Leak into downstairs flat, am I liable?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Leak into downstairs flat, am I liable?


    I rent out an upstairs flat, which was a 1930s built house which has been converted into two flats. The water waste for the kitchen/bathroom goes out through the wall to outside. The downstairs flat, which is owned by a housing association, has an extension built at the back of the property which has boxed in the external waste pipe for my flat.

    That pipe has leaked in the roof cavity of the extension for the flat below and brought the ceiling down. Ive never had access to inspect those pipes as they’ve been boxed in.

    I’d say the extension is around 10years+old and I’m not sure if the company that owns the property built it or if they bought it when it was already built.

    Am I fully liable?

    I wouldn't have thought so if they have boxed in the pipes which prevented you from carrying out maintenance inspections. Are they asking you to pay? You might need a solicitor to respond if they are since I assume they will have more money to hire lawyers themselves.


      Thanks for your advice. They haven’t asked for payment yet, the estate agent is managing the contact. This occurred 1.5month ago and I haven’t heard since, I’m asking as a precaution incase they do ask for payment. They did state they were going to send invoices.


        Have a look at the licence granted under the lease for the ground floor flat, there may be an indemnity that runs with the land to which your LA lessee is subject


          Can you not claim it on the insurance? Is the downstairs flat the freeholder of your flat and vice versa?


            Unless you've been negligent in some way, the only way you'd be liable is if you have caused the leak in some way or have some sort of commitment to the owners downstairs to keep the pipes in a good state of repair (which would be extremely unusual).

            Pipes do sometimes leak, it happens - the downstairs owner should sort it out without involving you.
            There's a presumption that the person upstairs automatically has a liability, but that's not the case.
            When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
            Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


            Latest Activity


            • Rtm
              by mags69

              Can anyone tell me whether the value of a flat is adversely affected if the development is self managed by an RTM? I've been told that the value is reduced by 35% and I would not be able to get a mortgage. Thanks
              25-02-2021, 17:20 PM
            • Reply to Rtm
              by mags69

              Thanks for your input.
              25-02-2021, 19:05 PM
            • Reply to Rtm
              by Callan1
              Off hand I can only think of a flat having a very short lease that might affect a property’s value to such a degree.

              I think a flat managed by rtm company might increase its saleability.
              25-02-2021, 18:35 PM
            • Director of a Residential Management Company Issue
              by NewGuy123

              I have been googling most of the day to try get some answers/explanation for the issue we have and i ended up reading through some of your topics and the answers have been really helpful so i am going to try my luck! I am slightly paranoid writing this as this is a public forum and...
              24-02-2021, 13:18 PM
            • Reply to Director of a Residential Management Company Issue
              by eagle2
              That happens too, in fact it seems to be the freeholders who are the most guilty of abuse who are the first to threaten legal action.
              Much as I am enjoying this debate, I am aware that we are departing from the original question.
              25-02-2021, 16:43 PM
            • Fire doors as front doors to flats
              by Codger
              Some leaseholders have installed front doors that have upvc frames and glass panels. It is likely to be mentioned in a fire risk assessment for the block so I wonder what we can do to enforce a recommendation to install firedoors.
              22-02-2021, 11:07 AM
            • Reply to Fire doors as front doors to flats
              by flyingfreehold
              Boards at different blocks are approaching this differently. We have a few blocks under professional management and the managing agents have variously either gone for a door upgrading scheme with every door upgraded to a new FR30 or a scheme whereby the doors are retrofitted with smoke seals, self closing...
              25-02-2021, 15:51 PM
            • Reply to Directors of rmc have breached the s.24 tribunal order to hand over management
              by SHill
              Sorry I have read it wrong

              Regulation 1985 Table A shall apply to the Company
              Regulations 73- 80 (inclusive) are not included and 84,87,94 to 97 (inclusive ) are not included which makes 81 included.

              My mistake....
              25-02-2021, 15:48 PM
            • Directors of rmc have breached the s.24 tribunal order to hand over management
              by SHill

              Can someone give me advise. I have been successful at First Tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to Appoint a Manager Pursuant to S.24 LTA 1987. The Tribunal appointed a manger but the Directors of the RMC (Respondent) has not comply to handover the information by June 2020.
              26-01-2021, 14:15 PM
            • leak
              by JackBluebird
              Hi I have experienced a leak to my apartment and the apartment below has also experienced the same issue (the video evidence is very similar (water coming in through an extractor vent into my bathroom)).

              I had a contractor out to assess my property who said there was no leak from my apartment...
              25-02-2021, 13:45 PM