Locks on inner doors, the legal position

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Locks on inner doors, the legal position

    I've read various posts about this but nothing says definitively what the legal position is so I am hoping someone can clarify.

    My daughter has just started renting a room in a shared flat in London. The other tenants are strangers; she has a separate individual tenants agreement. She is very concerned that there is no lock on her own bedroom door. I've seen other posts that say that there should be a level of trust with other tenants but these people are - for now anyway - strangers so this is a very worrying situation.

    She has asked her agent to fit a lock. The agent agrees to fit one but says that my daughter must pay a call-out fee of £65. Other posts suggest that as an individual agreement (not shared) it is the landlord/agent's obligation to fit locks but when she pointed that out to the agent the response was: "FYI there is no legal obligation to provide the lock, that would only stand for AST contracts however we operate with licence agreements."

    What are the legalities here? She can't easily afford £65 but even if she could it feels like the agent is trying to palm off some of the expense.

    Thanks for any advice.

    #2
    I dont think the landlord is legally obliged to fit locks even on individually rented rooms. It might be a licence condition if its a licensed HMO but otherwise try asking for permission to fit it yourself

    Comment


      #3
      Many, particularly HMO, landlords pretend that they have licence agreements, to avoid their legal responsibilities. Often these are legally invalid, and there is really an AST.

      If they are trying to argue a licence agreement, they cannot let your daughter have exclusive access to any part of the property, so they cannot allow her to fit locks..

      I would look for a more responsible landlord, as the earliest opportunity, but expect to pay more.

      Comment


        #4
        There is no legal requirement to have a lock (or, conversely, not to have one).


        There is an issue associated with locks and what is being rented by someone.
        If the person renting has exclusive access to a room and shares a kitchen/bathroom/other room(s) the rental is almost certainly a tenancy.
        If a room has a lock that's usually evidence of exclusive possession.

        Some agreements require that the occupant grants access, for cleaning or delivering a meal - in which case, there's an argument that there's no exclusive access and the agreement isn't a tenancy, it's a kind of licence.

        Tenants have more rights than licensees, particularly with regard to notice.

        In that situation, I'd want a lock (and if I were the agent, I'd probably want there to be no lock).
        When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
        Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).

        Comment

        Latest Activity

        Collapse

        • Grade 2 listed - requirement for an EPC
          HantsAgent
          I have a potential client who wants me to rent his Grade 2 listed barn conversion. It's a lovely property and he currently has it on the market for sale with another agent.

          They currently have an EPC for it (even though I don't think they needed one) and it's score is F.

          After...
          02-05-2019, 20:00 PM
        • Reply to Grade 2 listed - requirement for an EPC
          AndrewDod
          I wonder how many perfectly good buildings (and cars, and fridges, and light fittings) have been scrapped or destroyed as a result of these environmental evangelists. I suspect they are responsible for a great deal of environmental destruction (both planetary destruction and destruction of our infrastructure)....
          19-07-2019, 22:39 PM
        • HMO trouble!
          Jamesp1986
          Hi everyone,

          I've been renting a property out to a family and one of their friends for the last 2 years. The council have just told me that I should have applied for an HMO licence for the property as it now fits under new HMO rules. The problem is, that I remortgaged the property as a...
          19-07-2019, 18:43 PM
        • Reply to HMO trouble!
          AndrewDod
          a) Inform the mortgage company "I have been inadvertently fallen within a potential category of HMO through no wish of my own. My understanding is that it remains a single-let tenancy as there is only one AST and one single joint tenant. I am taking steps to evict the tenants as soon as possible....
          19-07-2019, 22:24 PM
        • Reply to HMO trouble!
          KTC
          Single-let doesn't necessarily mean a single family, and HMO doesn't necessarily mean multiple tenancies. It's perfectly possible to be both single-let and HMO.

          What's the definition of single-let in your mortgage? If it just mean a single tenancy, is that what you have? If not, then you...
          19-07-2019, 21:36 PM
        • S21 confusion documents not issued prior
          blinko
          Guys I have a question .

          I issued a tenancy in april 2016 the tenancy agreement was signed. I gave keys to the tenancy 1st march 2016 and protected the deposit and gave him relevant paperwork BUT I didnt get any proof I issued the paperwork.

          So 20th april i re did everything...
          19-07-2019, 11:11 AM
        • Reply to S21 confusion documents not issued prior
          blinko
          Of course but the challenge is not that the safety is is not being observed because for example consider the gas equipment to be faulty in the property blows up house burnt down everybody loses so so for me I would like to think that this is common sense.

          requesting here appears to be and...
          19-07-2019, 21:11 PM
        • Reply to S21 confusion documents not issued prior
          KTC
          I have to respond to this.

          Whether you are pro-landlord or pro-tenant, the safety of the occupiers are a hell of a lot more important than the ability of a landlord to evict a tenant without grounds....
          19-07-2019, 20:48 PM
        • Reply to HMO trouble!
          alex1
          The general rules for HMOs in England and Wales are described at https://www.gov.uk/house-in-multiple-occupation-licence:

          [/LIST]So assuming that the friend of the family counts as a separate household, if there’s five or more people in the property, you probably need a licence. If there’s...
          19-07-2019, 20:43 PM
        • Reply to S21 confusion documents not issued prior
          blinko
          Thanks for your thoughts guy is so yeah this is correct that for sure I am not able to prove that I served the correct documents prior to the tenant moving in and I have served them on three other occasions since as we have renewed the ast everything has been renewed including the positive being we...
          19-07-2019, 20:30 PM
        Working...
        X