Lying tenant

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Lying tenant

    We had a tenant in our property. Initial agreement was for 6 months from April 2016 but then went on to SPT.
    In June he didn't pay his rent due on 15th of the month. Chased him and got excuses. On 10th July got a text from him saying he had moved out and left a key under the mat for us. He reckoned he'd only decided to move out that day. He'd left furniture and rubbish in the property and damage to carpet and bath. We have struggled to get his deposit back because he won't reply but that is now almost sorted.
    We have since received bills from electric supplier and council. He had told both of them that he had moved out on July 8th and we are therefore liable from that date.
    Because he didn't give any notice he should be responsible for all bills until August 15th.
    I have spoken to both these organisations and got nowhere. The only way I can prove that he is liable is to send a tenancy agreement (which ended nearly a year ago).
    It appears that a tenant can tell these organisations anything and they believe it without question. He has given no forwarding address to them but they still accept what he has said.
    As landlord they are not remotely interested in even listening to what has I have to say unless I have proof.
    It makes me think that the only way forward with our properties is to always have a tenancy agreement in place. Forget SPT and sign tenants up every 6 months .
    Added to all this we are getting dozens of letters every day from finance companies who are clearly chasing him for money. The new tenants will almost certainly have to deal with bailiffs on their doorstep soon. I've tried contacting these companies to explain the situation but again they don't want to know. Only one company was prepared to put a note on his accounts saying he didn't live at the address and assure me that they wouldn't send bailiffs. Everyone else said "we'll keep sending the letters just ignore them. If the bailiffs come your tenants can tell them it's not their debt". Thanks for that. I'm sure the tenants won't be terrified when the bailiffs hammer at their door at 6am.
    This whole thing seems crazy!!

  • #2
    I'd forget about getting utilites to believe you. Just work out a reasonable extra amount to add to deposit request.


    • #3
      There are rules about who is responsible for the council tax. And they relate to residence, not the tenancy.
      If the tenant is in the fixed term of a tenancy agreement, that means they're liable.
      If they are in a rolling agreement and move out, you are liable.

      If the tenancy agreement says that the tenant is liable, you could chase the tenant to repay the council tax they are liable for.

      Same with utilities.
      The person using the utility is responsible for the bills - Again you can try and recover from the tenant.

      Send the finance company letters back with "not known at this address on them" (I use pre-printed stickers and stick them in the post box).

      Having a tenancy agreement always in place is one option, but sod's law says you'd be half way through when the tenant wanted to leave, and the mess would have been slightly bigger on one hand and less on the other.
      When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
      Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


      • #4
        Originally posted by JK0 View Post
        I'd forget about getting utilites to believe you. Just work out a reasonable extra amount to add to deposit request.
        And, of course, this.

        When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
        Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


        • #5
          Unfortunately the deposit doesn't come close to what he already owes. Deposit of just over £1100 to cover two months rent at £900 per month, replacement carpet £200, bath replacement needed, disposal of rubbish, clearing of garden. He 'kindly' left us some furniture which I managed to sell for around £250 to add to the pot.
          I've also had to go to a solicitor to get the Single Claim firm for the dps witnessed and spent hours on the phone sorting out this mess.
          I've totally given up the idea that the utilities would choose to believe me over a man who is probably already in debt to them.
          Hey ho. Just very annoying.


          • #6
            The deposit doesn't limit what you can try and recover from the tenant.
            It's simply a convention designed to make a simple claim easier.

            You can't sell the tenant's goods and use the proceeds to settle their debt without their consent.
            That's the tenant's money.
            When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
            Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


            • #7
              Hmm. If tenant was stupid enough to leave valuable furniture behind, it's JK0's money in my book.

              (Not that that ever happened. All I get left is broken Ikea tat.)


              • #8
                I understand that I could through legal means try and reclaim more than the deposit but this isn't even worth considering. His business had gone into receivership. He owes thousands as an individual and he is almost certainly now living in Poland. Not worth attempting to get any money out of him.
                As far as the furniture is concerned he gave me permission to sell it. When he told me he had left (by text message) he also explained that he had given me the furniture to dispose of. It was most certainly not valuable. The whole contents of the house raised £250. Broken divan beds, 2 ancient settees and 3 broken big backed tvs aren't worth a lot. A few other bits and pieces raised the money but also took our time and energy to get rid of.


                Latest Activity


                • Landlord (me) or agent to register deposit - pros & cons

                  I'm writing my ideal specification for employing an agent - I'm a very optimistic person!

                  So this is hypothetical ... I'm trying to work out if it's better to get an agent to register a deposit or register it myself (even if I pay for a fully managed service).
                  18-09-2017, 19:40 PM
                • Reply to Landlord (me) or agent to register deposit - pros & cons
                  okay... let me spell that out then to see if there are any gaps in my knowledge
                  1. I'd have to make sure that the AST contains a clause that allows notices/PI/etc to be served by email.
                  2. They'd pay me the deposit via bank transfer.
                  3. I'd place the deposit with DPS.
                  4. I'd send them the PI via email along
                  20-09-2017, 09:24 AM
                • Wording on AST Renewal
                  I have been in this property for 14 months now (15/7/16). In at the end of April I received a letter regarding renewal of my tenancy agreement. When reading the letter it states if I wish to renew or alternatively if I wish to vacate the property so I was under the assumption that these were the only...
                  19-09-2017, 19:37 PM
                • Reply to Wording on AST Renewal
                  It is not illegal (currently) for LA's to charge an admin fee for renewal of an AST. Nor is it illegal for a LL to insist that a tenancy does not go periodic but is renewed with a further fixed term. It may not be what you want and you may be right to think it's not fair, but it's not illegal.
                  20-09-2017, 09:20 AM
                • Taking on a lodger and interpreting mortgage terms

                  I'm new to this forum and to the world of property investment. I've recently purchased a second property on a residential mortgage for the purposes of being closer to my workplace for most of the week and also to ease myself into understanding the world of property investment. It's...
                  19-09-2017, 22:02 PM
                • Reply to Taking on a lodger and interpreting mortgage terms
                  For tax purposes, you will have to select which of the two properties you own is your main residence (as CGT is payable on the other one).

                  Your mortgage terms may not allow the situation anyway, as normally a residential mortgage is assumed to be on your main residence, not somewhere you...
                  20-09-2017, 09:02 AM
                • Reply to Wording on AST Renewal
                  I'm referring to Letting Agents that present your options as being "sign a new fixed term and pay the fee" or "move out". This is clearly misleading, as the third option of a statutory periodic tenancy is not put forward. The tenant is in no position to negotiate anything - you either...
                  20-09-2017, 09:01 AM
                • How early do you start advertising?
                  I manage my own properties and have always waited until I have a vacant flat which is ready for letting before I start advertising.

                  I have a tenant due to leave in one month and I am concerned that the later I leave the advertising, the harder it will be to fill the flat, given the time...
                  19-09-2017, 08:19 AM
                • Reply to How early do you start advertising?
                  One month before, usually have a waiting list by the time it is empty....
                  20-09-2017, 08:54 AM
                • Reply to Wording on AST Renewal
                  Yeah, it's shocking isn't it. You sign a legal contract, under UK law, and the least you'd expect is to be able to walk away from it and for any of the terms that you agreed to and signed up for to be just ridden roughshod over...

                  Some people need to take responsibility for their own actions!...
                  20-09-2017, 08:18 AM