Question regarding how to interpret a clause in the contract

[Drogoth]

Hi guys,

Theres a clause in my contract that I'm unsure how to interpret. It is as follows:

"Not to fix or hang any posters, pictures, photographs or ornaments to the walls or ceilings or woodwork with nails, glue, sticky tape, blu-tac or similar adhesive fixings other than solely with a reasonable number of commercially made picture hooks appropriate for the purpose and to make good at the end of the tenancy"

At first it seems like I'm not allowed to hang pictures at all, but the second half implies that I can if I use picture hooks. I can't imagine a picture hook that didn't use one of the previously listed items (the ones I had in mind were the 3M Command Strip hooks).

Obviously if my hooks leave any damage or marks I will need to repair them, I assumed that from the outset. I'm just concerned that if the agent decides to do an inspection I'll get dinged simply for having put ANYTHING on the walls.

Thanks in advance for any and all responses.

[nukecad]

I posted before but it seems to have gone to moderation for some reason.

The clause is poorly worded, as is usual when someone tries to use semi-legal / officious language to say something simple.

...other than solely with a reasonable number of commercially made picture hooks appropriate for the purpose...

Any commercially made picture hook is going to be 'appropriate for the purpose', they have been made for just that purpose. So its saying that you can use any hook that you buy.

All it prohibits is the use of just nails/screws/or adhesive without a hook, (and incidentally it says that you can't make your own hooks you have to buy them), and that you have to remove the hooks and 'make good' when you move out.

I doubt if that was what it was it intended to say, but that's what it says.


It would have been simpler to say either-
"You are not allowed to hang pictures, shelves, ornaments, or other decoration, anywhere in the property, by any means"
or specify what can be used-
"You are allowed to hang pictures, etc., for this purpose you may only use 'Acme Superhooks' or an equivalent product from another manufacturer".
(Even that's a bit imprecise as to what constitutes 'equivalent').

As the clause wording currently stands it's pretty useless apart from saying that you have to 'make good' before you leave.

[MdeB]

MdeB please explain your interpretation?.

I don't see what there is to explain.
The structure of the clause (excluding the specifics) is "Not to do stuff OTHER THAN SOLELY (i.e.'except') like this".

[mariner]

MdeB please explain your interpretation?
Making good at end of T is fine, but they rarely do it satisfactorily, leaving me free to employ a Contractor to make full restitution at commercial rate to claim from .T.

[MdeB]

Hi guys,

"Not to fix or hang any posters, pictures, photographs or ornaments to the walls or ceilings or woodwork with nails, glue, sticky tape, blu-tac or similar adhesive fixings other than solely with a reasonable number of commercially made picture hooks appropriate for the purpose and to make good at the end of the tenancy"

This says "Don't fix pictures ... UNLESS (other than solely) you do it in the stated manner".

If you do it in the stated manner, then you are OK.

[Hillsy101]

Yep, get clarification in writing before doing anything.
I've just repaired and redecorated and all walls are like new which I expect will last until about the end of the first week of a new tenant !

[Lawcruncher]

Best to ask agent or landlord what they mean. They may mean nail and adhesive free hooks which you can push into the plaster with your thumb. I have them in my flat. If you remove them the tiny holes left are barely visible.

[AndrewDod]

I get pretty irritated when tenants put up any new hooks and nails in walls. It is all very well to maintain that you "will repair them" but in practice this is not possible, usually, without repainting the entire wall, and with 6 month tenancies the walls rapidly turn into a huge mess.
I have 4 or 5 proper hooks in every room, and the tenants cannot put up ANY more.

That said your tenancy agreement seems to permit you to put a couple of picture hooks here and there.