Question about the obligation of the Check-out clerk to secure the rental property

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Question about the obligation of the Check-out clerk to secure the rental property

    Our latest tenants vacated our property on February 27. The check-out was done on February 27. The tenants requested to leave before the end of the tenancy because the property had been broken into in November and they were no longer happy in the house. WIthin 48 hours of them leaving, the property was broken into a second time. The mode of entry was very similar - the first break-in occurred by breaking a pane of glass on the kitchen door and also kicking the door in. We replaced the door with one which had no glass. Earlier this week, the thief gained entry through the French doors, also at the back of the property. Pictures show that he broke only a small piece of glass in order to reach in to open the door from the inside. When we received the check-out report, it was stated that the check-out clerk left the French door keys "in situ", i.e. in the door.

    I queried this with our letting agent, as my understanding was that the check-out clerk was responsible for securing the safety of the property, accounting for all keys, as well as checking its condition. I am cutting and pasting my question, and the agent's response:

    My question: When we first spoke, I imagined that the burglar either broke the whole glass panel of the French door and gained access to the house that way, or broke the lock. The photos show that the burglar broke only a small area of glass in order to reach in to open the door from the inside. The check out report states that the French door keys were " in situ". Does this mean that the keys were left in the lock? If so, it is easy to see how and why the burglar attempted to break in again.

    Agent's response: Tenants left the keys in back door and this is what the clerk means by situ, I understand your point but who would of thought that someone would of smashed their way through double glazed doors to get to the key.

    She elaborated in another email that it is common practice to leave keys in the locks and only to return the front door keys and room keys to the letting agent.

    I am at a complete loss to process this. I would welcome other landlord's experiences. Is this common practice? Even with a property that has been recently broken into? To me, the check-out clerk has failed in a key duty of care to the landlord and to the property.

    #2
    I don't think the clerk has any obligation to make the property more safe than they found it.
    I don't see how any duty of care arises, they're paid to make a report on the condition of the property which they did.
    When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
    Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).

    Comment


      #3
      I don't see any blame attaching to the clerk, they left the door locked and so the property was secure.
      The fact that the housebreaker had to cause damage to get in shows that it was secure.
      (If they had left it unlocked, or a window open, that would be different).

      Obviously a local housebreaker.
      He saw that the tenants had moved out and though that there would be a new tenant with lots of new posessions for him to steal.

      He would have broken in whether the key was in the door or not, as it is he's probably caused less damage by unlocking the doors rather than smashing the door/lock as he did before.

      Comment

      Latest Activity

      Collapse

      • Reply to Smoking tenant
        by Hudson01
        I can only echo the above comments, you have done what you need too, although to be honest i would have taken this action years ago, if you have never liked all the smoke then why put up with it for so long...... I would be very unhappy about all the smoke but i would seriously consider selling both...
        13-05-2021, 19:42 PM
      • Smoking tenant
        by renting25
        Please can you offer us advice as to whether there is any action that can be taken to stop a very serious situation of anti social behaviour.My wife and myself own 2 maisonettes a upstairs owned by me that we both live in and a downstairs that is owned by my wife and she has rented the property out...
        13-05-2021, 17:17 PM
      • Reply to Early change of Landlord
        by theartfullodger
        Sympathy! Don't forget to advise tenants to pursue the agent's complaints process and when that process fails - (I can foresee the future) - to use the lettings agent redress scheme. See here advice from Mssrs Shelter..
        https://england.shelter.org.uk/housi...edress_schemes

        Good luck:...
        13-05-2021, 19:34 PM
      • Early change of Landlord
        by islandgirl
        Would be grateful for thoughts on this. Daughter signed student tenancy for next academic year on Monday this week. LL shown as an individual with the same name as the letting agency. Yesterday she was told that the LL wishes to self manage and to change her standing order payment to an investment company...
        13-05-2021, 09:52 AM
      • Reply to Smoking tenant
        by Jon66
        Yes I agree with the above. Make sure you have complied with statutory requirements to ensure any s21 is valid.
        13-05-2021, 18:59 PM
      • Unreasonably Withholding Consent on Internal Layout Change
        by wabdiddly
        Dear All,

        Looking for an opinion and some legal views behind what I can do in the following situation.

        My top floor flat has rather wonky flooring, which the structural engineer's report described as "in poor condition and needs levelling to provide satisfactory living...
        13-05-2021, 18:28 PM
      • Reply to Smoking tenant
        by ash72
        You have been provided the advice by your legal council, if you want them out seek possession of the property (do it before S21 is removed), you need to now moved to the next stage which is put in an application for possession, then finally bailiffs. I would also stop complaining to the T's it is harassment,...
        13-05-2021, 17:44 PM
      • Reply to New landlord needs some advice
        by DPT57
        She wouldn't be able to rent it straight away anyway if you carry out referencing, (which you should), as this takes a few days. I get people to complete an application form too. A lot of prospective tenants are flaky on OR. Some promise to call you and you never hear from them again, even if you try...
        13-05-2021, 17:38 PM
      • New landlord needs some advice
        by wenqi
        Hi, I am just a new landlord who is renting our first property using openrent. I do need some advice from you.

        We had a very lovely lady to view our house. She looked love our property and wanted to take it straight away. Because she came alone (her partner was working), my husband advised...
        12-05-2021, 19:56 PM
      • Reply to 'Replacement tenancy' issue
        by berliner
        "If the new tenancy is for a lesser rent, the tenant will remain liable to pay an amount equal to the difference between the original rent and new lower rental figure up to the end of the original fixed term."

        I read in a similar post that such a clause might not be enforceab...
        13-05-2021, 17:38 PM
      Working...
      X