Question about damage

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Question about damage

    Good morning, I'm new here so, firstly want to take the opportunity to say hello.
    I'm living outside of the UK at the moment and my property in the UK is being rented out. I had an excellent Tennant who has now moved out. He has openly admitted damaging the lounge carpet. I have had a quote to replace it, the carpet is 2.5 years old and good quality. Should I make an allowance in the cost of repair for wear and tear? The carpet is still like new. I have no other issues with the property I just want to be as fair to the ex tennant as I can but also to my self.

    Thank you in advance for any advice.

    What specifically are we talking about in terms of damage? As far as I'm aware, you can't deduct from deposit for fair wear and tear; if the tenant has looked after it as well as reasonably possible and been there a few years and it's slightly worn or light sofa indentation I wouldn't expect a claim to be made for this. But if it is damaged I.e. permanent staining or rips etc then I'd expect a claim to be made proportionate to restoring/replacing the carpet but with age and condition in mind.


      A landlord is entitled to compensation for any loss in value of their asset(s) beyond fair wear and tear that occurred during the lease.

      The formula that they should use, and a court (and the protecting company ADR process) will use is:
      (Cost of the original item and any installation/fitting [not the cost of a replacement] / expected lifetime) * (expected lifetime - actual lifetime).
      That is, compensation for the lost value (life of use) of the item.

      That presumes that the item is entirely ruined and the landlord can show that it happened during the lease.

      If a repair is a more cost effective solution than a replacement (or vice versa), the cheaper option has to be taken.

      Alternatively, an actual repair cost might be claimed, but again, this should be adjusted to reflect the tenant's share of the lifetime (but sometimes this is just meaningless).

      Fair wear and tear is “reasonable use of the premises by the tenant and the ordinary operation of natural forces”.
      When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
      Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


        Get an Ind Inv Clerk to asess damage based on move in report.



          Some how he has burnt the carpet, not a cigarette burn, he said he spilt molten plastic on it, but it has melted into the carpet and cannot be removed.


            You must make an allowance for wear and tear, and you must use the original price, not the replacement price as the basis.

            The allowance for wear and tear is based on the lifetime of the carpet when used by average tenant, not on the rate of wear and tear with the current tenant. Otherwise you would penalise the tenant for not causing wear.

            The life expectancy of landlord quality carpets seems to be about 5 years, so you are talking about a discount of 50%, on cost price, so a little more than 50% on replacement price, unless you used a premium carpet.

            Is the damage such that you will have difficulty letting it or have to accept a reduced rent?


            Latest Activity


            • When to call end to tenancy
              Thoughts from experienced landlords would be appreciated. The tenancy is now periodic. The house is a modern build, in good repair and decoration.

              Tenants are slow in reporting maintenance issues or, conversely, needy. We have replaced a blown light bulb as tenants did not know how...
              18-05-2019, 17:58 PM
            • Reply to When to call end to tenancy
              if tenants smoke outside thats usually acceptable

              i think that for mice well - this is a common problem but as for carpets smelling of urine ??mmmm I found i had mice in my loft a few years back and the council come down for free to put stuff down and do a survey all free maybe you could...
              19-05-2019, 23:22 PM
            • deposit and damage
              Hi all
              I've read quite a few of the posts here about deposit returns and deductions. Renewals of on going tenancies, unprotected deposits but I still have some questions

              A tenant moved in Oct 2015 and vacated on 29th April. (I have 6 other properties I let just for context). This...
              15-05-2019, 11:18 AM
            • Reply to deposit and damage
              exactlly where is the deposit now ? in the scheme ? or in your pocket ?

              this doesnt make sense to me --

              This particular one the letting agent I use always put the deposit into a scheme themselves and when tenant vacated in 2015 they returned as there were arrears and damages...
              19-05-2019, 23:17 PM
            • Buying a tenanted property
              Hi I'm thinking about buying a tenanted property.Is there anything I should be weary of ? .This would be my 4th and would bring my total income to about 48000 minus mortgage interest etc.Im presuming the new tax rules would not affect me as I would still be in the basic tax bracket ?
              19-05-2019, 19:04 PM
            • Reply to Buying a tenanted property
              if there is a tenant in there - beware
              is there some reason why the property is being sold ? is this a bad tenant ect ?
              not sure if you would be in the basic tax bracket but check that out - in a basic tax and earn 9,000 pounds plus my rental income 4000 pounds minus repairs/mortgage and...
              19-05-2019, 22:34 PM
            • i Have given up letting ......
              just to let you all know i have given up letting - the only property i have now is where my son lives and a let that one out and hes no intention of letting me sell it either to himself or otherwise -
              i did have another property which was quite far away and the problems i had with a tenant with...
              17-05-2019, 16:10 PM
            • Reply to i Have given up letting ......
              yes ive dont know why people on here think i dont fill in my tax return as it seems to be something that people think i do not do when i have been doing it for the past 20 years , although im a low earner and pay very little tax or usually get a return - been letting property out for 20 years and self...
              19-05-2019, 22:30 PM
            • I did not use tenancy deposit scheme help !
              I am a novice landlord and i took over the tenancy from the agent and they gave me the deposit . Tenets moved out and i deducted £160 from there £600 deposit for repairs . Then got a letter from a solicitor demanding 6x the deposit ! After looking in to it i now see i was in the wrong but from...
              08-04-2019, 22:41 PM
            • Reply to I did not use tenancy deposit scheme help !
              i know of a landlord who has over 100 properties and NEVER takes a tenacny deposit simply because of this...
              19-05-2019, 21:46 PM