Tennancy - using a rent guarantor

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Tennancy - using a rent guarantor


    I've got a tennant applying to rent, everything seems normal, visited the place with her mum and has 2 teenage boys. She works part time but not enough to get approved for the rental payments. She has offered her mum (also working and home owner) as guarantor.

    Through openrent the credit checks fail her mum as guarantor as her income isnt massive either, despite her fully owning a house.

    What should I be doing here, as i see it, the guarantor should pass as she is a home owner - so surely will be able to pay any damages or missed rent?


    It's always landlord's decision. Entirely legal to use a 18yr old unemployed looser with no assets if you wish.

    How much equity does she have

    Your choice your decision:. Use a deed.
    I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


      Yes i appreciate i can choose who i want - be they poor or not, but being christmas time, tennant choices are few and far between! This tennant seems fine and they have been in prior property for 10 years. Working for 4 years in stable job etc.

      But why would a check on a guarantor fail as she fully owns (no mortgage) a house! Surely this is the perfect guarantor as she will not want to have to sell the house to pay silly repair bills on her daughters rental!?


        Originally posted by eniacs View Post
        But why would a check on a guarantor fail as she fully owns (no mortgage) a house!
        Because she needs sufficient income to cover both her current outgoings and the rent on your place?


          Mdeb - Surely if the original tennant could not pay the rent suddenly, then i would start eviction and claim the difference from the guarantor. I wouldnt keep an nonpaying tennant and ask the guarantor to pay indefinately?

          I suppose i am assuming that the tennant can pay the rent with other income which doesnt count towards the credit check. As would be the guarantor, unless the mother actually tops up the daughters income, which i find unlikely. More like the daughter tops up her income with tax credits.

          What alternatives are there?


            the alternatives are other tenants.

            If you take this tenant on with her mother as guarantor, you have to be willing to accept that if she doesn't pay and her mum doesn't pay you could ultimately be in a situation where you are evicting a mum with two teenage kids and forcing someone to sell their home to pay debts their family member has incurred and they can't pay.

            If you can deal with that worst case scenario, and the stress and initial cost to yourself, then all is fine.

            When taking on a guarantor, you have to be able to envisage the worst case scenario because that's what guarantors are for. There's no such thing as a guarantor's guarantor.


              Check the home owner - there might be so many charges on the property that she has no or little capital in it. An experian full credit report will show this.


                Only offer prospective T a fixed Term AST for 6 months. Ref the G.


                  Wait til the New Year - always new renters on the scene as overcrowding at Christmas gets to people.....reason mother for failing checks could be credit card debt etc

                  Freedom at the point of zero............


                    I agree with the above.
                    Better a void than a bad tenant.
                    When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
                    Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


                      Mother didnt fail credit checks, only the guarantor part. She hasnt the income to cover the rent. I appreciate what you've all said and I've gone back to her to ask if there is someone who could afford the rent and act as guarantor.

                      You are right as well, the new year will bring new renters.

                      Its a shame as she is obviously a genuine person with a good history who could pay the rent. But the renter checks say dont rent to her. This is my first time dealing directly with enquiries as I've always used a agent befor as I was abroad. But now dealing with them direct i feel bad for them.


                        good that you have a conscience... but imagine how much worse you will feel for them if you have to evict them.


                          Yes you are right. I've explained to them and they understand. They have come back with another guarantor who has a higher income so will try that. Also have another viewing tomorrow with someone else as a back up.

                          Thanks for assistance. Great forums.


                          Latest Activity


                          • Reply to arrears and damage
                            by Hudson01
                            I applaud you on your forward thinking in regards '' tailing '' them, very smart. I agree with the above comments, i feel for the new landlord...... and in my opinion if you had, had the opportunity to evict them and their two children it is not you who is responsible but the adult who has decided not...
                            11-07-2020, 18:16 PM
                          • arrears and damage
                            by Dougie99
                            Hi, I have recently had 2 tenants leave Mother and daughter and 2 kids. They had been in arrears since Feb and left owing £2130.

                            I had £1040 deposit signed to me and they signed an agreement to pay arrears over 12 months, they moved out a day before they said they were going to and moved...
                            11-07-2020, 08:10 AM
                          • Reply to Rent Guarantee Insurance
                            by AndrewDod
                            I guess the only point ever to insure is if

                            a) You think they have calculated a too-low premiums based on the (correct) information you gave (extremely rare) so that you will statistically "win"

                            b) If the event (if it occurs) will be life changing. Like medical travel...
                            11-07-2020, 18:14 PM
                          • Rent Guarantee Insurance
                            by oi2004as

                            I would be interested in your view on the following

                            I received a renewal Legal & Rent Guarantee Insurance documents from Rentguard (which initiallyy I purchased through Openrent)

                            There is the following condition in their 'statement of fact':
                            11-07-2020, 11:59 AM
                          • Reply to Rent Guarantee Insurance
                            by Section20z
                            Insurance can never pay out more than it takes in premiums so you're on a hiding to nothing. The only way you'll ever win on insurance is if you have below average luck, but in that case you'd probably also find you'd forgotten to pay the premium 🤔
                            11-07-2020, 18:04 PM
                          • Reply to Rent Guarantee Insurance
                            by AndrewDod
                            Yes, RG insurance is pretty much a waste of time. And this is a ludicrous clause at so many levels. I'd drop the policy....
                            11-07-2020, 17:56 PM
                          • Reply to Break Clause in AST - Recommendations Please
                            by AndrewDod
                            I think closer to 10 to 14 months in many places - pre virus. 4 months almost never happens anywhere with a tenant who resists in any way. In that time they can basically steal £15K.

                            This average of 4 months will include the 90%+ of tenants who leave voluntarily having been served no...
                            11-07-2020, 17:52 PM
                          • Break Clause in AST - Recommendations Please
                            by landlord-man
                            I wish to add a Break Clause into our ASTs - actually, I'd like to put two in there if possible................


                            To allow either the Tenant or the Landlord to exit the Tenancy after 4 months.


                            To allow the Tenant (not the Landlord) to exit...
                            11-07-2020, 15:54 PM
                          • Reply to Break Clause in AST - Recommendations Please
                            by KTC
                            Well yeah, but whether it's wise, and whether it has the effect you intended are different questions.

                            A landlord cannot legally evict their tenant except through the courts obtaining an order for possesion and then having that order executed by bailiffs or High Court enforcement officers....
                            11-07-2020, 16:56 PM
                          • Reply to Break Clause in AST - Recommendations Please
                            by theartfullodger
                            General advice is to avoid break clauses as they are notorius for being difficult to get valid (only way to find out if they are valid would be in court if tenant and/or landlord sues the other one).

                            First doesn;t need a break clause: Simply make initial fixed term of AST only 4 months:...
                            11-07-2020, 16:47 PM