Question about damage

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Question about damage

    Good morning, I'm new here so, firstly want to take the opportunity to say hello.
    I'm living outside of the UK at the moment and my property in the UK is being rented out. I had an excellent Tennant who has now moved out. He has openly admitted damaging the lounge carpet. I have had a quote to replace it, the carpet is 2.5 years old and good quality. Should I make an allowance in the cost of repair for wear and tear? The carpet is still like new. I have no other issues with the property I just want to be as fair to the ex tennant as I can but also to my self.

    Thank you in advance for any advice.

    What specifically are we talking about in terms of damage? As far as I'm aware, you can't deduct from deposit for fair wear and tear; if the tenant has looked after it as well as reasonably possible and been there a few years and it's slightly worn or light sofa indentation I wouldn't expect a claim to be made for this. But if it is damaged I.e. permanent staining or rips etc then I'd expect a claim to be made proportionate to restoring/replacing the carpet but with age and condition in mind.


      A landlord is entitled to compensation for any loss in value of their asset(s) beyond fair wear and tear that occurred during the lease.

      The formula that they should use, and a court (and the protecting company ADR process) will use is:
      (Cost of the original item and any installation/fitting [not the cost of a replacement] / expected lifetime) * (expected lifetime - actual lifetime).
      That is, compensation for the lost value (life of use) of the item.

      That presumes that the item is entirely ruined and the landlord can show that it happened during the lease.

      If a repair is a more cost effective solution than a replacement (or vice versa), the cheaper option has to be taken.

      Alternatively, an actual repair cost might be claimed, but again, this should be adjusted to reflect the tenant's share of the lifetime (but sometimes this is just meaningless).

      Fair wear and tear is “reasonable use of the premises by the tenant and the ordinary operation of natural forces”.
      When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
      Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


        Get an Ind Inv Clerk to asess damage based on move in report.



          Some how he has burnt the carpet, not a cigarette burn, he said he spilt molten plastic on it, but it has melted into the carpet and cannot be removed.


            You must make an allowance for wear and tear, and you must use the original price, not the replacement price as the basis.

            The allowance for wear and tear is based on the lifetime of the carpet when used by average tenant, not on the rate of wear and tear with the current tenant. Otherwise you would penalise the tenant for not causing wear.

            The life expectancy of landlord quality carpets seems to be about 5 years, so you are talking about a discount of 50%, on cost price, so a little more than 50% on replacement price, unless you used a premium carpet.

            Is the damage such that you will have difficulty letting it or have to accept a reduced rent?


            Latest Activity


            • No deposit strategy
              Hello all,

              I'm hoping those of you with much more experience could help me out. I've been reviewing the way in which i manage my tenancy's and im thinking of no longer taking deposits and instead just bringing rent up to market value. Obviously there is both pros and cons to this idea...
              21-03-2019, 15:44 PM
            • Reply to No deposit strategy
              Sounds like a good idea to me. I might steal it. ...
              21-03-2019, 19:10 PM
            • Reply to No deposit strategy
              I am always wondering the wisdom of not charging a deposit.

              Sure there are less work involved, and creates less hassel, so far nearly always returned the full deposit.

              The deposit for me acts like a gate for tenant fiance, having deposit to pay usually means the tenants has...
              21-03-2019, 18:47 PM
            • Notice to Quit - Tenant Side
              Good Evening Everyone,

              Please see the below.

              Q1 – Where is the rented property located (England / Wales / Scotland / N Ireland)? - England

              Q2 – What type of Tenancy Agreement (TA) is this e.g. sole tenant / multiple tenant / room only? - Multiple Tenants (2
              20-03-2019, 18:39 PM
            • Reply to Notice to Quit - Tenant Side
              The answer is something you will have to agree with your landlord.
              The solution was not to have made an adjustment when the rent payment moved.

              While it's sensible to coincide paying rent with getting paid (which is usually why the date moved), the best solution is to leave the rent...
              21-03-2019, 16:58 PM
            • Reply to No deposit strategy
              Best strategy for keeping voids down and tenants staying longer is to charge the right rent and keep things in a decent state of repair.
              Or allow pets and/or prioritise tenants with school age children.
              21-03-2019, 16:53 PM
            • Reply to Notice to Quit - Tenant Side
              Thanks for the replies - really helpful.

              The ex and I are still on good speaking terms so that side won't be a problem.

              I will speak to the landlord as we are also on good terms and hopefully, we can come to an arrangement.

              Lastly, how is the rent apportioned...
              21-03-2019, 16:34 PM
            • Reply to No deposit strategy
              Thank you both for your responses, so i would be able to offer both options when showing around prospective tenants? The reason for below market rate is to lower void periods and keep good tenants in situ for longer or at least i like to think thats how it works....
              21-03-2019, 16:31 PM
            • Reply to No deposit strategy
              I agree with jpkeates. Properties should be let at the market rents if you're running a business. You're allowed to set the rent as you see fit. The only chance of it ever being likely to become a problem is if after 12 months you elect to increase the rent using a s13 notice to a sum so far in excess...
              21-03-2019, 16:17 PM
            • Tenant with learning - alcohol problems given council flat but no idea what to do.
              Dear Forum,

              Will try and keep this short.

              I had to recently serve notice to a tenant of mine with both learning and alcohol problems.

              Prior to given tenant his section 21, I went to the local council and explained tenants situation, as he had lived in the same...
              21-03-2019, 13:17 PM