Permission to let problems

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Permission to let problems

    Hi
    Wondered if someone could help with some advice please.

    My long leasehold flat has been rented for a few years. By oversight prior permission was not sought from freeholder in advance. The lease says that prior permission must be sought and a fee of £45 paid for each sublet. To rectify the situation (after threats from freeholder) I sent a cheque for £45 +VAT for each past sublet (x6). They responded saying the fee was now £175 per sublet. I declined to pay, arguing that the charge was not reasonable. This was about 1 year ago. I have since made another sublet and sent them a cheque for £45 +VAT for the new one (as per lease). They have replied that the fee is now £230 +VAT per letting. They are also claiming £800 legal costs which I have refused to pay.

    The lease states the fee payable is : “£45.00 (or such higher sum as may from time to time be reasonably stipulated by the Landlord)”. (Lease date is 2014).

    What would a reasonable fee be? How can this be established - or will I have to contest it at Tribunal?

    Many thanks in advance.

    #2
    Make a complaint to your local MP and ask him or her to join the APPG for Leasehold Reform.

    Make a complaint to CMA which are collecting evidence for prosecution of some freeholders for leasehold abuse.

    Comment


      #3
      Are you communicating with them via email? Keep hard copies of these exchanges as evidence.

      Comment


        #4
        “£45.00 (or such higher sum as may from time to time be reasonably stipulated by the Landlord)”

        That gives you a choice. You either pay (a) £45.00 or (b) such higher sum as may from time to time be reasonably stipulated by the Landlord.

        To whom does the lease say the fee is payable?

        Comment


          #5
          Reasonable for a charge of £45 in 2014 would simply be plus 6 years RPI increase. So not £230 but is it worth arguing at FTT ? Probably not.
          Personally I would ignore it and certainly not tell them every time you have a new tenant. How would they know ?

          Comment


            #6
            Thanks Lawcruncher. The lease doesn't actually specify although it's pretty clear form the context that it's payable to Landlord. I wondered if there are any Tribunal cases I could cite. I think they are expecting to get away with unreasonable charges by making lease forfeit threats for breach of lease and hoping I won't want to fight.

            Comment


              #7
              Section20z,

              £230 +VAT every 6 months for doing nothing is excessive in my opinion and I can't afford it. And I don't want to have to lie. I'm quite happy to honour the lease and pay a reasonable fee. According to Bank of England £45 in 2014 is worth £50.76 in 2019.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by sid1956 View Post
                The lease doesn't actually specify although it's pretty clear form the context that it's payable to Landlord.
                Please quote the whole clause. You mention the fee is for permission, but it sounds more like a fee for registering notices.

                Originally posted by sid1956 View Post
                I wondered if there are any Tribunal cases I could cite. I think they are expecting to get away with unreasonable charges by making lease forfeit threats for breach of lease and hoping I won't want to fight.
                You do not need that. I repeat the comment I made above: That gives you a choice. You either pay (a) £45.00 or (b) such higher sum as may from time to time be reasonably stipulated by the Landlord. That is equivalent in form to: Give the landlord a box of chocolates or a bunch of roses. In that case it is clear that you have a choice of giving chocolates or roses. The same goes for £45.00 or a higher fee. You are the beneficiary of faulty drafting! ( I am assuming that the words you quoted are taken from the lease.)

                Comment


                  #9
                  This is the whole clause:
                  Within one month after the date of every transfer, death, grant of probate or administration, assent transfer mortgage charge, sublease or other event or document relating to the Property to give notice thereof in writing to the Landlord and in the case of a document produce a copy of it to the Landlord or their managing agents or solicitors for registration and to pay a fee of forty-five pounds (£45.00) (or such higher sum as may from time to time be reasonably stipulated by the Landlord) plus Value Added Tax at the appropriate rate for each such registration of a document.

                  You are right, it's a fee for registration. I appreciate the point you make and the literal interpretation is correct. Might a Tribunal not say that the real meaning is obvious - that the Landlord is entitled to charge a higher amount - but only a reasonable one.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    There is no saying what a tribunal might find. The thing is though that although we know what was intended, it is not what is said. A literal interpretation, though it produces an odd result does not produce a ridiculous one.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      So - can we have a second line of defense based on reasonableness of the fee. How would we approach that question?

                      Comment


                        #12
                        You are the current lessee party to the lease and have a right to insist any charge in excess of £45 is outside the lease and not payable unless judged as reasonable and fair by the FTT. Ask the other side to make an application to the FTT.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by sid1956 View Post
                          So - can we have a second line of defense based on reasonableness of the fee. How would we approach that question?
                          The fee is expressed to be for registration. Registering an underlease takes no longer than it does to write down the details of the tenant, the term and rent - 5 minutes maximum. Even £45 is excessive. You can get 3 nights bed and breakfast for £230. Why have they incurred legal costs? What advice did they need that cost £800?

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Presumably £800 is solicitor's fee for writing a letter threatening forfeit of lease. They also want me to sign an underletting agreement - mostly indemnifying them for anything the tenant does. And they want to put a term limit on the permission (6 months) - whereas the lease says notification is required for any "new" contract. If a tenant stays after 6 months (holding over) then I don't think any new permission is required. Is that right? Thanks.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              They also want me to sign a 4 page Sublet Agreement adding new covenants. Do I have to sign this? - it doesn't say anything about a sublet agreement in the Lease - just that permission will not be unreasonably withheld.

                              Comment

                              Latest Activity

                              Collapse

                              • Reply to Freeholder owns a number of leases, is this something to avoid?
                                by Macromia
                                All leaseholders should be treated equally and in accordance with the terms of the lease. Unfortunately this isn't always what happens.

                                Hypothetically, you have the same protections where the freeholder is a company owned by leaseholders, and run by directors who have a controlling interest,...
                                28-09-2020, 01:19 AM
                              • Freeholder owns a number of leases, is this something to avoid?
                                by phatfish
                                I am buying a flat in a block of 11 where the landlord is a small company with two directors. One happens to be the owner of the lease i would take possession of.

                                The other does not own any of the leases directly, but some family members own at least 4 of them (maybe one or two more, i...
                                27-09-2020, 17:43 PM
                              • Reply to LPE1 Questions
                                by Macromia
                                Managed area will include the building and any grounds, gardens, outbuildings, etc., basically anything that the leaseholders may be required to contribute to the maintenance of via service charges.

                                Common parts would include communal corridors, gardens, etc., and may also include parts...
                                28-09-2020, 01:08 AM
                              • LPE1 Questions
                                by comm1985
                                For the purposes of LPE1 could someone clarify the below:

                                1. Slightly confused by the terms 'Managed Area' and 'Common Parts'. For a building of 4 standalone flats with no communal areas or entrances.

                                a) I assume the "Managed Area" is the building containing the...
                                27-09-2020, 18:28 PM
                              • Reply to management and maintenance costs for parking court
                                by Macromia
                                Without knowing what your "parking court" is like, I would think that all of the charges that you list would likely be considered reasonable - apart from the management fees (personally I would consider the accountancy/audit charges to be of no value whatsoever to leaseholders, and therefore...
                                28-09-2020, 00:53 AM
                              • management and maintenance costs for parking court
                                by cooked
                                sorry this may in the wrong forum but I could not see a forum title which was relevant
                                my wife and I own (leasehold) two flats in a block of 3 flats
                                each of the 3 flats has two parking spaces in a 30 space parking court
                                in 2018, we became the RTM for the building but the parking court...
                                25-09-2020, 22:30 PM
                              • Reply to Freeholder owns a number of leases, is this something to avoid?
                                by phatfish
                                Hi Scot,

                                Thanks for the reply. Yes i worded that badly, all i meant was the lease has a provision that states that all leaseholders are responsible for an equal share of a service charge and i have no reason to believe one lease is different from another.

                                I did familiarize...
                                27-09-2020, 20:52 PM
                              • Reply to management and maintenance costs for parking court
                                by cooked
                                The fees charged to us for the parking court have risen slightly in the last few years and there was no reduction when we took over the management of the building.
                                The management of the parking court remained with the original management company even though the management of the building itself...
                                27-09-2020, 19:27 PM
                              • Reply to Freeholder owns a number of leases, is this something to avoid?
                                by scot22
                                The Freeholder MUST abide by the lease and any leasehold ownership can be problematic. I doubt if you have to pay whatever is demanded. It would have to be expenditure justified by the lease and be reasonable.
                                I suggest looking on the LEASE site where there is a wealth of information.
                                27-09-2020, 18:25 PM
                              • Responsibility of window frames
                                by charlie8899
                                Hello - I hope someone can help. I own a new build flat and have a faulty window that needs replacing. This will be quite costly and requires erecting scaffolding. I was surprised to hear from the building management company that windows are the responsibility of the leaseholder. This doesn't seem right...
                                23-09-2020, 08:05 AM
                              Working...
                              X