Application to the FTT for determination of breach of covenant?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Application to the FTT for determination of breach of covenant?

    Hi Guys,

    Wanted to start a separate post with a few legal queries regarding applications to the FTT for a formal determination for a breach of covenant.

    Firstly, is it called the FTT (LVT) or the property chamber? We know its changed names quite a few times, but would like to know a final answer on this and what exactly has changed recently?

    Secondly, were going through a dispute regarding a breach of lease by some tenants that recently moved in and have been locking their barking dog in to bark and sqeual all day beneath our home. The lease states "no nuisance pets" and our solicitors have determined from our evidence that the pet is a nuisance and demanded they remove the animal which they have refused to do.

    We've recently learnt that we can apply to the FTT for a final legal determination of a breach of covenant for nuisance for not much money, this seems too good to be true? As surely it costs them a fortune to look into these cases and make determinations?

    Our managing agent has refused to act on their breaches or remove the animal but we feel they will have to act if the FTT judges the animal to be a nuisance proving a breach of covenant.

    Our question is really, are we correct on the above? Does the FTT really have the power (and time) to look at the evidence and make a final determination?

    Do they have powers to demand the removal of the nuisance animal / that the breach of lease be ammended?

    We have found this form to start the process:

    https://www.gov.uk/government/public...e-has-occurred

    Is this the correct place to start? And who do we put as the respondents... the Freeholder? The Owners of the flat? Or their Tenants who own the nuisance dog?

    Any help/guidance much appreciated.

    Thanks!




    #2
    As has been stated in your other thread here, you can only take action against other parties to your lease.

    You cannot get a tribunal to determine whether your neighbours have breached their lease (which is what you are trying to do) unless their lease specifically includes covenants that are with you and not just with the freeholder.

    It is likely that only your freeholder can start legal action to determine whether or not your neighbour is in breach of their lease.

    The only possibility that might let you 'start the ball rolling' (so to speak) is if your lease states that the freeholders have covenanted with you to uphold the terms of the leases against other leaseholders - in which case you could potentially start a case to determine whether or not the freeholder is in breach of their responsibilities under your lease.


    For the other part of your question:
    If you are in England it is now FTT (Property Chamber). In Wales (and I think Scotland - but may be wrong) it is still the LVT.

    Comment


      #3
      As we have stated in the other post - we are all party to the same lease as leaseholders (we all have the same lease). The freeholder has a responsibility to uphold the covenants against all leaseholders... by not upholding the terms of lease against the offending leaseholder the freeholder is in breach of lease. Hence we are applying to the FTT for a breach of covenant that the freeholder has failed to act...

      Comment


        #4
        You have absolutely zero chance of success.

        Comment


          #5
          FYI - we have been to the tribunal before under different circumstances with a previous neighbour/leaseholder in the same block of flats, and the freeholder was found to be in breach of lease for not taking action against previous owners/leaseholders party to the same lease in the building for a previous breach of lease...

          Comment


            #6
            Please explain section20z... the freeholder has already been judged to be in breach of lease by a senior lawyer, so we dont agree.

            Comment


              #7
              Macromia... we are all party to the same lease, and the freeholder has a legal obligation to enforce the covenants against ALL leaseholders.

              Comment


                #8
                Presumably we put the freeholder a the 'respondent' to the FTT and not the leaseholder?

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Tw1982 View Post
                  The freeholder has a responsibility to uphold the covenants against all leaseholders... by not upholding the terms of lease against the offending leaseholder the freeholder is in breach of lease. Hence we are applying to the FTT for a breach of covenant that the freeholder has failed to act...
                  What clause / covenant in your lease do you believe the freeholder is in breach of?
                  Please quote the clause / covenant word for word.






                  Originally posted by Tw1982 View Post
                  Please explain section20z... the freeholder has already been judged to be in breach of lease by a senior lawyer, so we dont agree.
                  You have repeatedly said things like this on your other thread, and it has repeatedly been pointed out to you that the lawyers / solicitors that you go to for advice don't "judge", or "determine", whether or not there has been a breach of the lease.
                  All that this senior lawyer has really done is told you that in his (or her) opinion, you might have success in a court or tribunal (and he might have been lying when he told you that because he knows that he will get paid regardless of whether you win or lose).

                  Comment


                    #10
                    You are trying to prove a negative which is impossible.
                    And even if you could prove to FTT that the freeholder has breached the lease (as you claim you have already done in the past) what remedy do you expect against the Freeholder?

                    ​​​​​

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Tw1982 View Post
                      Macromia... we are all party to the same lease, and the freeholder has a legal obligation to enforce the covenants against ALL leaseholders.
                      No they don't.
                      They have the legal right to enforce covenants against individual leaseholders.

                      So far you have given no indication that there is anything in your lease that would obligate the freeholder to take action against one leaseholder because of complaints from another leaseholder.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Macromia... the lease states "a leaseholder must not permit nuisance pets or other animals". If youd read the previous post youd see we have over 60 videos of the nuisance animal, 100 pages of formal complaints to the managing agent of dog nuisance, sound diaries, video diaries, and medical reports proving the effects the nuisance dog has had on us, and an "opinion" as youve put it from a senior lawyer that we've used before and has won every case we've fought. He is very balanced and very trustworthy and has saved us thousands of pounds over the years.

                        Section20z... the remedy, assuming a breach of covenant would be removal of the nuisance animal as the lease clearly states "no nuisance pets"

                        Comment


                          #13
                          If the freeholder doesnt act after a breach of lease has been proven at the FTT then potentially we can take him to court for breach of contract for not enforcing the terms of lease against the other leaseholders party to the same lease...

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Tw1982 View Post
                            ... the lease states "a leaseholder must not permit nuisance pets or other animals". If youd read the previous post youd see we have over 60 videos of the nuisance animal ...[etc.]
                            That's between the freeholder and the leaseholder.
                            Whatever evidence you have that the dog should be considered a nuisance is irrelevant if your lease doesn't contain something that specifically requires the freeholder to act on any complaints you make against other leaseholders


                            Originally posted by Tw1982 View Post
                            ...and an "opinion" as youve put it from a senior lawyer that we've used before and has won every case we've fought. He is very balanced and very trustworthy and has saved us thousands of pounds over the years.
                            So? It's still just his opinion.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by Tw1982 View Post
                              If the freeholder doesnt act after a breach of lease has been proven at the FTT then potentially we can take him to court for breach of contract for not enforcing the terms of lease against the other leaseholders party to the same lease...
                              Only if the terms of your lease obligate the freeholder to enforce the terms of the lease at your request.

                              Comment

                              Latest Activity

                              Collapse

                              • Lease extension - should I pursue non statutory?
                                by theta
                                I received a section 42 notice for a statutory lease extension for a flat where I own the freehold. There are 87 years remaining on the lease, and ground rent review is every 10 years linked to RPI (next review 2027).
                                My appointed managing agent recommended a solicitor with experience on this,...
                                25-09-2020, 07:56 AM
                              • Reply to Lease extension - should I pursue non statutory?
                                by sgclacy
                                A statutory lease extension offers just one option – 90 years added and a peppercorn rent and the law commission now feel that there should be greater flexibility and that lessee should be given the right to extend the term keeping the rent terms the same or extinguishing just the rent but keeping...
                                26-09-2020, 22:14 PM
                              • Reply to Lease extension - should I pursue non statutory?
                                by sgclacy
                                Flying freehold is quite correct, but his words have incorrectly interpreted by the OP.

                                Both individuals and companies can roll over gains resulting from statutory lease extensions. Individuals pay CGT and companies pay corporation tax on their gains. If the individual or company holds...
                                26-09-2020, 21:26 PM
                              • Freeholder's consent
                                by stressed12
                                I am freeholder and tenant in a converted Victorian house. The lessee of the top flat wants to sell and asked for written consent for:
                                1) right to pass from a driveway that leads to a parking spot. His lease mentions the right to park in that spot (along with another lessee, so 2 flats have the...
                                28-04-2020, 18:46 PM
                              • Reply to Freeholder's consent
                                by Section20z
                                Why did you tell them ?
                                If they want a ridiculous amount then just back out, no great loss and unlikely they will take action for the breach.
                                If they do then deal with it then ....
                                26-09-2020, 20:53 PM
                              • Reply to Freeholder's consent
                                by Vednaik
                                Hi, I want to buy freehold of my semi-detached property and have approached the landlord. The lease is for 800 years and ground rent is 7£ per annum. The previous owners have done a loft conversion . I being a first time buyer was unaware of the consent thing and had trusted that solictors will sort...
                                26-09-2020, 20:36 PM
                              • Front garden to parking
                                by mikkimolly
                                I have a long lease on a flat in a Victorian converted building with a demised parking space on the driveway. The Landlord is currently selling the two other flats in the building, which previously were tenanted. To make them more profitable he has concreted over the front garden to create a parking...
                                25-09-2020, 15:10 PM
                              • Reply to Front garden to parking
                                by mikkimolly
                                Thanks Scott, yes this has been a wakeup call for me, believing that the church would act in good faith. Being told that their changes would not impact my lease, when i asked for further and better details of the changes was arrogant and patronising. I have mulled this over and decided to seek specialist...
                                26-09-2020, 19:00 PM
                              • Reply to management and maintenance costs for parking court
                                by AndrewDod
                                What does your lease say?
                                What the lease says is what you do.

                                I doubt the lease and RTM order say that they can charge a massive fee for managing the car park....
                                26-09-2020, 17:29 PM
                              • management and maintenance costs for parking court
                                by cooked
                                sorry this may in the wrong forum but I could not see a forum title which was relevant
                                my wife and I own (leasehold) two flats in a block of 3 flats
                                each of the 3 flats has two parking spaces in a 30 space parking court
                                in 2018, we became the RTM for the building but the parking court...
                                25-09-2020, 22:30 PM
                              Working...
                              X