Former leaseholder's right to challenge historical service charge after a sale?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Former leaseholder's right to challenge historical service charge after a sale?

    Hi, I’m just about to sell my long leasehold flat (in England), but I’d like to be able to apply to the First-Tier Tribunal after the sale in order to recover some of the service charge overpaid by me over the past few years. (I need to do it after the sale as the buyer is insisting on a "clean slate" before completion.) I know I would win if I were still the leaseholder, but does a former leaseholder still have standing to make a claim and recover overpaid charges, or does that right transfer to the new leaseholder upon sale? And if the latter, is there any way of reserving this right to the seller, or having the buyer assign the right back to me, in the sale contract?
    Many thanks.

    All rights under the lease of the flat transfers to the next leaseholder so you do not have any rights after registration of new owner at Land Registry. Any unspent service charge money is normally held and spent by the managing agent and is not returned to individual leaseholder after sale of each flat.

    You should send an enquiry to the the legal advisor at to ascertain if you have any claim under "clean slate" condition required by the buyer.


      Thanks for taking the time to reply. I feared as much, although it seems very unfair that a leaseholder's right to challenge the service charge for current/recent years is effectively extinguished when the flat is sold. Most applications to the FTT are made at least 6 months after the relevant service charge period, to give time for the summary of costs to be prepared and the evidence of expenditure to be provided, so whenever the flat is sold there will be a delay in gathering that information, possibly 18 months or more if the sale occurs near the beginning of a period. Is that just an anomaly in the law?


        No..Its not an anomaly..Leases are contracts between The Leaseholder and The Freeholder, these 2 parties will change over the years but the contract remains between whoever is LH and FH at the time. After the sale, you will not be the LH, the new owner will be.

        This is different to most contracts which are between you as an individual and another party.

        Only think to check is what happens if you make an application to FTT/Court now but you arnt the LH by the time its heard.
        Advice given is based on my experience representing myself as a leaseholder both in the County Court and at Leasehold Valuation Tribunals.

        I do not accept any liability to you in relation to the advice given.

        It is always recommended you seek further advice from a solicitor or legal expert.

        Always read your lease first, it is the legally binding contract between leaseholder and freeholder.


          It is a very good point, at the time of a sale, the accounting information is usually between 6 and 18 months old and in extreme cases, it can be much older. The solution is to attempt to reach agreement with the freeholder/management company prior to selling or make an application to a Tribunal before selling. I cannot see that any purchaser would agree to commence legal proceedings and account to you for any benefit.


          Latest Activity


          • Group Freeholder wants to replace new windows unnecessarily - what to do?
            by Boab
            Hi all

            This is a request for help for my partner who is the long term leaseholder on a ground floor flat/maisonette in a detached house owned by a large group.

            The freeholder is demanding all the double glazing be replaced at a cost IRO £8000. My partner simply cannot afford...
            21-01-2021, 14:33 PM
          • Reply to Group Freeholder wants to replace new windows unnecessarily - what to do?
            by Gordon999
            £8K for replacing plastic windows on the ground floor is over the top.

            Make an application to your local Magistrates Court for a declaration the windows at your flat at ( Address ) were replaced 2 years ago and do not require to be replaced again. Speak to the court manager about how...
            22-01-2021, 02:44 AM
          • Deposit on Freehold Purchase
            by chris1544
            We have decided to buy the freehold of our two flat building. Our surveyor has negotiated a price with the freeholder that we are happy with and this has been done by agreement rather than through the statutory route. The freeholder has written to us and asked for a deposit to “initiate the process”...
            21-01-2021, 23:37 PM
          • Reply to Deposit on Freehold Purchase
            by Gordon999
            I suggest you check the freeholder title and site plan at Land Registry is registered under the name of the freeholder and the plan corresponds to the boundary for your building and postcode. before proceeding ?

            The deposit for Sale and Purchase of the freehold title should be paid...
            22-01-2021, 02:31 AM
          • Reply to £390 Overdue Charges on £50 Ground Rent Balance
            by J-T
            Thankyou both. The letter is being posted tomorrow. I will inform once I receive a reply.
            21-01-2021, 22:51 PM
          • £390 Overdue Charges on £50 Ground Rent Balance
            by J-T
            I've read around on here and read the FAQ, but I'm hoping for a little more direction on the following:

            I purchased a long (999yr from 1976) leasehold BTL in 2018. I have just refinanced the property and the mortgage company asked about the ground rent account, which spurred me into thinking...
            18-01-2021, 20:31 PM
          • Negotiating a lease extension
            by LizLease
            Hi all, I am new to the forum.
            I am looking to extend the lease on a flat (currently under 70 years).
            I received a quote from the freeholder and a valuation from a surveyor (£3k lower than the freeholder's figure).
            I spoke to the leasehold Advisory Service who said to ask the surveyor...
            21-01-2021, 12:44 PM
          • Reply to Negotiating a lease extension
            by Gordon999
            Try offering £11,000 and agree to £12,300 which is the starting point by hmrc for charging capital gains tax at 18% or 28% .

            Make the offer for 90 years statutory extension and peppercorn ( NIL ) ground rent which is your legal right to seek under the L&T act 1993.
            21-01-2021, 22:23 PM
          • Block of flats - freehold or leasehold
            by ritfor
            Hello Folks,

            Sorry if this is in the wrong place. I think it might fit into many of the forums. Point me in the correct direction if needed though!

            I'm looking to invest in a block of 4 flats. Large terraced houses split into 4 self contained flats some while ago, with planning...
            21-01-2021, 16:56 PM
          • Reply to Block of flats - freehold or leasehold
            by Codger
            I had a block like you describe and sold it about ten years ago. It's much better to own the free hold
            ​​​ otherwise someone else is cutting your profit and deciding what to spend on improvements. If you own the lot you can make new leases if you want to sell piecemeal. I think leases are...
            21-01-2021, 21:10 PM