Retrospective License For Alteration Consent Fees

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Retrospective License For Alteration Consent Fees

    I am a co-landlord and also live in my 1 bed flat - my underlying lease has 997 years left on it - the entire property is held in a Declaration Of Trust between the 4 landlords - I carried out some alterations a couple of years ago by changing my internal floorplan to create an open plan kitchen and gained verbal consent from my other co-landlords. The clauses of my Lease that are in 'breach' are:

    "8.2 – Not to make any internal, non-structural alteration or addition to the Property, or alteration to the plan, design or elevation of the Property, without the prior written consent of the Landlord, such consent not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed”

    “8.3 – Not to install, alter the route of, damage or remove any Service Media at the Property, without prior written consent of the Landlord , Such consent not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed”

    Schedule 4, paragraph 10.2 (Water Pipe materials)
    “10.2 – To keep in good repair and watertight condition all water pipes, wastepipes, baths, showers, sinks, lavatories and all appliances and equipment which use or contain water and regularly inspect the same and to ensure that no water escapes from the Property”

    Schedule 5, line 17 (Floor Coverings)
    "Not to live in the Property unless all floors (other than in the kitchen and bathroom) are covered in good quality carpeting and underlay or with other effective sound deadening material and not to replace the floor coverings existing at the date of this Lease except with those which provide sound transfer reduction values of 4 decibels for impact noise and 18 decibels for airborne noise transfer"


    The issue being consent was not gained prior in writing. I have submitted all the certificates and warranties of all the work carried out but now whilst trying to obtain retrospective consent the other co-landlords have instructed solicitors wanting an undertaking starting with £3000 +VAT and will need a surveyor report and I fear how much that'll cost me given the excessive solicitor fees... my Lease states regarding the Landlords reasonable fees:

    "Schedule 4 paragraph 7 Costs
    To pay to the Landlord on demand the costs and expenses (including any solicitors’, surveyors’ or other professional fees, costs and expenses and any VAT on them) reasonably and properly incurred by the Landlord (both during and after the end of the Term) in connection with or in contemplation of any the following:
    7.1 the enforcement of any of the Tenant Covenants
    7.5 any consent applied for under this Lease, whether or not It is granted"

    I appreciate I need to go through the process of gaining retrospective consent but is there anyway of limiting the excessive fees I am being quoted doesn't seem reasonable at all - any advice would be greatly appreciated - thanks!

    #2
    The issue being consent was not gained prior in writing.

    Given that:

    (a) Consent was given orally;

    (b) The other freeholders stood by while you carried out the work;

    (c) The other freeholders have waited two years to go to a solicitor;

    I think that a court would overlook the technicality that the consent was not given in writing.

    You do of course have the problem that if you want to sell you have nothing in writing. I suggest biding your time and if the other freeholders want anything in the future your price will be a waiver of the technical breach.

    Comment

    Latest Activity

    Collapse

    • I've breached my lease
      by pcuk1979
      Hi there. I hope someone can help me because I have been frantic with worry for 3 days now. This is a bit long!

      I bought a leasehold flat in July 2014. Since I've been here, I have done everything to it to bring it up to a modern acceptable standard. Note that the floorpan of the property...
      12-07-2020, 14:00 PM
    • Reply to I've breached my lease
      by sid1956
      First of all, you should not be stating or implying to anyone, least of all your landlord, that you have breached the lease. An admission of a breach saves the landlord the trouble of having to determine that a breach has occurred and has no benefit whatsoever to you.

      From your description...
      12-07-2020, 21:15 PM
    • Leaseholder refuses to pay into our bank account !?!?
      by rfph1
      Ok, the situation is this...

      I am a director of the freehold management company for a small block of flats (other directors being leaseholders like myself).

      Earlier this year we had some banking issues and changed from one of the big high street banks to an on-line bank....
      10-07-2020, 17:36 PM
    • Reply to Leaseholder refuses to pay into our bank account !?!?
      by rfph1
      thank you - the clarification on the need to accept cask is appreciated.

      I'm aware that Tide has issues, but so to did out high street bank (complaint made to financial ombudsman pending)
      12-07-2020, 18:40 PM
    • Reply to I've breached my lease
      by pcuk1979
      Here's some more

      Comply with and observes such regulations as the Council may from time to time make for the benefit of the owners and occupiers of the said flats and in particular but without prejudice to the foregoing to comply with the regulations made at the date hereof and set out...
      12-07-2020, 15:58 PM
    • Reply to I've breached my lease
      by Macromia
      For a start:
      1. Any clause that says that you have to keep floors carpeted, or can't have wooden floors.
      2. Any clause that states that you need inform the freeholder, and/or get freeholder's permission, for non structural alterations.
      3. Any clause that requires you not to do anything...
      12-07-2020, 15:24 PM
    • Reply to I've breached my lease
      by pcuk1979
      I thought that ground floors only were allowed wooden floors.

      And you're right, if I was in my buyer's shoes, I would hate the guy who sold them a flat with clearly weakened soundproofing qualities. I mean, it wasn't great anyway, but it was liveable.

      What clauses should I...
      12-07-2020, 15:04 PM
    • Reply to I've breached my lease
      by Macromia
      Rather than withdrawing from the sale, you could just inform the buyers solicitor that you initially answered these questions thinking that they referred only to structural changes, but would like to inform them of the work that you have done.
      It will then be up to the buyer whether they continue...
      12-07-2020, 15:03 PM
    • Reply to I've breached my lease
      by pcuk1979
      I also have no Building Regulations certificates, even though I may have decreased the acoustic and thermal properties of the building.
      12-07-2020, 15:00 PM
    • Reply to I've breached my lease
      by Macromia
      Nothing that you have said that you have done to your flat seems to breach the lease clauses that you have quoted - but that doesn't mean that you have breached clauses that you haven't quoted as you clearly haven't quoted all potentially relevant clauses in full.

      It sounds more like the...
      12-07-2020, 14:59 PM
    Working...
    X