Dilapidated Flat

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Dilapidated Flat

    In a block of 24, unfortunately one flat has become dilapidated. The new owner has bought cheaply. She is now demanding the Freeholder pays to refurbish it claiming they have been negligent. Is there a reasonable case ?

    #2
    What is the precise nature of the 'dilapidation'?
    And what does the lease say about the maintenance responsibilities of the leaseholder and freeholder?

    Comment


      #3
      Because service charges are for decorating the insides of everyone's flat?
      To save them chiming in, JPKeates, Theartfullodger, Boletus, Mindthegap, Macromia, Holy Cow & Ted.E.Bear think the opposite of me on almost every subject.

      Comment


        #4
        Usually inside the flat, the re-decoration is paid by the leaseholder of the flat.

        In the communal areas , the maintenance work is paid by the service charge account , paid by all flats in the building .

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by scot22 View Post
          claiming they have been negligent
          In what way?

          There is a fine line between irony and stupidity. If I say something absurd please assume that I am being facetious.

          Comment


            #6
            Many thanks for the prompt and helpful replies. Mainly, I suspect, due to lack of ventilation and heating there is some damp. She says the Freeholder should have stopped this happening by work to outside wall !? Efforts, including engaging surveyors whose advice has been followed, have been made to ensure wall is in good repair.
            Our lease has leaseholder responsible for interior and freeholder exterior wall.

            Comment


              #7
              What utter nonsense.

              The new buyer should have had a survey before they purchased.

              Comment


                #8
                The previous owner might have had a case. The new owner I think only for claims for problems during their ownership. But ianal.

                Presumably she got a great price as it was so dilapidated
                I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by scot22 View Post
                  Mainly, I suspect, due to lack of ventilation and heating there is some damp. She says the Freeholder should have stopped this happening by work to outside wall !?
                  If a leaseholder can show that internal maintenance is required because of a freeholder's negligence (e.g. a failure to meet external maintenance obligations according to the terms of the lease), they will potentially have a claim against the freeholder and be entitled to expect the freeholder (the freeholder, not the other leaseholders via the service charges) to pay the cost of that maintenance.

                  If what you describe is accurate, in this case it sounds like the leaseholder is either clueless or is intentionally trying it on, and it is unlikely that they have much likelihood of making their case, if the freeholder stands their ground and forces them take the claim to court (if they don't drop it).
                  I would expect that them buying the lease cheaply might also go against them.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Thanks all. It was a great price, significantly below market value, plus in further negotiations a reduction to pay for any further work. This was identified by a surveyor. She is not clueless.....
                    Artful in my research I read that can only claim for her ownership period.
                    It is all incredible.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Condensation is a common problem in flats. It looks different from a leak. Is it a top floor flat? Do other flats have the problem?

                      Comment

                      Latest Activity

                      Collapse

                      • Freeholder failure to maintain
                        by Catastrophiser2020
                        What to do about a freeholder that doesn't maintain property?
                        Unfortunately right to manage is not an option
                        There is damage to my property due to FH failure to repair...
                        22-01-2022, 20:36 PM
                      • Reply to New Government proposals re leasehold reform
                        by sgclacy
                        As I said earlier if a property is burdened with a ground rent of £300 - £500 per annum and it rises by the RPI or doubles every 20//25 or 33 years how is that the stuff of nightmares ?

                        We are regarded in a world stage to have a very advanced legal system and as seen as a safe place to...
                        22-01-2022, 20:15 PM
                      • New Government proposals re leasehold reform
                        by perigee
                        I see that there are proposals to simplify the extension/enfranchisement procedures and reduce the costs for lessees, including abolishing marriage values. I appreciate that these are early days but is there any guidance from professionals acting for landlords - as distinct from lessees - on these...
                        12-01-2022, 17:53 PM
                      • Reply to New Government proposals re leasehold reform
                        by Lawcruncher
                        A lease is the grant of an estate in land. The estate granted is a "term of years", a label which describes what is in the tin. Virtually all leases have conditions attached or implied, but the conditions are not essential. A lease may for convenience be regarded as the combined grant of a...
                        22-01-2022, 19:51 PM
                      • Who can view CCTV?
                        by Luverlyjuberly
                        I'm having a problem with someone spitting in the communal areas of our block of flats. The person is the boyfriend of a tenant. She has already been spoken to about the incidents but I think it likely that he denied it was him or claimed it was a accident (as he had a nasty cold when the spitting...
                        22-01-2022, 19:30 PM
                      • Section 61 and my Landlords rights for an order of possesion
                        by andyg1
                        Hi All

                        I wonder if anyone can set my mind to rest, i am the leaseholder of the flat in question . In 2008 i employed a firm of solicitors to extend my Lease . It was a 99 year lease granted in 1978 and it was eventually extended for an additional 90 years . During negotiations...
                        20-01-2022, 16:35 PM
                      • Reply to Section 61 and my Landlords rights for an order of possesion
                        by sgclacy
                        In 55 years time, you may be faced with the possibility that the freehold is able to buy your flat at its market value.

                        You undertook that exercise in 2008 so if you were just 21 then this "problem" would concern you when you are 90 - if freeholder can satisfy the court about...
                        22-01-2022, 15:26 PM
                      • Reply to New Government proposals re leasehold reform
                        by sgclacy
                        It is the financial burden that the ground rent imposes on the property that needs to be valued correctly.

                        The consumer credit act sought to value one financial product with another, by having the APR quoted to assist the purchaser make an informed choice. My proposal would be that the...
                        22-01-2022, 15:09 PM
                      • Neighbour’s automatic garden watering system
                        by Joubert
                        I am the director of a freehold company which has a number of flats in a purpose built mansion block.

                        One of the lower ground flats has a serious damp issue which has been addressed several times over the years at considerable cost by the building. The damp is coming through the floor...
                        18-01-2022, 10:03 AM
                      • Reply to Neighbour’s automatic garden watering system
                        by Section20z
                        Seriously ??? If it's really the neighbours water then just dig a couple of meter deep trench along the boundary and put a French drain it.
                        £80k ? Someone's having a laugh with you...
                        22-01-2022, 14:03 PM
                      Working...
                      X