Can I Sue The Council for negligence ?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Can I Sue The Council for negligence ?

    Wondering if someone can help me here.
    I live in Council Estate. Having a mortgage and been living here since 2002
    Earlier this year gang of thieves entered Storage Room (doors are secured with number lock) and broken into my storage and tools worth approximately £ 2000 were taken.
    I was not the only victim, other tenants had their belongings stolen too.
    One of the tenants Also, his car broken into
    Meanwhile, he has gone, he had enough....

    Long story short..on 06 09 i reported to Council that Storage Room lock was broken and any gang can come back to demolish storage.

    I can only assume that that lock has been broken for some time since response I received by email was they didn't know lock was broken.
    (although here is cleaner here every day and CCTV but i have never received info that CCTV actually works.

    I was away from 09.09 and just came back today and realized that lock has been fixed.
    I wanted to put luggage back into storage only to be shocked that my doors were opened(lock broken again) and others doors too

    I just contacted the police and only was given a reference number and told might be called to see if the forensic team would come.

    Considering all this I am thinking after over 17 years to sell this flat.
    Or even Sue The Council for negligence ..does anyone have any suggestions is this even possible considering I feel Council behaves like they failed to ensure security for all tenats.

    Stress, money spent is not worth staying here anymore.

    Maybe someone can help?

    email to council

    Yes, stories like this one and others I've heard about negligent Council freehlolders and trapped leaseholders made me realise some time ago that Right to Buy, particularly where the property is a flat or on an estate, is not always the easy pickings that the erstwhile tenants assumed


      Leaseholders can be resp resp for insuring their own residence,not the freeholder.


        I am not sure in what way the council has been negligent.
        When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
        Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


          Your claim is obviously against the thieves.

          But you can sue whoever you like for whatever you like. Case may or may not be accepted and you may or may not win.

          You could sue Bozo for being an incompetent who never actually does anything:
          I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


            I understand..but my point is that this is the second time the same thing happened and i even told them it would happen.
            CCTV that is on top of the building looks like is only for decoration purposes.
            My point is that since i am paying so many bills, surely Council has a responsibility to ensure the safety of the estate.

            First time when it happened, nobody even reported it, like 5 days after a gang broke into it..

            Surely,at least they can do know it install CCTV in storage room itself,fix all the looks and change entry door (key -rather then number lock as it originally was)
            Damage done in my case i reckon is approx 2K.(mainly tools taken...)


              You are asking for something that would normally not be a recoverable cost on a private sector lease. Right to Buy leases often do provide for improvements, so that might not be true in your case.

              Also, I note that the costs of providing security to vehicles is not allowable against UC, even if it is allowable against the service charge, and whilst not quite the same, I imagine that the authorities would treat this more like a vehicle than a house.

              You bought the property with the level of security it actually had, and you chose to store expensive tools, in that knowledge.

              On a technical detail, conventional metal keys are a problem in this application, as they will get lost, get copied, fall into the hands of the criminal fraternity (which are represented even on private sector estates, and probably more so on council ones). If you want to maintain security, you will have to regularly change the locks and issue new keys. Even the simple, 4 out of 12 push button locks can be easily recoded, and the new "key" distributed as a slip of paper. More sophisticated ones may have a code per user, meaning that compromised codes can be replaced without inconveniencing anyone else.

              CCTV is also quite rare in older private sector developments, and is probably more effective as a deterrent than in actually identifying criminals.


                Unfortunately, it looks like you are right. Police are asking for CCTV footage but since it is not working anyway there is probably nothing the can do. They probably would do nothing anyway.
                It is clearly a waste of money and time just installing it ..
                What upset me the most is the fact that nobody in this block report anything and even once reported it takes like ages for council to do something.
                It is like nobody cares.
                I reported it just days before it happened again..but what is the point?

                It is probably the most useless Council in London


                  Any non-workng Security system can have a detterence factor untll sussed eg dummy alarm boxes.
                  L has no duty to provide CCTV in communal areas and is best advised not to do so,


                  Latest Activity


                  • Written information proving protection of deposit not provided by agent/landlord

                    Basically, we've moved out of our property and are awaiting our deposit back. We are aware that the agent wants to make deductions, but has not told us of what amount. Anyway, whilst trying to source our deposit we have noticed some issues, and I believe we are within our rights...
                    22-10-2019, 08:18 AM
                  • Energy efficiency certificate
                    I am in the process of letting out a house to a new tenant, I cant seem to find my enegry efficiency cert, how do I go about getting an energy efficiency certificate?

                    Was it supposed to be given to me by the estate agents when I purchased the house a few years back,
                    or did the current...
                    21-10-2019, 17:25 PM
                  • Reply to Energy efficiency certificate
                    It's not legal to let the property without the tenant being shown the current valid EPC beforehand.

                    I've never heard of anyone having a problem with that in real life, though....
                    22-10-2019, 08:18 AM
                  • Oven light not working
                    I have a new tenant, a fussy one. I had a new bed base and mattress delivered for him, the first day he moved in complained mattress is too soft so had to replace and lost money on the other one
                    Then he called the grill in the electric oven is not working which I knew from previous tenants...
                    20-10-2019, 14:54 PM
                  • Reply to Oven light not working
                    I don't have a bulb in my oven. ( it's gas ) Should i insist on a brand new cooker with a light ? but i don't want an electric cooker, but that's not my problem. I want / demand a light in my cooker.

                    Supply the tenant with a torch is the answer.
                    22-10-2019, 07:56 AM
                  • Enquiry about pregnant prospective tenant
                    Hi all

                    We have had an enquiry from a couple to rent our two-bed flat. The lady is pregnant. We did put no children on the ad; however we are willing to see them and let them view the flat.

                    If however, we decide not to process their application further, can she sue us for discrimination...
                    21-10-2019, 18:03 PM
                  • Reply to Enquiry about pregnant prospective tenant
                    Thankyou Berlingogirl. We have told her that as the flat is not available for viewing until the 21st November, she can apply nearer the time and her application will be judged by the same criteria as everyone else's. She hopefully will find somewhere else during that time.
                    22-10-2019, 07:31 AM
                  • Reply to Enquiry about pregnant prospective tenant
                    As post number 7.
                    As you say, you have lets say 10 applicants, you cant give the flat to the pregnant woman because she may sue you, because that is discrimination against the other 9.
                    You would be purposely discriminating against the ones with no children especially as you said "no...
                    22-10-2019, 07:30 AM
                  • Reply to Enquiry about pregnant prospective tenant
                    Just tell her you've decided to let to somebody else. You could say they have a higher income and a fantastic credit reference or whatever. You don't need to say anything about her prospective child, in that way there is no discrimination....
                    22-10-2019, 07:16 AM
                  • Rent increases.
                    Hi everyone.
                    I need some advice about how best to approach rent increases. I own a property with good tenants who look after the house, they have been in the house for about 4 years. The market rent is around £675 but I am charging £595 so £80 less a month partly because I charged a bit less...
                    21-10-2019, 18:03 PM