Deposit - What amount is reasonable to deduct?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Deposit - What amount is reasonable to deduct?

    Dear everybody,

    I'm a tenant in a private self-contained studio room that is managed by the landlord who lives in the same house, and his agency.

    Here's my problem: my partner accidentally dropped her mug/bottle of something on the bathroom sink, creating a small chip. It's about 5mm x 2mm, and on the side of the sink. We informed the landlord directly after it happened and he has covered the problem with some silicon. The chip does not stop the sink from functioning at all and is not dangerous due to the silicon covering. The chip is barely noticeable and there is no risk of further damage due to the chip. In other words, the sink is perfectly fine asides from a slight imperfection.

    We're moving out soon and the landlord says he wants to deduct a rather large sum of money from our deposit. He also says he might want more as he'll have to change the sink entirely, but also change the bath, bidet, shower and toilet, as they are all the same color and he 'must have' a bathroom "set". I also know the bathroom is several decades old, and he's been wanting to change it for a while.

    I've also found out that the deposit is not protected under a Deposit Protection Scheme.

    So the question is: what should I do? Should I allow him to take the money from the deposit to change the sink (and probably the whole bathroom at the same time)? Should I argue it should be covered by his insurance? Should I mention the lack of DPS for the deposit? Should I argue it was reasonable wear and tear or that since the bathroom/sink was needing change anyway so we shouldn't pay? Should I have an independent 3rd party assess the damage/cost of repairs and go with that? Should I only pay the cost of repairs to the sink that are reasonable depending on the age and average life of a sink?

    I appreciate all feedback you may have on my situation, even the "you are responsible, pay for it all" answers. I just want to know my options, even if it means I'll probably have to pay for it all!

    Many thanks!

    #2
    Sounds like fair wear and tear to me. To claim an entire bathroom for it is taking the mickey!

    Comment


      #3
      Good guidance on Shelter's website on disputing deductions and also actions you can take to get up to 3x deposit due to landlord flouting the deposit protection laws.

      Stupid (in two ways) landlord
      I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...

      Comment


        #4
        Ok, thanks for your feedback! I appreciate it!

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by Hillsy101 View Post
          Sounds like fair wear and tear to me. To claim an entire bathroom for it is taking the mickey!
          Clearly this landlord is in trouble, and replacing the whole bathroom is a joke. But whatever the case and whatever recompense might be due (I would have thought replacing the basin - which will not be an improvement) dropping something on a basin and breaking it is hardly "fair wear and tear".

          If I was the landlord I would just keep very quiet if the OP is not in fact a lodger (which they might be). But "wear and tear"...... hardly.

          Comment


            #6
            I had a tenant put the hot iron on the carpet burning a nice big brown hole in it. I charged them to replace the carpet in that room but I couldn't charge them to re-carpet the whole flat the same style and colour - I'm sure you get the idea.

            However, the above is irrelevant because the Landlord didn't protect the deposit. Personally, I wouldn't sue someone for the 3x amount but I sure as hell would make sure I got all my deposit back and was allowed to leave when it was convenient to me (he can't use Section 21 either)

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by BJHutchison View Post
              Dear everybody,

              We're moving out soon and the landlord says he wants to deduct a rather large sum of money from our deposit. He also says he might want more as he'll have to change the sink entirely, but also change the bath, bidet, shower and toilet, as they are all the same color and he 'must have' a bathroom "set". I also know the bathroom is several decades old, and he's been wanting to change it for a while.

              I've also found out that the deposit is not protected under a Deposit Protection Scheme.
              Landlord is taking the P***

              Whilst i agree it is certainly not fair wear and tear i would personally use the fact he didnt protect the deposit to my advantage.

              Probably going to get slaughtered by the regulars round here for this next bit but nevermind....

              Tell him you'll agree to not sue him for 3x deposit for failing to protect deposit in exchange for getting your deposit back in full and if he wants to change the bath, sink and toilet he does so at his expense.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Usernametaken View Post

                Probably going to get slaughtered by the regulars round here for this next bit but nevermind....

                Tell him you'll agree to not sue him for 3x deposit for failing to protect deposit in exchange for getting your deposit back in full and if he wants to change the bath, sink and toilet he does so at his expense.
                No, it's completely fair. I'm a Landlord but I don't exploit tenants.

                Comment


                  #9
                  There is a reason new posters are asked to supply this information

                  1 – Where is the rented property located (England / Wales / Scotland / N Ireland)?

                  Q2 – What type of Tenancy Agreement (TA) is this e.g. sole tenant / multiple tenant / room only?

                  Q3 – What date did current TA start dd/mm/yy?

                  Q4 – How long was initial fixed term (6/12/24 months / other)?

                  Q5 – Does the TA state that rent is due weekly? / 4-weekly? / per calendar month (if so, on what same date each month)?

                  Q6 – Did the TA require a tenant damage deposit to be paid? If so, on what date was this paid (dd/mm/yy)?

                  Q7 – If your query relates to a notice for repossession from the landlord (a Section 8 or Section 21 notice) or a tenants's notice to quit to the landlord, please provide the exact date the notice was sent/received (dd/mm/yy).

                  Q8 – Does the landlord live in the same property as the tenant?


                  Your landlord may claim you are a lodger. Doesnt affect what is reasonable, does affect whether you may have to sue to get a deposit back.

                  What colour is the suite and what material (plastic, ceramic?)? I'd be inclined to call his bluff by sourcing a sink, if i hadnt already mended the chip myself. https://www.amazon.co.uk/Cramer-Cera.../dp/B001RQ5TMK

                  He cant legitmately take money for changing everything and even if the sink needed replacing totally he would have to make a deduction for wear and tear based on the life of the sink. He could charge for fitting the sink, that might cost more than the sink.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    He says he is a tenant. We have to assume he knows whether he is on a tenancy agreement or a licence.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      I disagree. A lot of people are poorly informed.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by Usernametaken View Post

                        Probably going to get slaughtered by the regulars round here for this next bit but nevermind....
                        I doubt it.

                        Regular posters on here are scrupulously fair to tenants.

                        Have a read through some past posts.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by Icike View Post
                          I'm a Landlord but I don't exploit tenants.
                          Join the club dear, there's no need to brag about it.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by boletus View Post

                            I doubt it.

                            Regular posters on here are scrupulously fair to tenants.

                            Read through some past posts.
                            I have for the past 3 years.
                            Maybe i worded it slightly wrong.
                            Agreed some are really fair to tenants. Some however i get the impression dont agree with the deposit penalty side of it.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              T can only sue for deposit non-protection, it is Judge who decides extent of Penalty (1-3x deposit).
                              LL can serve a valid s21 if he first returns full deposit paid.
                              A chipped hand basin here is T damage, not FW&T. LL can change whole of bathroom suite if he wishes, but can only claim for replacement hand basin + fitting, less FW&T allowance for original hand basin. The remaining new suite may be considered to be a capital expenditure 'improvement' for tax purposes.

                              Comment

                              Latest Activity

                              Collapse

                              • Convoluted landlord issues (tenant)
                                Chris49
                                Good morning everybody, hope you are all enjoying the bank holiday.

                                Sorry that this will likely be a very long post, I would like to put all the details on the table.

                                To start I moved into my current house share last year in August. Prior to moving in the advertisement has...
                                26-05-2018, 10:54 AM
                              • Reply to Convoluted landlord issues (tenant)
                                KTC
                                Who is listed as landlord in the tenancy agreement?

                                If the person you are living with is not listed, then the fact that he is a brother of the landlord is irrelevant and you are a tenant assuming you're not in some converted flat and the landlord live elsewhere in the same building or similar....
                                26-05-2018, 11:14 AM
                              • PAT Testing
                                wotsitallabout
                                Hello, the house is an hmo and let to tenants. Does the electrician have to NICEIC qualified or is City and Guilds ok please?

                                Regards, nice weekend to you all.
                                19-05-2018, 10:49 AM
                              • Reply to PAT Testing
                                wotsitallabout
                                Thank you everyone, the HSE web page is good, Nukecad.
                                Regards to all.
                                26-05-2018, 11:08 AM
                              • Reply to Convoluted landlord issues (tenant)
                                jpkeates
                                Unless the brother is named on the tenancy agreement as landlord (or joint landlord), his residence in the property won't change anything relating to the AST.

                                Whether you have an AST depends on what you rent. So, if you rent a room in a house with exclusive access - and have access to common...
                                26-05-2018, 11:08 AM
                              • Tenancy break up
                                Captain Birdseye
                                Hi hope someone can help with this situation.

                                Tenants have been with me for over a year and signed joint tenancy. Now on a periodic tenancy the lead tenant has given me 1 months notice to vacate the property due to relationship break down. The other person wishes to stay in the property...
                                26-05-2018, 10:49 AM
                              • Reply to Tenancy break up
                                KTC
                                Assuming statutory periodic and not contractual periodic with terms otherwise. If the tenant's notice was a valid notice to quit (in writing, at least one month if paying monthly, ending on the first or last day of a period of tenancy), then the tenancy would end on the notice expiry.

                                If...
                                26-05-2018, 11:07 AM
                              • Reply to Tenancy break up
                                jpkeates
                                If there is a joint tenancy, the notice by the exiting tenant's notice ends the tenancy (when it expires and assuming it was valid).
                                That ends the tenancy for both of them and the other person will have to leave when the notice expires.

                                If they don't leave, they will theoretically...
                                26-05-2018, 11:01 AM
                              • Attic conversion liability issues
                                Col13
                                Hi, I am new to the letting business, and have just come into possession of a terraced house that I intend to let rather than sell. The attic in the house I am about to let out was converted 35 years ago, without building control or planning. Its fine, but doesnt satisfy modern regs in terms of fire...
                                26-05-2018, 10:18 AM
                              • Dispute with landlord over deposit
                                MarieMB
                                I have recently moved out of a property and requested my deposit back (£2000) from my landlord which has been protected in My Deposits scheme. I paid rent every month on time and gave him the correct amount of notice prior to moving out. I left the flat clean and received an email response from him...
                                13-05-2018, 20:47 PM
                              Working...
                              X