Deposit dispute and a bit of gardening

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Deposit dispute and a bit of gardening


    Having moved out I'm now in dispute with my ex landlord over the deposit. To cut a long story short they want to keep the whole deposit nearly 3K after eighteen months tenancy. After attempting to negotiate I have raised a dispute with the TDS scheme and they have submitted their evidence.

    Im preparing my response but I have a couple of questions on specific points.

    First gardening. I didn’t get time to cut the grass before I left although I’d done it a couple of weeks earlier so it wasn’t particularly long so I offered them £100 for a gardener , they want this and say I should pay a further £200 to have a tree trimmed, thing is the tree isn’t that big probably fifteen feet , not sure what it is but it looks very old and is slow growing I can’t see any diffence since we moved in, but the neighbours house behind has a large vine tree of some kind this has grown over the boundary covering top of a shed and partly grows into the tree concerned. Am I responsible for the cost of removing foliage from a neighbours tree.

    Second they claimed they found some damage, a broken lock two weeks after we moved out and the landlord got the inventory company to come back and add it to the inventory two weeks later. It was fine when we left.

    Third the house was freshly painted magnolia when we moved in and although we had touched up a few picture holes we repaired , the inventory described it as freshly painted off white. Same thing basically. Landlord wants £1600 to repaint the entire house saying it’s been repainted without permission.

    I had looked after it really well the inventory guys said to me basically it’s very good condition just needs a clean when he did the checkout.

    Thanks any opinions appreciated.

    You're not responsible for removing foliage from a neighbour's tree unless it's damaging something in your property. Then it depends on what the tenancy agreement says you are responsible for.

    Dispute the broken lock if you don't think you broke it, 2 weeks is a long time.

    First of all, the landlord can't claim the whole cost of the redecoration even if you had repainted. He can either claim that he has suffered a loss as the result of a breach of the contract term (in which case the loss would be the difference between the value of the property with your paint as opposed to their original - which would be negligible in this case because it's the same paint), Alternatively, they can try and argue that you have denied them the use of the original paint, but again, there's no loss because you've either replaced it with new paint or (as you say) it's actually the same paint.

    I'd make the point to the ADR that it's a mistake and it's the same paint and as a result there's no loss. And further, even if the landlord is adamant that the paint has been replaced, because it really hasn't, what's there is as good as what was there before, so there's no loss.
    When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
    Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


      What jpkeates said.


      Latest Activity


      • Reply to Is time more important than money?
        by Lawcruncher
        I am not suggesting it is the landlord's fault. I am just saying that, in some cases, if a tenant feels secure he is more likely to take care of a place....
        27-01-2022, 23:02 PM
      • Is time more important than money?
        by jpucng62
        Just had tenants move out of a property after 2 years. Always paid on time, perfectly pleasant young family who have now bought their own home BUT:

        House was grimy - looks like they didn't clean properly in 2 years rather than anything overtly unpleasant
        Garden was left in a mess...
        27-01-2022, 17:20 PM
      • Reply to Tenant not paying and letting agent mismanaged
        by MdeB
        That is because you have to do things properly for S21 to be valid.

        Do everything properly and the S21 is valid.
        Get one thing wrong and it is invalid. There are many things to get right....
        27-01-2022, 22:54 PM
      • Tenant not paying and letting agent mismanaged
        by Beeble
        We rented a flat out with the local branch of a national estate agent. They were charging a very low fee (that should’ve had my alarm bells ringing) and had a tenant immediately available. This was Dec2020/Jan2021 and the tenancy paperwork they sent to me was minimal.

        Tenant moved in...
        25-01-2022, 15:37 PM
      • Reply to Deducting Cleaning Costs from Deposit
        by Lawcruncher
        The requirement comes from the tenancy terms. There are various reasons why a contract term may be void or unenforceable. They include: illegal; impossible; contrary to public policy; statute forbids them to be imposed; unfair. A requirement to keep a dwelling clean and leave it it clean is none of...
        27-01-2022, 22:20 PM
      • Deducting Cleaning Costs from Deposit
        by Piffy
        I use a Letting Agent. Recently the tenants vacated, prior to the tenants leaving when the letting agent did an inspection they advised the tenants that the property would need cleaning before they vacated. The tenants have now left, the place does need a good clean, the Letting Agents have said that...
        27-01-2022, 11:30 AM
      • Reply to Inherited a few rentals
        by AndrewDod
        Almost everything is telling you to sell them - far away, no experience, higher rate taxpayer, current environment
        27-01-2022, 22:04 PM
      • Inherited a few rentals
        by Landlord7289
        Hoping for some advice on this situation from people who may have been through similar...

        I am inheriting 4 rental properties from my late father. Are there any tips or ideas people would share about this situation?

        My situation is I am early 30s in full time employment, live...
        25-01-2022, 15:02 PM
      • Reply to Deducting Cleaning Costs from Deposit
        by DoricPixie

        Why does a tenant need to leave the property in a reasonable state of cleanliness if the property wasn't in a reasonable state of cleanliness at the start of the tenancy? Where does the requirement come from? The deposit protection schemes don't appear to take that approach...
        27-01-2022, 21:11 PM
      • Reply to Tenant has moved partner in.
        by Hudson01
        Totally agree, the classic - still the best. They sound like a nightmare and i would be looking to get rid as soon as i could whilst we still have S21, removing kitchen cupboards !!! In a 2 bed flat...... why the hell would you remove part of a fitted kitchen, what are you going to do with the space....
        27-01-2022, 20:41 PM