Deposit return- end of tenancy with a tenant swap

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Deposit return- end of tenancy with a tenant swap


    Very much appreciate your views on the below issue.

    The concise question is:

    At the end of an AST contract, can the landlord undertake simultaneously a tenant swap and a contract extension against the written wishes of outgoing tenants, and retain the deposit?

    The context:

    We are four tenants sharing a four bedroom flat. All four names are on the contract. We had a one year AST contract. The contract states (as usual) that the deposit will be returned at the end of the contract. Towards the end of the contract, three of the flatmates decided that they would move out at the end of the contract and therefore not renew the contract. One flatmate decided she wanted to stay and find replacements for three outgoing tenants.

    The three tenants wrote to the landlord saying they would not renew, that the contract would terminate at the end of its term, and that the tenants would be released from any obligations after the end of the contract term, and that they expected the deposit to be released.

    Separately, the one flatmate who wanted to stay found three replacements. The landlord then signed a contract with that tenant, plus the three new tenants.

    Now the landlord is refusing to release the deposit to the outgoing flatmates, and telling the outgoing flatmates that it is their responsibility to organise a deposit transfer from the new tenants to the outgoing ones.

    Whilst we understand that this might be the case for a tenant swap during the term of the contract, we do not believe that this should be the case at the end of a contract term.

    The tenant who is staying has a history of not paying bills, and when a tenant swap was performed during the last contract, this tenant asked the incoming tenant to transfer the deposit to her, but never transferred it back to the outgoing tenant. She has done the same thing with the incoming tenants. We (the outgoing tenants) are therefore worried that we will not get our deposits back.

    Is 12 month AST still within fixed Term (12 mo).
    IMO, IF the LL has signed a new AST with the remaining T + your replacements, then your Contract ends on date the new AST commences.


      Has this all happened already - have the original three tenants moved out and the new tenancy begun with the new tenants?
      Or is it about to happen?
      When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
      Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


        Seems to me that it is a new tenancy, not an assignment of the tenancy.
        Therefore the LL should
        1. Return deposit, less appropriate deductions, for the first tenancy.
        2. Produce a new inventory for second tenancy.
        3. Take and protect deposit for second tenancy.


        Latest Activity


        • licensee vs tenant
          i have been given 14 days notice -

          i asked my friend for help and to sort things out if possible, as he works in lettings etc -

          he said to be this is a licensee contract not an (AST) one - (i didnt know)

          basically, i want to know what rights i have to...
          07-02-2019, 20:58 PM
        • Reply to licensee vs tenant
          before this letter, I received a letter of order from the courts saying:

          it is hereby heard in court that:

          the licence agreement is in a different name to the claimant (or something like that)

          im assuming it has something to do with the licence agreement and it...
          16-09-2019, 20:09 PM
        • Problems with a Management Agency
          My son took a 6 month AST out in October 2018.

          In March 2019, the management agency advised if he wanted to stay in the property he needed an extension to the agreement, and charged him £90 for the priviledge - although they gave him nothing in the form of new paperwork. He simply signed...
          11-09-2019, 13:32 PM
        • Reply to Problems with a Management Agency
          As an update ** I would appreciate comments on the legality of the following statement received by my son in an email from the Agents today ***

          They have listed the fees they want to levy on him from his deposit and have cited the following statement

          "£50 + vat for XYZ...
          16-09-2019, 20:08 PM
        • Reply to licensee vs tenant

          How on earth did the landlord's claim get struck out when you didn't bother to turn up?

          16-09-2019, 20:05 PM
        • Reply to licensee vs tenant
          I have received general form of order from the courts.

          The update was, upon hearing the council for the claimant, and upon mr joe bloggs not attending....


          1) CLAIM IS STRUCK OUT

          What does that ACTUALLY mean? who came...
          16-09-2019, 19:50 PM
        • Can I Sue The Council for negligence ?
          Wondering if someone can help me here.
          I live in Council Estate. Having a mortgage and been living here since 2002
          Earlier this year gang of thieves entered Storage Room (doors are secured with number lock) and broken into my storage and tools worth approximately £ 2000 were taken.
          email to council
          16-09-2019, 19:50 PM
        • Making Small Claims Online for Overseas Landlord
          Hi everyone,

          I currently have a TDS adjudication with my ex-tenants ongoing. The tenants' deposit is 4300. The damages i am trying to claim in total is 7000. Even if i do get awarded the full deposit, i'm still short 2700. Im wondering if Small Claims via Money Claim Online (MCOL) is available...
          16-09-2019, 19:24 PM
        • Reply to Making Small Claims Online for Overseas Landlord
          Ah, forget it buddy. Even if you attend, you stand little chance against landlord hating judges. But not attending? Not even worth the court fees.
          16-09-2019, 19:27 PM
        • Repair costs after burglary my responsibility or not
          Hi all,

          A couple of weeks ago burglars broke into my rental property late evening. The tenants were not home. There was damage to the back door. The tenants called the police, who then called a repair man for the door. The tenants did call me, but it was 3am and I was asleep and did not...
          16-09-2019, 13:20 PM