Does Section 214(4) apply to a lodger?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Does Section 214(4) apply to a lodger?

    Hi folks. I had a couple living as lodgers in a spare room in my house for about 6 months. As usual, I didn't see much use in a contract for such a casual let, and we made a really simple verbal agreement. Just the monthly rent, a calendar month notice either way, and a deposit of one month rent. During their stay it became apparent that one of them had serious anger management issues, and was causing quite a lot of damage. In the end, that amounted to more than the deposit, so I didn't give them their deposit back. Eventually they brought a case to County Court, quoting Section 214(4) Housing Act 2004. I was horrified to find out that this allows the court to not only make me give them their deposit back, but up to 4 x the deposit!

    I've had a quick look on the internet, but I can't find out for sure whether this act is applicable to a lodger. Anybody know?

    Thanks for looking!

    I'm assuming that the case has not yet gone to court, but as it stands, they don't have a leg to stand on.

    You are right, that section of the act does not apply to lodgers and there is no requirement to secure the deposit in one of the official schemes.


      It depends what they're claiming.

      If they're claiming that you had no right to keep their deposit, with the s214 issue as an "as well", they might still have a case, but have no ability to claim the penalty.

      If the lack of protection is all of their claim, it's pretty much a non-starter.
      When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
      Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


        As long as you were living in the same property and sharing living accommodation continuously for the period of their tenure, then there was no requirement for you to protect their deposit in a scheme and provided you have good evidence of reasonable deductions from their deposit you have nothing to fear.


          But next time, use a formal signed agreement, suggest shorter notice period. How on earth can you prove the verbal terms that you'd agreed??
          I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


            You will need to prove they were lodgers by documenting the premises as your actual address where you lived possibly using council tax documents, utility bills, bank statements, DVLA docs etc. If you did not live there then that is a different matter.

            Freedom at the point of zero............


              Thanks for all your replies and advice. My fingers are crossed!


              Latest Activity


              • Reply to Maintenance access home working tenants
                by cymro123
                You could do this if you blindly follow 1980s legislation but given we are in the middle of a pandemic, the risk of infection and restrictions on one person from one household entering another household you would need to consider if that is the right thing to do. In this case is the risk of infection...
                04-03-2021, 19:07 PM
              • Maintenance access home working tenants
                by Morleyman
                Wondered if anyone can clarify where I stand needing to have electrical maintenance carried out on a rental property where tenants work from home due to COVID. The electrician I am using only works weekdays but my tenants have said this work cannot take place during the week as they can’t have the...
                03-03-2021, 20:43 PM
              • Reply to Maintenance access home working tenants
                by cymro123
                The OP refers to 'electrical maintenance' not inspection and testing of the electrical installation
                04-03-2021, 18:55 PM
              • Reply to Floor damage in rented house - who pays?
                by Berlingogirl
                And water can travel quite a way under laminate flooring if it's laid on a solid floor....
                04-03-2021, 18:41 PM
              • Floor damage in rented house - who pays?
                by A.Renter

                I rent a house from a landlord (generally pretty decent and helpful). I did a thorough mopping of the floor a while back, which is made up of interlocking wooden plywood slats. Unfortunately some of the water must have drained below, causing some of the slats to 'bubble' and rise...
                01-03-2021, 21:04 PM
              • Reply to Freehold Nepotism
                by AndrewDod
                - Nobody can be forced to be a director of a company (indeed some people are disqualified)
                - If you are disabled and you feel the property is not managed according to the law/lease it is better not to be a director (or even a minority shareholder)....
                04-03-2021, 18:37 PM
              • Freehold Nepotism
                by bluemonday735
                Hi there,

                My block of flats has 8 shares. I have one flat and one share. the majority shareholder has 1 flat, 3 shares. She started the building limited company before I moved in, and it's just her and her ex partner on the board. The two of them always end up doing the work on the building...
                04-03-2021, 09:31 AM
              • Reply to Maintenance access home working tenants
                by pebblepebble
                Because I have had two solicitors now telling me I can't go onto the property to do the work without permission and as we are selling once they are formally evicted I'm not worried if it doesn't get done.
                04-03-2021, 18:16 PM
              • Reply to Unusual situation
                by Hudson01
                As said above he does sound like a guest and not a tenant, although he may well have a claim on the house via the rules governing inheritance unless the will states something different ..... which given his family position can be challenged anyway....
                04-03-2021, 18:13 PM
              • Unusual situation
                by mystic08
                The ex husband of a friend of mine has died. She is an executor of his estate and is unsure of the situation re her stepson. He receives some benefits (not housing) and has lived in the pool house (more of a shed really) rent free for the last fifteen years. It has a washbasin, a cooker and a heater....
                04-03-2021, 15:58 PM