Consent - not to be unreasonably withheld.....

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Consent - not to be unreasonably withheld.....


    I own the first floor flat in a house.
    My ownership is long leasehold (152yrs remaining)
    The freeholder is the ground floor flat.

    Many flats up and down the road have added an additional room/dormer window in the roof, so the precedent from a planning perspective is there.
    The lease states that our demise includes the roof and roof space.


    The lease states the following "not without the prior written consent of the lessor (which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld or delayed) to make or permit to be made any alterations or additions to the demised premises"

    We have approached the freeholder to request her consent and she has said no, stating previous issues with subsidence (underpinned in 1994) as her rationale. But we have since had a structural surveyor round who has attested that the loading of a dormer extension is minimal and all the risk can be (over) engineered out.

    Can anyone suggest whether there is an opportunity to push this forwards (through legal process or otherwise) or whether the "unreasonable" clause means we are stuck in a negotiating black hole??

    I am happy to pay for the correct advice, so get in touch....


    In this case I think the freeholder has a good case for not wanting a dormer and can withold consent. Adding additional weight to a property that has had subsidence may invalidate insurance for further subsidence. Problems could occur years down the line when you have sold and moved on.


      Probably should have expanded on the description of "subsidence" but it was merely the bay window to the front of the property, which was subsequently underpinned....

      The structural surveyor was very complimentary of an extension (obviously as he'd be involved in its construction) but also as the roof and fabric of the building would be strengthened, tieing the party walls together and the heavy "red 22" tiles would be replaced by lighter slate.

      If i was to ensure appropriate insurance, before, during and after the work, would this be deemed enough of a mitigator to the "risk"


        This is a major structural project you are talking about with replacing the roof with a different material, tying the buildings together, reinforcing ceiling joists. Party wall consent from both neighbouring properties which the freeholder would have to obtain. Soil may have a tendency to subsidence in the area. The disturbance to the freeholder whilst the building works occur. Unforeseen problems that occur once the project starts. I see red flags everywhere so witholding consent in this case is not unreasonable. Remember you do not own the property, you are on a long term lease.


          It makes sense to get freeholder approval for this before planning....Peter


          Latest Activity


          • Development permission over shared access
            by Davidwd
            I have an unusual situation, I live in a property in a private cut de sac of 5 properties. Property No.1 owns the substrate of the driveway and the other 4 properties own the surface and have right of way over the driveway. Property No.1 wants to build another house on their land and use the driveway...
            29-03-2020, 16:56 PM
          • Reply to Development permission over shared access
            by royw
            If they have right of access over the road then yes they can, a house built in the garden also has that right.
            29-03-2020, 21:35 PM
          • Reply to Development permission over shared access
            by pilman
            Depends if the property at No.1 has a right of way granted over the private road.

            It would imply that No.1 owned the road but transferred the surface to the other four owners who have responsibility for the maintenance of the surface.

            Any decent solicitor would have included...
            29-03-2020, 17:41 PM
          • Chimney pot gas compliance
            by Perfectgame
            Out home is a Leasehold ‘house’ jutting out from a refurbished Grade2* building comprising 55 apartments. Ours is the only one with gas supply to the C19th chimney. We had a gas fire recently installed, but the chimney pot did not comply with the gas fire. According to the freeholder the existing...
            23-03-2020, 15:11 PM
          • Reply to Chimney pot gas compliance
            by AndrewDod
            Is this the first gas fire in this spot -- why does it have a gas supply?
            If you plan to make some amendment to your flat why do you feel other lessees should pay the cost?

            In this whole thread I think we need to be careful of words -- "responsibility" versus "rights"...
            23-03-2020, 17:49 PM
          • Reply to Chimney pot gas compliance
            by JK0
            I wouldn't argue IIWY. Plenty of freeholders not only charge lessees for doing the job, but bung on hundreds in fees also. Sounds like you have consent to do it yourself, doesn't it?
            23-03-2020, 15:48 PM
          • Reply to Chimney pot gas compliance
            by Interlaken
            What does it say in your lease about walls, roofs and structures outside the confines of your 'house' - that is where the answer lies. Ask the Freeholder to explain why he thinks it is not his responsibility. Usually it is the freeholder's responsibility.
            23-03-2020, 15:31 PM
          • Question on Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL)
            by Clulass
            I realise its not the best time to consider a development project given that the world is about to shut down and maybe end, but it helps distract me, from our impending doom.

            So to my question:

            Am I right in thinking that there is no CIL payable.....IF.... you are converting...
            14-03-2020, 21:29 PM
          • Reply to Question on Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL)
            by Interlaken
            CIL payments depend on which local authority you are in. In my area of work and having a Neighbourhood Plan in place 25% of CIL did go to the plan area for use in the community but suddenly our new Unitary Authority banned this so CIL goes into one big pot to be bid for. This does not please me and...
            23-03-2020, 09:34 AM
          • 1 bed to 2 bed conversion
            by slix_88
            Hi all

            First time poster here after lurking on these forums for the past week. I've just put an offer on a large 800+ sqft 1 bedroom flat and was hoping to get your input with regards to the Building Regulations. For a moment, I am assuming the landlord / freeholder may refuse consent under...
            14-03-2020, 14:46 PM