0% Service Charge / Insurance?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    0% Service Charge / Insurance?

    My situation is that there are currently 6 flats in the building.

    One flat was originaly owned by the FH and his lease had him not contribute any service charge and no insurance. (The flat is now sold on).

    My question is whether this is legal. I know the distribtion does not have to be equal and the FH can proportion at their will as long as it adds up to 100%, but can one flat be completely exempt from all costs?


    Many thanks.

    #2
    Two thoughts:

    1. It's probably legal. Did your solicitor on purchase not alert you to this problem (because presumably yours suggests that the service charge apportionment is 20%)?
    2. You may, may, have some ability to take the matter to LVT to get the % changed, but I've no idea whether you would be successful.

    Comment


      #3
      Your starting point is the lease full wording on %'s. They often have a provision for amendment or alteration. if that is possible, then one route is to ask that it is varied, and if ignored or refused exercise arbitration rights under the lease.

      Depending on the lease wording and the support of others you may have the right to apply to the LVT to amend under sections 35 to 37 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987.

      Contact lease_advice.org for further info.
      Based on the information posted, I offer my thoughts.Any action you then take is your liability. While commending individual effort, there is no substitute for a thorough review of documents and facts by paid for professional advisers.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by LHolder View Post

        My question is whether this is legal. I know the distribtion does not have to be equal and the FH can proportion at their will as long as it adds up to 100%, but can one flat be completely exempt from all costs?


        Many thanks.
        Some leases don't state a %age of the service charge that is payable. Merely that it should be a fair proportion of the service charge, as determined by the landlord. If that is the case with your lease, then one flat being completely exempt would not be a fair proportion.

        As advised earlier, it depends how your lease is worded.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by boletus View Post
          Some leases don't state a %age of the service charge that is payable. Merely that it should be a fair proportion of the service charge, as determined by the landlord. If that is the case with your lease, then one flat being completely exempt would not be a fair proportion.

          As advised earlier, it depends how your lease is worded.
          That is an example where the clauses are variable and can be determined at the LVT or by arbitration
          Based on the information posted, I offer my thoughts.Any action you then take is your liability. While commending individual effort, there is no substitute for a thorough review of documents and facts by paid for professional advisers.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by leaseholdanswers View Post
            That is an example where the clauses are variable and can be determined at the LVT or by arbitration
            Thanks lha, that confirms what I was sort of fishing for.

            Comment


              #7
              Two of the leases (inc mine) have us pay 20%, the other 3 leases which are newer have them pay a share "which is to be calculated by a managing agent acting reasonably".

              Is the exempt flat, therefore, within its rights?

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by LHolder View Post
                Two of the leases (inc mine) have us pay 20%, the other 3 leases which are newer have them pay a share "which is to be calculated by a managing agent acting reasonably".

                Is the exempt flat, therefore, within its rights?
                But what does it say exactly re 20%, is there a review clause? it may be elsewhere in the lease
                Based on the information posted, I offer my thoughts.Any action you then take is your liability. While commending individual effort, there is no substitute for a thorough review of documents and facts by paid for professional advisers.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by leaseholdanswers View Post
                  But what does it say exactly re 20%, is there a review clause? it may be elsewhere in the lease
                  No (apparent) review clause.

                  In principle, say that the leases are all worded correctly, is it possible legally to have one flat exempt from all charges?

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by LHolder View Post
                    No (apparent) review clause.

                    In principle, say that the leases are all worded correctly, is it possible legally to have one flat exempt from all charges?
                    Yes. The question is therefore can you change that, and for that, have a good look at the lease for a review clause. Otherwise you are looking at relying on section 35 to 37 as above.
                    Based on the information posted, I offer my thoughts.Any action you then take is your liability. While commending individual effort, there is no substitute for a thorough review of documents and facts by paid for professional advisers.

                    Comment

                    Latest Activity

                    Collapse

                    • Managing Agents Massively Screwed Up Section 42
                      by divadee
                      We are the freeholders to a block of flats. We own the freehold in a limited company.

                      Apparently one of the flats issued a Section 42 back in April with a date of July for any counter offers.

                      Our managing agents have only just told us about this TODAY and we are way out of...
                      04-08-2020, 12:24 PM
                    • Reply to Managing Agents Massively Screwed Up Section 42
                      by sgclacy
                      The statutory price assuming 85% relativity gives a result of £15,250 (Capitalization rate 6% - but that hardly matters, 5% for deferment rate - in line with Sportelli)

                      So you are down £5,000 - so as I suggested earlier everyone takes a haircut - now it would be £1650 each - it really...
                      09-08-2020, 22:58 PM
                    • Reply to Managing Agents Massively Screwed Up Section 42
                      by divadee
                      We have learnt a bitter hard lesson about this. We will be doing this through our solicitor. We just thought we could rely on the managing agents, as they are company secretary's for the freehold company but live and learn.

                      Hopefully it will all be over one day, us moved out and onwards...
                      09-08-2020, 20:16 PM
                    • Reply to Managing Agents Massively Screwed Up Section 42
                      by divadee
                      S42 amount - 10,052
                      lease length- 64 years
                      property location - central south coast (where everyone is flocking too currently 😉)
                      property value with a long lease - approx £160,000
                      ground rent - £25 doubling every 25 years

                      Thank you for any help in advance....
                      09-08-2020, 20:13 PM
                    • Freeholder Roof Maintenance
                      by Matt F
                      Hello. My flat is rented out - it's a leasehold and managed by a management company on behalf of an investment company who are the freeholder. Recently, while undertaking some other works, the surveyor noticed that the roof was sagging. Further investigation with a structural engineer has revealed that...
                      09-08-2020, 17:48 PM
                    • Reply to Freeholder Roof Maintenance
                      by Anna1985
                      If I am not mistaken you are to have a new roof every 25 years? So it is worth bearing it in mind....
                      09-08-2020, 19:31 PM
                    • Reply to Freeholder Roof Maintenance
                      by scot22
                      Are owners working together ? If so commit to sharing the cost of disputing the charge.
                      I think it essential to engage surveyor with leasehold knowledge to advise both on work and responsibility.
                      It will cost so I suggest an escrow account to protect interests.
                      09-08-2020, 18:25 PM
                    • Building with FH owning commercial units and flats
                      by Stacker
                      Hi
                      I have been reading through a lease for a property with a commercial shop on the ground floor and two flats above...the Flat leases pay ground rent but the service charge apportionment is unclear....it does not state a percentage and I cant see it is apportioned by area the only percentage...
                      09-08-2020, 17:16 PM
                    • Reply to Tools for RTMC & Block self-management experience
                      by scot22
                      The list is long because it is an onerous responsibility. My mantra was is everyone does a little no-one has to do a lot. Unfortunately everyone didn't.
                      Remember people will move and new owners have different attitude. My experience is limited to one block but also voluntary organisations....
                      09-08-2020, 12:50 PM
                    • Tools for RTMC & Block self-management experience
                      by stokey83
                      Hi,
                      1) We shall soon acquire the management function of our block (RTMC) and do not intend to appoint a managing agent. What are the simple tools available online for managing company accounts / service charges, contractors, maintenance/repairs, building docs, etc?
                      2) I am also interested...
                      07-08-2020, 15:48 PM
                    Working...
                    X