• Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts


    I had a benefits tenant email the estate agency telling them they intended to leave and would hand the keys in that week. They had a 12 month AST which does not end until November 2019 The agency contacted them stating that they would be liable for rent etc. Their response was “we have already moved”
    I asked the agent if they could find out when they intended to bring the keys in. The response from the tenant via email was “sometime this week, I am busy” Incidentally their phone number no longer worked so it was not possible to contact them by phone.
    I went to look through the window of the property and could see that the property had been emptied. The estate agent then suggested that a seven day abandonment notice was placed on the property. This was done last Thursday. They have subsequently sent a friend into the estate agents to leave the keys.
    I have since been told by the estate agent that I will not be able to use Leeds Vs Broadley with regard to the council tax as an abandonment notice was placed on the property, is that correct ?

    Ask the agent to explain what legal status they think an "abandonment notice" has and what effect it can possibly have on council tax.
    There's no such thing as an abandonment notice.

    What has actually happened is that you have probably accepted the tenant's surrender by accepting the keys and thereby brought the tenancy to an end.
    That ends the tenant's liability for council tax and utilities.
    The liability for paying rent ended at that point.

    If that's not what you want to happen, you need to confirm to the tenant that you are not accepting the surrender and that the tenancy continues (providing the agent hasn't accepted the surrender on your behalf).
    When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
    Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


      Thanks, there initially was a strongly worded email sent to the tenant explaining refusal to accept early surrender and their ongoing liability.
      I have been informed the keys were left in the estate agency by a friend of the tenants in a sealed envelope and the friend turned on their heels and left.


        Read this, it's tricky: "Abandonment" has no real legal meaning....

        - but good news about the keys. Arrange an inspection promptly, take witness & LOADS of photos.
        I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


          Leeds v Broadley appears to have no relevance in this case.

          The tenancy is still in its fixed term, so council is required to pursue T for council tax until the tenancy is properly ended.

          Leeds v Broadly is a ruling that a tenancy that has an initial term of at least 6 moths and has become contractual periodic is a single tenancy of at least 6 months, and therefore the council must pursue the T for council tax if T leaves before the tenancy is properly ended.(https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2016/1213.html)

          Your agent appears not to understand the law. I would suggest terminating your agreement with them on this basis (what else do they not understand?) and find an agent that does know the law.


          Latest Activity


          • Reply to Letting Agent Withholding Key (Lease signed + rent paid)
            by HobbitShire
            Sorry but I must reitterate that she DID provide all documents which were initially requested before both parties signed the lease. This new, rigid requirement for a utility bill only came a day before the agreed move-in date.

            This is not a case of a prospective tenant having no paper trail....
            20-01-2022, 01:28 AM
          • Letting Agent Withholding Key (Lease signed + rent paid)
            by HobbitShire
            My partner has recently signed a lease through a well known property agent in London.

            The lease was also signed by the landlord. References from current + previous employer, landlord, etc, and proof of address were requested before signing, and provided.

            Upon signing the lease...
            20-01-2022, 00:57 AM
          • Reply to Letting Agent Withholding Key (Lease signed + rent paid)
            by HobbitShire
            Firstly, she already provided the previous lease, along with a document from the municipality of Amsterdam stating that she was registered as living there. I paid the bills as we were living together, and she has closed her Dutch bank account (as is required when you are no longer a resident). I'm sure...
            20-01-2022, 01:11 AM
          • Reply to Letting Agent Withholding Key (Lease signed + rent paid)
            by Jon66
            No bank statements with the old address on? These are available freely from your online account, or previous utility bills, council tax bills etc. I find it difficult to accept that they are unable to provide something. I would have concerns if you were my prospective tenant. You need to provide the...
            20-01-2022, 01:02 AM
          • Reply to Property damaged. Advice please
            by minorbark
            When you put it like that I'm more inclined to edge towards the S21 route regardless. As much as part of me feels some compassion for the guy and doesn't want to lump more stress on top of someone who appears to be struggling already, as has been said before, none of us are acting as a charity.
            19-01-2022, 22:51 PM
          • Property damaged. Advice please
            by minorbark
            Apologies if something similar has already been covered elsewhere. I did try to search but couldn't find anything that matched my situation particularly closely. A huge thanks in advance to any of you who do take the time to read and advise.

            TLDR version: Police have forced entry into my...
            18-01-2022, 21:55 PM
          • Reply to Property damaged. Advice please
            by minorbark
            Thank you.

            My initial contact with the police was just a phone call to the local station. As I almost half expected they wouldn't give up much info, I didn't particularly push back when they said as much and I left it at that. A formal complaint might fill in a few blanks in the story but...
            19-01-2022, 22:37 PM
          • Reply to Property damaged. Advice please
            by Hudson01
            A back door way into finding out what did happen (or more info than you have now), is to ask for a callback from the local PCSO who covers the beat area where the tenant lives (go online and start a live chat), he or she will know far more about your tenant that a faceless comms operator at HQ or anyone...
            19-01-2022, 22:17 PM
          • Reply to Property damaged. Advice please
            by DoricPixie
            Just because someone knocks on your door, even if it crescendos to them banging loudly on your door, it doesn’t mean you have to answer it or have to go and investigate.

            If the tenant suffers from mental health issues and the police were sent round because someone thought the tenant’s...
            19-01-2022, 21:47 PM
          • Reply to Property damaged. Advice please
            by WebLand
            From painful personal experience of this issue... You should formally contact the police, ask them why they broke the door down and ask for compensation. Their lawyer will then write to you with some information which may be useful for you to know (but not giving very much detail). I expect they'll...
            19-01-2022, 21:31 PM