Breaches of Licence to Alter

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Breaches of Licence to Alter

    I am trying to give some help to my Aunt, who is 90 and lives in a basement flat, where she is suffering excessive noise from the flat above, not necessarily caused by loud music, etc. but just the noise of people walking about on bare floors - the tenants in that flat have a reciprocal issue as they can hear (and have complained about) her TV and even phone calls. The upper flat owner (who lets it to the tenants) made some alterations to the flat and was granted a Licence to Alter by the Freehold Company (of which my Aunt is a joint Director, along with 2 other occupiers in the building).
    One of the terms of the licence was that a specific type of sound absorbing matting should be laid down in the flat. The matting was not laid, but the owner has refused access for proper inspections, ignores letters and emails, and has done nothing but be obstructive. My Aunt's fellow Directors, though helpful in sending letters, seem unable or unwilling to pursue the case - it doesn't affect them directly. She has had to get her solicitor to write to the Freehold Company, which of course risks damaging her (currently good) relationship with the other Directors.

    This has been going on for 3 years and she is at her wit's end. What other recourse does she have? I see there is a First-Tier Tribunal System that seems to offer relatively straightforward access to the law in Property matters, but I am not sure if it would cover her case? And even if it did, the only acceptable solution is to have the work done as specified, could such a tribunal make (and enforce) such an order? Any thoughts/suggestions would be most welcome.
    I would add that her flat was twice flooded as a result of the works, a temporary repair was effected but the landlord has not provided evidence of permanent, capillary soldered repairs (as specified by the Freehold Company's Surveyor), or gas safety certificates, so the noise issue is something of a last straw, she cannot even enjoy watching her TV and she fears further incidents.

    #2
    Better to move to a quieter property on the ground floor. No sense for a 90 year old lady to be living in a war zone.

    Comment


      #3
      Moving is a major upheaval and a well known cause of stress at any age, let alone when when you're 90, so in addition to being forced out of her home, she would suffer financially (moving costs, conveyancing, and the effect of the current dispute on the value of her property). Meanwhile the perpetrator gets of scot free.

      Comment


        #4
        I agree with Gordon, knowing how stressful these disputes can be. It is demanding trying to get any legal decision. When you've got it there is then an arguably greater challenge in getting it enforced. Assuming she could find a suitable change the pragmatic solution is to move.
        is the Freehold with a residents management company ? If so demand action.
        Does your Aunt get on with flat above ? Is it possible to work with them ? If it is with a letting agent perhaps complain to them. Cause as many problems as you can for the person, like to be polite in my language, who is disregarding his obligations.
        I have always found LEASE to be helpful. A gov funded body that gives free qualified legal advice. The site is comprehensive and informative.
        Finally, if I may be personal, it's heartening to know of someone assisting an elderly relative.

        Comment


          #5
          I believe that if your aunt has been fighting a losing battle for 3 years , it better for her to move away.

          If you want to help your aunt, you could apply to the local Magistrates Court for a court order requiring the upstairs flat owner to insert sound insulation under the floor boards. Go to your local Magistrates Court and speak to the Court Manager.

          Comment


            #6
            Thanks for your replies. I have looked at LEASE which does contain some useful pointers that I can follow up. I will also speak to them when I have marshalled all the facts. I can also look at the Magistrate's Court option, though I am still interested to learn if the First Tier Tribunal has jurisdiction in cases such as this, and whether their judgements are enforced.
            Even at 90 my Aunt is a feisty lady of strong opinions, I am reluctant to encourage her to move as I know she is very attached to her current location in spite of the difficulties of the last 3 years.

            Comment


              #7
              Your best option may be to email the relevant tribunal for your region, explain the situation, and ask if they consider it to be under their jurisdiction.

              Comment


                #8
                Good for her. Good for you giving her respect. Enforcement is usually a problem.

                Comment

                Latest Activity

                Collapse

                • Reply to Voting Rights and Required Percentages
                  by Andrea Cunningham
                  Is it 3/4 of shareholders, or 3/4 of a quorate meeting? Could be 4 people needed in the former case, but possibly only 3 in the latter.

                  Likeliest is that most decisions are made by a majority of votes at a quorate meeting - if there is a 50/50 impasse then the chair has a right to a casting...
                  23-01-2022, 20:56 PM
                • Voting Rights and Required Percentages
                  by Arizona
                  Good Morning. I'm brand new to this site so I apologise if this question is in the wrong section.

                  My wife and I live in a self contained apartment in a converted old house. There are five apartments in total, occupied by five separate couples. We are all leaseholders and we collectively,...
                  23-01-2022, 08:52 AM
                • Reply to Enfranchising from a company I'm already a member of.
                  by Andrea Cunningham
                  Well over a year later - BUMP!
                  23-01-2022, 20:41 PM
                • Enfranchising from a company I'm already a member of.
                  by Andrea Cunningham
                  The estate I live on has 2 blocks. All the leaseholders are members of the company which owns the freehold and manages the block ("Share of freehold").

                  Suppose one of the 2 blocks decides to go it alone - so in other words gain the freehold from a company they are already a member...
                  04-10-2021, 12:07 PM
                • Isn't there any obligation to be insured?
                  by Sarah17
                  Hi All,
                  I recently bought a flat and learned since that the flat above is a regulated tenancy. The current tenant has moved in 1972. The flat is in a very shabby state, and I am worried about it (safety concerns, fire risk...etc). I wrote to the landlord and didn't receive any answer yet. A few...
                  16-01-2022, 17:57 PM
                • Reply to Isn't there any obligation to be insured?
                  by Sarah17
                  Hi All, many many thanks for your answers. As it is a regulated tenancy (beginning in 1972), indeed the rent is very low, the LL is doing the minimum expecting the tenant to move. I had the opportunity to look inside, it sounds in a very bad state, but I don't know up to which point this is just a...
                  23-01-2022, 17:14 PM
                • Adjoining garage roofs
                  by NaomiB
                  A year ago I bought a run down garage with a leaking roof. I thought I would be able to fix it with Flashband but it was impossible. I got a new roof and door and let it out to a neighbour. The flats are managed but the garages are not.

                  Yesterday I got a text from the owner of the adjoining...
                  10-01-2022, 07:19 AM
                • Reply to Adjoining garage roofs
                  by NaomiB
                  I'm afraid there is not the slightest chance that the roofs will all be done at once so that one's out. Although the flats are managed well, the garages never have been. The other garages in that block of six are owned by the freeholder. With him, it's a case of 'I won't do anything unless I can get...
                  23-01-2022, 17:05 PM
                • Reply to Adjoining garage roofs
                  by JK0
                  I don't think you'll hear from your roofer, Naomi. I refer you to what I said before.



                  Whatever he does will be done grudgingly, even if you get trading standards involved. Do you really want him to come back to do more of the same?

                  As before, the roofs need all...
                  23-01-2022, 16:48 PM
                • Reply to Adjoining garage roofs
                  by NaomiB
                  I wrote to my roofer on 10 Jan but have had no reply. On Thursday my son went up to get better pictures. They show that the rubber has flapped right back and needs re-fixing. I wrote to him again on Friday but haven't had a reply. I am worried he is going to say it's wind damage but surely, with...
                  23-01-2022, 16:15 PM
                Working...
                X