Spy cameras in communal areas

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Spy cameras in communal areas

    I was interested in this week's case concerning Ring door bells with cameras and audio. As a result of this, talking to a neighbour, I have learned that one of the tenants has installed a spy camera in the corner of the communal area, outside her flat.

    It has apparently been there a couple of years and I had no idea it was there.

    What would you do about it? Should she have informed us that it is there?

    #2
    Installation of the camera will require ICO registration by the owner if there is a recording device (which could be cloud storage) attached.

    If it's in your AST that the Tenant ask you before installation then yes they should have. You can write to request its removal but I guess not much else if they refuse.

    Most CCTV systems do have a way to block out certain areas so they cannot be seen, heard or recorded. Of course, the tenant could show this and then just change it when you've gone.

    Other than that, this is an issue between tenant and neighbour - which if it's been there 2 years then I can't see that the neighbours been that bothered before this week.

    My views are my own - you may not agree with them. I tend say things as I see them and I don't do "political correctness". Just because we may not agree you can still buy me a pint lol

    Comment


      #3
      We are all long leaseholders living in a block of nine flats. It is not the managing agent or freeholder who has put this camera up. It is one of the leaseholders.

      It may have been up two years but the point is that I, for one, didn't know it was there. She has been able to see and hear everything that has gone on in our quite large hallway and we had no idea that that was happening.

      If I'm outside then I know that anybody can see me. If I'm inside, with no doors open, I used to think I was on my own but I wasn't. If I stood and talked to someone then she could see us and hear what we were saying.

      I now know another leaseholder has a camera looking outside the flats. Last year I thought it was a bit odd that several times when I went down to put stuff in the bins, he would appear. It seemed a bit too often. Did he spend his whole life looking out of his kitchen window? In fact I almost wondered if someone had set up a spy camera in my flat so they knew when I was going out. I knew it was far-fetched but when things happen odd ideas come into your head!




      Comment


        #4
        The question is going to be if a communal area is 'public'; and I don't really see how it could legally be classed as 'private' - it's public although restricted access.

        So the laws on recording in public places would apply

        Comment


          #5
          Check your lease but I'm almost certain it's a breach of the lease. He should be told to remove it without delay.

          Comment


            #6
            I think that it shouldn't be allowed but the lease was written in 1962. Actually, I'm not totally opposed to it but all the leaseholders need to be informed if there is a camera in the communal area.

            Comment


              #7
              lol then just pop a note in each letterbox.

              You dont have to say who you are, simply that you're advising them of the cctv existence.
              My views are my own - you may not agree with them. I tend say things as I see them and I don't do "political correctness". Just because we may not agree you can still buy me a pint lol

              Comment


                #8
                I expect you are not allowed to put anything in a communal area not cause a nuisance.
                I would object to being filmed. They can distort any video and I just don't accept being filmed without my consent. What next in communal areas ?

                Comment


                  #9
                  Can you film someone in a public place?

                  This is aimed at amatuer film makers, but covers all filming in public places:
                  https://www.theiac.org.uk/resourcesn...in-public.html

                  A communal area is a privately owned public place, much as a shopping center, sports stadium, or museum, is a privately owned public place. So unless the owner of the communal area puts a restriction on filming/recording of that communal area it's quite legal to film it, and to make a recording.
                  Whether it's done covertly or openly doesn't matter, it's legal to do.

                  If the lease says nothing about it, which I doubt it will then it's not prohibited.
                  (A ban on putting items in the comunal area because they may cause an obstruction probably wouldn't cover a wall/ceiling mounted camera. eg. a video doorbell. The lease may say something about tenants not putting 'fixtures' in the communal area, but possibly not).

                  As said above if someone has put a camera up then you can simply tell everyone about it, anonymously if you like.

                  Or you can complain to the owner of the communal area and ask them to put a ban in place.
                  But if they do put a ban in place and someone breaks that ban then it's a civil matter and not a criminal one.

                  And just in case you were tempted; small (tiny) wifi cameras are cheap these days so replacing a broken one isn't onerous.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    I don't really think it is like a shopping centre because, there, you know anyone can see you. If I walked downstairs and no-one was around I did feel that I was alone. This week I stood and talked to someone by the front door and I thought we could not be overheard but I was wrong. Now I am wondering what we talked about. I won't do that again.

                    Mind you, they do say that listeners hear no good about themselves!

                    Comment


                      #11
                      So, what have you decided to do?
                      My views are my own - you may not agree with them. I tend say things as I see them and I don't do "political correctness". Just because we may not agree you can still buy me a pint lol

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Well I have been thinking about that! I will email the committee and say that I hadn't realised that these spy cameras have been in place for some time. What I would like them to do is either bring it up at the next residents meeting

                        Or find out how many of these spy cameras there are in the communal areas, advise the other residents where they are and they can be left.

                        Or put up a notice by the front door saying that CCTV cameras are in operation in the area

                        Or, ask the managing agent for advice

                        They will probably say they are there to protect their properties from intruders etc. I will say that that's all very well but they were filming us when we thought we were alone.

                        I'm not at all a very private sort of person but don't like the idea that I could have been spied upon.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Perhaps get used to the term CCTV for Safety & Security rather than Spy Cameras lol

                          It works for the Police and Council.



                          And as said previously, IF these images are being recorded in any way then there needs to be a registered Data Controller with the ICO (and an annual fee paid).

                          Warning Notices do need to be displayed and carry the contact details for the Data Controller too - any court case relying on the images could fall flat if this is not done.

                          There also needs to be a log of who has been given access to the data - if the Police wish to view it, the Data Controller can demand a written request from a SENIOR Police Officer first.


                          If I was in your position, a short note popped into each letterbox would be sufficient.

                          HOWEVER, if you think the owner of these cameras is (shall we just say) "suspect" then I would be more concerned about it. And don't shake his hand (sorry lol)


                          My views are my own - you may not agree with them. I tend say things as I see them and I don't do "political correctness". Just because we may not agree you can still buy me a pint lol

                          Comment


                            #14
                            I have no objection to CCTV and I'm sure it could be invaluable if someone in the flats got burgled. When it's on all the time, or movement activated, and it can possibly be used to spy on other residents, then I think it's fair to call it a spy camera. Amazon has got a whole range of what it calls 'spy cameras'.

                            The Cambridge dictionary definition of CCTV is "a system that sends television signals to a limited number of screens, and it is often used in shops and public places to prevent crime".

                            Comment


                              #15
                              We're going off topic a little but re-read what you said lol

                              You have no objection to CCTV to catch a burglar in the flats.

                              But you object to it being on all the time or motion activated.

                              Erm, how do you suggest it's going to catch that burglar in action?


                              Back on topics again - I guess you've highlighted your own options so hope it gets sorted for you.

                              Though going back to the start post - you mentioned it's a female tenant who's installed the camera, in which case I'd be even less concerned about it (probably get shot for such a comment these days)
                              My views are my own - you may not agree with them. I tend say things as I see them and I don't do "political correctness". Just because we may not agree you can still buy me a pint lol

                              Comment

                              Latest Activity

                              Collapse

                              • Reply to Who owns loft space when it is not stated in lease.
                                by Babyspice
                                vagabond does ur lease state to whom has the roof been demised to? Who is responsible for insuring/repairing and rebuilding (in case of fire)?

                                i am currently progressing a loft conversion application with the FH, and even though my lease does not specifically mention the loft space, since...
                                28-01-2022, 18:27 PM
                              • Who owns loft space when it is not stated in lease.
                                by vagabond
                                Hi, I own a top floor maisonette and share the freehold 50/50 with the ground floor maisonette. I would like to build a loft conversion and after checking my lease I'm unsure who the loft space belongs to. All I can see in my lease is "the right for the lessor/owner/occupier of lower maisonette...
                                21-01-2022, 14:45 PM
                              • Reply to Is there a limit to what constitutes a premium?
                                by Babyspice
                                Annoyingfreeholder good news for u. U have a qualified covenant (not absolute). This means that ur FH cannot unreasonably withhold consent. Now to check if a premium is payable or not to the FH, u need to check the extend of ur demise. Eg if ur demise includes internal and external walls and provided...
                                28-01-2022, 18:17 PM
                              • Is there a limit to what constitutes a premium?
                                by nomadiclord
                                Evening all,

                                I have a two bedroom garden flat and a second child on the way. So I am planning on an extension to give us more living space. Although the garden is demised to me, the lease clearly states that I cannot cut maim alter or injure any of the principal timbers or walls...
                                ...
                                15-05-2021, 19:06 PM
                              • Reply to 2 misconceived court claims and last minute back down by landlord
                                by Starlane
                                Thank you and in all this time they have never addressed any repair issues only repair issues to the directors flats so my flat has probably depreciated in costs and may be harder to sell with the damp issues. Yes they only way out now is to go to the FTT and have constant battles or sell.
                                28-01-2022, 16:49 PM
                              • 2 misconceived court claims and last minute back down by landlord
                                by Starlane
                                Over the last few years the current directors have made simple mistakes and brought court claim after court claim against me causing me stress, distress and lots of wasted time and energy. I have tried to be reasonable call meetings to discuss and collaborate and still they carry on and NO I cant remove...
                                27-01-2022, 18:30 PM
                              • Water Leaks Again and Again and Again...
                                by bigalxyz
                                Director of RMC - 11 flats in London
                                There seems to be a long standing problem with the plumbing in the bathroom of one of the flats. 4 water leaks in the last 18 months, causing damage to the flat below.

                                Is there anything the RMC can do to compel the leaseholder of the problem flat...
                                28-01-2022, 16:05 PM
                              • Reply to AGM cancelled.
                                by Gordon999
                                Companies Act 2006 for small companies replaces the CA1985.

                                Any member of a small company with 5% interest can call a EGM meeting by giving 21 days notice.

                                The agenda for meeting can be ; electing new directors.

                                The meeting chairman can be the third director....
                                28-01-2022, 14:08 PM
                              • AGM cancelled.
                                by Grumio
                                Is this legal?

                                A bit of background, we currently have three directors, we are allowed to have up to a maximum of eight directors according to the articles of association. We are all leaseholders. Last summer the three directors decided to hire a managing agent who is now in charge of the...
                                26-01-2022, 00:46 AM
                              • Reply to Leaseholders with no information on the residential association accounts.
                                by Gordon999
                                You need to vote in new directors and get them registered at Companies House first .

                                1. 5% members of a small company can call a meeting to vote in new directors but the organiser must give atleast 21 days notice before meeting day. ..


                                The meeting agenda ( purpose)...
                                28-01-2022, 13:32 PM
                              Working...
                              X