have to prove who caused the loss, just that it exists and there is a reasonable value being attributed to it.
      .......
      Errr.. so tree falls from next door, nothing to do with tenant, demolishes shed etc & tenant pays?


      Think this may depend on what photos and inventory have on the drive: bzw anything??
      I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...

      Comment


        #4
        By surmising, you seemed to have been shocked perhaps from a sudden notice of tenants and also have a drive way with some outlandish surface. Because even in a car garage, their 99.99% oil dropping washed away leaving the surface/pavement shinier even after couple of rains. Unquestionably, when such palpably vacuous claims gets thwarted by the adjudicators then emit a sense of sheer misconception as if they are slanted by default towards tenants.

        Comment

        Latest Activity

        Collapse

        • Reply to Building damage?
          by ram
          Not to put a damper on things, but insurance is for accidents / unforseen occurences / trees falling on building / cars.- etc

          Insurance does not cover for deliberate acts which caused a fault.
          Thats why why drill round holes in bricks, put a plug in it then screw though the plug.
          ...
          29-07-2021, 13:05 PM
        • Building damage?
          by lampshade
          I have noticed that one of the 3 blocks has some studs hammered into the brickwork in one corner. There are also cracks running down the bricks. I am guessing that these studs are markers made by an engineer at some point, suggesting a structural issue maybe.
          In the event that any further opening...
          29-07-2021, 11:11 AM
        • Reply to Building damage?
          by lampshade
          Within the service charge there is of course a charge for Insurance. Presume if any work ever needs doing it would come from that Insurance policy? And then possibly an increase in future Insurance cost
          29-07-2021, 12:33 PM
        • Reply to Help! Sub tenant with no contract eviction rights
          by Yasmenaax
          Thanks for the response. Just wondering how I am not a tenant here though? Since there is a verbal agreement, I have been paying rent to her and she does not live in the property....
          29-07-2021, 12:25 PM
        • Help! Sub tenant with no contract eviction rights
          by Yasmenaax
          Hi there,

          I moved into a property 2-3 months ago which was subletted to me by a girl named on the main tenancy contract of the property. I handed over a deposit (which is currently unprotected) and have paid rent on time. She today decided to give me notice to leave, giving me only 2 weeks...
          29-07-2021, 02:19 AM
        • Reply to Isolating beyond the end of a fixed term
          by HantsAgent
          Indeed. And my worry for the tenants here is that this technically means their tenancy could have continued for an effective additional two months (unable to give a valid NtQ until the beginning of the next tenancy period and that notice having to be a full tenancy period)



          ...
          29-07-2021, 11:52 AM
        • Isolating beyond the end of a fixed term
          by HantsAgent
          Is anyone aware of anything giving tenants some leeway if they have to isolate and it takes them beyond of their fixed term?

          I'm trying to help the student son of a friend whose landlord appears to be being a little opportunistic because they had to stay in the property for a few days over...
          28-07-2021, 12:56 PM
        • Reply to Building damage?
          by ash72
          It would only be an insurance issue if the freeholder has an adequate policy covering it. The best thing is for the freeholder or managing agent to instruct an engineer who will put movement detectors on the property and see if there is any movement. It could be historical.

          All leaseholders...
          29-07-2021, 11:33 AM
        • Reply to Washing machine meter legality
          by landlord-man
          HaHa - I had already planned for that.

          My power sockets are behind a locked cupboard so they can only access the coin meters.

          I also put the communal wifi router power socket in a locked cupboard - otherwise, they could add an adapter socket to the router mains and run an extension...
          29-07-2021, 10:36 AM
        • Washing machine meter legality
          by Dreamingofsea
          i have a small hmo non licensable due to locality. It had a meter on the washing machine when I bought it but I disconnected it. I m finding that 1 tenant is doing 2 - 3 washes every day and so obviously is taking advantage of it and also hogging it. I stated in their tenancy agreements fair...
          20-01-2021, 21:16 PM
        Working...
        X