Buy freehold or not: Auction vs enfranchisement

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Buy freehold or not: Auction vs enfranchisement

    I own one of four maisonettes in a block, each valued at £200,000. My ground rent is £12 pa and there are 158 unexpired years on the lease. I've estimated the freehold value at £1,200 (£300 each). Is this about right?

    The freeholder wants to dispose of the block freehold and is proposing £3000 plus his solicitors fees. This was in 2005.

    Myself and another resident are interested due to potential savings on the service charge (buildings insurance and agent fees) which was £510 each in 2006, and increases c.20% pa. Would the residents that are not interested in the freehold have the same cost benefits without any responsibility?

    The freeholder now proposes to dispose of the block freehold at auction, if residents arent interested. I would expect to achieve a better deal at auction and if not then enfranchisement is an option with the new freeholder. Does this make business sense to bid at auction?

    Finally, I am in two minds about sharing the freehold with my neighbour due to concerns that a business relationship would be unsuccessful. I would consider purchasing the freehold on my own at auction or keeping my leasehold. Any views?.

    The value of the freehold is worth approx:-

    Value of £12 X 4 = £48 per annum at 7.5% = £640.00

    Value of reversion £800,000 (4 X £200K) discounted back at 5% over 158 yrs = £360.00. This is based on a generous interpretation of Cadogan and Sportilli. many would argue "nil" for this part of the calculation

    Marriage value - nil

    Therefore value of freehold = £1000 exactly.

    The most important aspect is the containment of professional fees in this matter you could easily spend £2000 plus on the total of your own solicitors and surveyors fees in addition to the Landlords

    I would suggest you set out your valuation (for £10 made payable to "Children in Need" I will do you a nice spreadsheet where you can alter the variables ) and send it to the Landlord and invite him to put forward his valuation but offer instead of £1,000 offer £1,500 and £500 towards his legal costs. Therefore making it clearly worth his while doing a deal outside the Act.

    Any savings you make on the buildings insurance will be enjoyed by the non participators however if there is a provision for a management charge you may feel justified in levying a modest charge for administration.

    You may wish to consider holding the freehold by way of a trust . The trust would hold the freehold and you and the other purchasers would be trustees of that trust. This is useful should anyone go AWOL . Because if they are on the title deeds as a joint owner it is nigh on impossible to remove them. However if the freehold is held as a trust then you simply remove them as a trustee. Your solicitor will be able to give you better advice on this point I am sure

    The landlord may very well do a deal with you and offer to you as an individulal the freehold after having gone down the Section 5 route. The costs of selling at auction an investment of £1k would be enormous. Could even wipe out the £1k sale proceeds!!!


      A. sglacy is correct.
      B. Your L has to offer f/r to collective lessees before selling at auction. See LTA 1987, s.5 et seq
      C. Joint ownership of f/r, if lessees succeed. is on an automatic implied trust. No need for separate Trust Deed. Refer to my CONV. FORUM thread on joint ownership.
      JEFFREY SHAW, solicitor [and Topic Expert], Nether Edge Law*
      1. Public advice is believed accurate, but I accept no legal responsibility except to direct-paying private clients.
      2. Telephone advice: see
      3. For paid advice about conveyancing/leaseholds/L&T, contact me* and become a private client.
      4. *- Contact info: click on my name (blue-highlight link).


        Buy freehold or not: Auction vs LTA

        I appreciate the benefit of both your expertise and would be pleased to make the charity donation. I intend to research according to the list below and then to approach the freeholder:
        1) solicitor / surveyor quotations (as this is the main barrier to proceeding)
        2) LTA 1987, s.5 et seq
        3) buying outside of the act (either as an individual or joint ownership)
        4) refer to my leasehold in relation to the management charge
        5) implied trust and deed trust (either as an individual or joint ownership)


          With each unit worth 200K each, really 250 pds for a 1/4 share of the freehold is a MUST buy situation because it seems that you can recover the cost in 2 years by savings in reduced service charges.

          When you come to sell your property, the offers to buy may be 5K -10K below asking price but if you offer a SOF, you are in a better position to resist accepting lower offers.

          You should put these points to the other leaseholders and get them to participate with you. It makes sense to stop collecting ground rent.

          So don't hesitate and just get a solicitor to put that offer to the landlord. I think sgclacy has done you a big favour and you should send him a cheque for his valuation.



            Thank you

            Thank you sgclacy. I do really appreciate your advice very much and im going ahead as advised.


            Latest Activity


            • Reply to Freeholder/Agent Demanding Money for Repairs
              by eagle2
              It makes you wonder why any freeholder should comply with s20 at all. As you say, it can wait to see if any leaseholder challenges the costs. It does not even need to explain why it did not comply with s20, the only consideration appears to be whether or not the leaseholders suffered any financial prejudice,...
              23-10-2021, 06:34 AM
            • Freeholder/Agent Demanding Money for Repairs
              by SSLA91
              Hi all,

              Long time lurker of this forum and recent new member. Have always found the forum incredibly helpful so thank you! Have now got an issue with our freeholder that I could use some specific advice on (have tried searching for similar posts but to no avail).

              We have recently...
              20-10-2021, 20:28 PM
            • Reply to Section 20 notice
              by Starlane
              Hi Macromia thank you as always for your helpful and sensible input.. one building is saying one thing and another building the other, the usual chinese whispers so I took the bull by the horns and spoke to everyone and I am almost there apart from a Director who wants to do their own thing ( not being...
              22-10-2021, 20:57 PM
            • Section 20 notice
              by Starlane
              Hello I would welcome input on the following:
              Two roofs feed into a valley, the valley is in need of repair, this is a shared responsibility and therefore a shared cost. so how do we issue a section 20 notice when really we need the consent and agreement from two different buildings/landlords...
              22-10-2021, 19:09 PM
            • Share of freehold questions - confused
              by sixunforced
              Not sure if this is the right place for this query but anyway, I'm a first time buyer and have been searching for a property for like two years now (not continuously but on and off and obv covid halted my search for a while). I found a really nice 2 bedroom flat for under £320,000 in a block of around...
              18-11-2020, 21:19 PM
            • Reply to Share of freehold questions - confused
              by Starlane
              Agree thank you...
              22-10-2021, 20:52 PM
            • Reply to Section 20 notice
              by Macromia
              Assuming that the two freeholders have agreed that they will work together and share the costs, they jointly agree what needs to be communicated to the leaseholders and then each freeholder writes to the leaseholders in their building.
              22-10-2021, 20:16 PM
            • Freeholder threatening to cut water off
              by Disraeli-LLH
              I was hoping you would be able to help. We own a ground floor flat LLH(970 yrs remaining). The freeholder owns the house and lets the flat upstairs on an AST.

              The freeholder currently undertaking works including replumbing. We have been on a shared water supply and we connect through their...
              20-10-2021, 15:35 PM
            • Reply to Freeholder threatening to cut water off
              by Macromia
              This is possibly by far the most important consideration, in my opinion.
              If the OP's lease doesn't allow 'improvements' to be charged to service charges, the freeholder cannot require them to contribute anything towards the costs, and would therefore be something that they would have had no choice...
              22-10-2021, 20:08 PM
            • Reply to Freeholder/Agent Demanding Money for Repairs
              by Macromia

              Although when my freeholder applied for dispensation a while back (arguing that the proposed work had to be carried out as a matter of urgency) they were granted dispensation with the First Tier Tribunal commenting that the 2013 Supreme Court Case of Daejan versus Benson meant...
              22-10-2021, 19:51 PM