Returning Tenants deposit

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Returning Tenants deposit

    Hi, This is my first time posting so forgive any mistakes I make!

    Our lodger signed a lodger agreement when he moved in 6 months ago. The contract clearly states that the 'tenancy' is for the duration of 12 months and that only us (the landlords) can terminate the agreement by giving him 4 weeks notice.

    He informed us four days ago that he will be moving out.

    The contract states that he will forfeit his deposit unless he provides us with another tenant of equal standards, and we agree on the choice.

    He found someone that says they want the room, but we will need to agree if we are happy with her moving in - this is our home after all!

    According to him, because he has found someone we need to return his deposit, but we have told him, that's not how it works! We need to be happy with the person moving in.

    Are we in the right? Or could he try and escalate this further (take us to small claims court)? any advice would be gratefully appreciated

    #2
    That is an indefensible clause, more suited to an AST, not a lodger Agreement.
    Return his Deposit..

    Comment


      #3
      I think that your agreement is unfair and even if any part of it is lawful, the tenant has fulfilled his part by finding a replacement. If you do not like the proposed lodger that is not his fault.

      I understand it is your home, but do you want to keep a lodger that does not want to be there? That could be awkward!

      Next time you take a lodger I would suggest your agreement is a little fairer - asking for a months notice perhaps.

      Lodger agreements give you, the home owner, considerably more rights than the lodger, you should respond by being fair with your terms.

      Comment


        #4
        There is a lot of difference between taking a lodger into your own home (on a lodger agreement) and giving a 12 month tenancy (AST) on a flat or house where you do not reside.

        I think you should read up on the 2. They don't mix and match.



        Freedom at the point of zero............

        Comment


          #5
          I'd never go with an agreement like that: Apart from being one sided, biased, unfair (in the legal sense) it would probably decided unenforceable if it ever went to court.

          Plus it gives a very strong message to your esteemed lodgers that you run an unfair service... guess how'd they react?

          Further, landlord having to give 4 weeks in all circumstance is unwise: You need to be able to evict much faster if there is unlawful acclivity, bad behaviour etc etc..

          Get a lodger agreement that's fair & decent, good old British values!
          I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by daisydee View Post
            Our lodger signed a lodger agreement when he moved in 6 months ago. The contract clearly states that the 'tenancy' is for the duration of 12 months and that only us (the landlords) can terminate the agreement by giving him 4 weeks notice.
            ...
            Are we in the right? Or could he try and escalate this further (take us to small claims court)? any advice would be gratefully appreciated
            No.
            And if the tenant escalates it to a court, they'd almost certainly win.
            When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
            Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).

            Comment

            Latest Activity

            Collapse

            • Reply to Landlord pulling out
              by DPT57
              It's possible that the correspondence with the Agent, particularly their acceptance of your application and offer of the keys for Monday would be enough to form a contract, in which case they would be in breach of contract by not allowing you to take-up the tenancy. However, its possible that the Agent...
              02-04-2020, 15:57 PM
            • Landlord pulling out
              by Charl2951
              I’m not sure if I’m in the right place but just wondering if anybody can help me please.
              I applied for a property that has been empty since December.. application accepted over night. I’m a single parent to two kids, a part time worker (earning 18 grand a year) and a post graduate doing...
              02-04-2020, 12:31 PM
            • Reply to New 3 month rule...
              by Piptrees
              6 months for AST or periodic, or both??
              02-04-2020, 15:57 PM
            • New 3 month rule...
              by Piptrees
              From today (26 March 2020) landlords will have to give all renters 3 months’ notice if they intend to seek possession (i.e. serve notice that they want to end the tenancy) –

              My tenant had already given notice before 26th March that he wasn’t renewing his tenancy. If he can’t move...
              01-04-2020, 17:05 PM
            • Reply to Move into a new rental property during this uncertain time
              by theartfullodger
              Re. Inventory if you do move in simply take LOADS AND LOADS of photos, ideally date-stamped. It's more a problem for the landlord if he can't prove what was there (eg 6 chairs..) or what condition (eg new, used, knackered..) so hard for him to claim any loss
              02-04-2020, 15:49 PM
            • Move into a new rental property during this uncertain time
              by BellaLDN
              Trying to get an insight into whats happening with new tenancies starting shortly during this corona situation.

              Friends sibling due to move into new flat in central london. Was viewed through an estate agency late jan / early feb (before corona drama), holding deposit given. References...
              01-04-2020, 19:56 PM
            • Reply to Landlord in Distress
              by AndrewDod
              That's probably the rate of death from (as opposed to with) the virus in the UK right now. The big missing element in the whole thing is the denominator. You will notice that I said that this is probably (a guess) currently at around 3 million. The 0.1% (perhaps a little less) are dramatic, sad and...
              02-04-2020, 15:49 PM
            • Landlord in Distress
              by Roydravid
              Hello ,

              My tenant has stopped paying the rent on from the 5th of MArch 2020. This was the first month they stopped the rent . It is a period tenancy after one year tenancy agreement in 2018.
              The Tenant has changed the locks and denied access for inspection and essential works . ...
              25-03-2020, 06:26 AM
            • Reply to New 3 month rule...
              by theartfullodger
              Scotland it's now 6 months... And anyway there's no s21 equivalent for tenancies for last couple of years.
              02-04-2020, 15:46 PM
            • Reply to New 3 month rule...
              by DPT57
              Yes, although the Secretary of State did hint that this may be extended to 6 months....
              02-04-2020, 15:24 PM
            Working...
            X