how to reject s.42 notice

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    how to reject s.42 notice

    Freeholder received s.42 claim for lease extension. The time to respond with counterclaim is almost up.
    Not using lawyers.
    The leaseholder suggested a really low value and made some errors in the claim.
    The freeholder wants to reject the s.42 on grounds of stupid low offer and get it dismissed. How?
    Can freeholder respond with - I think - a s.45 counterclaim - rejecting outright the claim? And that is enough? Or does the freeholder have to apply to court separately to ensure the s.42 is invalid, rejected, and to ensure no new claim can be made within the next 12 months?

    What amounts to a very low claim such that it make it invalid is a moot point.

    It you regard the claim as invalid the lessee can immediately serve another, so I am not sure there is a great advantage in so doing. The 12 month rules applies if a valid notice is served and the lessee withdraws. The 12-month rule would not apply if the notice is invalid

    Perhaps you should consider regarding the notice as valid EXCEPT for the premium proposed and put down what you think is the correct premium. There are various points you need to consider in the counter notice. They are set out in Section 45


      An invalid notice is not a notice , it is just a simple letter and doesn't need to be "declared invalid" by a court.


        Just one question - how does the lessee officially withdraw? Are they supposed to follow up their s42 with a legal retraction or a simple letter saying they withdraw?


          A simple letter referring to the offer they made and stating that they wish to withdraw it.

          Until they do they are still liable for certain costs you may incur, such as a valuation by a surveyor and the solicitors costs in verifying that the notice is valid


            thanks for that sgclacy. Its all very complicated and confusing. just to clarify - that if they decided to withdraw that's when they can't serve again for another 12months?


            Latest Activity


            • Right to Manage Costs
              by Pariah81

              I am part of a residents association that is exploring right to manage (RTM).

              We are a 30 flat block in the Ealing area.

              We want to get advice on the process so how much should we be expecting to pay for our legals?

              I'm also aware we have to pay...
              21-09-2021, 13:48 PM
            • Reply to Right to Manage Costs
              by sgclacy
              Reminds me of a riddle from the book by Feldman and Spratt - Five Frogs on a log

              Five frogs are sitting on a log.
              Four decide to jump off. How many are left?
              Answer: Five
              Because there's a difference between deciding and doing....
              23-09-2021, 20:14 PM
            • Reply to Right to Manage Costs
              by Gordon999
              Yes , many years ago I was organiser to buy the freehold , some leaseholders agreed to participate but when the time came to pay their share of the purchase funds, they dropped out.....
              23-09-2021, 19:50 PM
            • Reply to Right to Manage Costs
              by lampshade
     would be very interesting especially as our Freeholder, who owned the company that Managed the building gave the contract to another fringe company, and the fees doubled to £10k pa....and if 12 of us leave that will cause fee problems for the remaining 2 flats, but not our problem....will...
              23-09-2021, 17:50 PM
            • Reply to Right to Manage Costs
              by Section20z
              Yes, you should be able to. We did something similar for one of two blocks with same name just different flat numbers. First step is to get 6+ owners to take part and form a company to serve the notice. A reluctant freeholder will fight every step so you may need professional help to get it right....
              23-09-2021, 17:35 PM
            • Reply to Right to Manage Costs
              by lampshade
              Interesting....I have one lease in a total of 3 blocks totalling 34 flats. All managed under one managing agent appointed by the FH.
              But each block, whilst seemingly are all connected there are 3 separate blocks of about 11 flats in each. Each block has both front and back entrance, and unique...
              23-09-2021, 15:29 PM
            • Reply to Reasonable solicitor fees?
              by eagle2
              You can insist on a summarised time record showing the number of hours spent by each grade of solicitor on the different aspects of the work involved. You can then compare it with your own solicitor's time records in order to raise a specific complaint.

              Intead though, I suggest that you...
              23-09-2021, 14:42 PM
            • Reasonable solicitor fees?
              by LizLease
              After six long and tedious months of negotiations to extend the lase on a flat, we are nearing completion and I have been sent the final balance.

              I was shocked to be presented with a £2,700 bill for the freeholder's solicitor fees. When I first inquired about renewing the lease, the freeholder...
              21-09-2021, 17:17 PM
            • Reply to Negotiating a lease extension
              by sgclacy
              Does that include the surveyor fee ?...
              23-09-2021, 14:36 PM
            • Negotiating a lease extension
              by LizLease
              Hi all, I am new to the forum.
              I am looking to extend the lease on a flat (currently under 70 years).
              I received a quote from the freeholder and a valuation from a surveyor (£3k lower than the freeholder's figure).
              I spoke to the leasehold Advisory Service who said to ask the surveyor...
              21-01-2021, 12:44 PM