Leasehold - changing garden boundaries with neighbour

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Leasehold - changing garden boundaries with neighbour

    Help! We are leaseholders of a first/top floor maisonette. L&Q are freeholder. The back garden is currently split on the lease between us and our downstairs neighbours. However, we have agreed that neither of us like the current split and want to change it - as it currently stands we have access across their garden to get to our section. I am concerned that changing the split officially will be incredibly expensive as it may involve not a deed of variation, but a deemed surrender and regrant of the leases. Does anyone have any experience of this?

    You are right that the exercise is likely to prove disproportionately expensive. The documentation is not difficult, but on the other hand not exactly everyday. There are three ways to do it:

    1. Each tenant surrenders the part the other wants and on the same day the landlord grants a tenancy to each tenant of the part he wants. The leases can be very short incorporating the terms of the existing lease by reference.

    2. Each tenant assigns to the other the part he wants. That may be a problem if the leases prohibit assignment of part. The landlord will need to join in anyway to ensure that the rent is legally apportioned.

    3. Each tenant surrenders his lease and on the same day the landlord grants new leases of what each tenant wants. That is not worth considering really.

    If mortgages are involved that will complicate things.

    You are potentially involving five parties here:

    Tennat 1
    Tenant 2
    Lender 1
    Lender 2

    Apart from the expense it is likely to take ages as it will not figure on anyone's top priority list.


      That's really helpful lawcruncher, thank you. I don't see anything about part assignment in the lease so maybe can go with option 2. Assume in this case though that the assignment would only last as long as the period left to run on the lease itself? Rent is peppercorn so hopefully the freeholder will consent.


        What does the lease say about assignment? Please quote the relevant provision in full?

        Is either flat mortgaged?


          Our flat is mortgaged, our neighbours is not. Changing the boundary would only increase the value of the maisonette but I guess that's not the main issue. This is the only provision on assignment I can see in the lease.

          Assignment section.jpg
          Attached Files


            If that is indeed the only provision and the rent is a peppercorn then you can proceed without the landlord's involvement apart from giving notice of the assignment.

            Assuming that you are on friendly terms with the other flat owner this is a suitable case where you can save costs by both instructing the same conveyancer. You will need accurate plans drawn up. Before doing anything write to your lender setting out your proposals.


              Hi Jafferz

              What did you eventually do on this as I’m in exactly the same situation but we’ve already changed the garden format but now want to formalise it as I want to sell my property.


                Lawcruncher could you not get a deed of variation?


                  Originally posted by Sancahojo View Post
                  Lawcruncher could you not get a deed of variation?
                  Whatever you call the deed it has to include either a surrender and regrant or assignments effecting an exchange.


                  Latest Activity


                  • Freehold confusion
                    by davetg
                    30 years ago I bought a flat from a friend. The freehold at the time was registered to my friend and the lady who owned the other flat. I understood at the time that I would replace the friend on the freehold but this never happened. This was not a problem until now as when work on the structure of...
                    24-05-2022, 14:29 PM
                  • Reply to Freehold confusion
                    by sgclacy
                    Your friend may not have to have his ID confirmed as the consideration will be far less than £5,000 and if he did form ID5 makes life a lot easier as it can be done via a video link...
                    24-05-2022, 19:59 PM
                  • Reply to Section 20
                    by Anna1985
                    3, it feasible but we have already enforce the lease via small claims process, due to failure to pay for upkeep.
                    so, we would be going again but just really need to understand what is allowable and what is not...
                    24-05-2022, 18:56 PM
                  • Section 20
                    by Anna1985
                    So the lease allows for the property to be kept in good condition.
                    Thus, the shared hall could be spruced up no problem, but there is an issue with driveway - partially it belongs to the freeholder, partially to the ground floor leaseholder - it is made out of the old paving stones, it looks...
                    22-05-2022, 21:03 PM
                  • Reply to Old managing agents accounts
                    by jazzythumper
                    So the only statement we have shows, the significant arrears of the aforementioned leaseholder, the only accounts we have ever received at handover were the balances and arrears of each leaseholder. This was never accounted for against actual costs. I presume we should have had this information. Can...
                    24-05-2022, 16:27 PM
                  • Old managing agents accounts
                    by jazzythumper
                    Since obtaining the RTM and changing the managing agent, we have never been given full accounts / receipts for the previous year(s). We believe that as the old freeholder and leaser holder of one of the flats were represented by the same solicitor that prior to the sale of the freehold, we were subsidising...
                    20-05-2022, 11:21 AM
                  • Reply to Freehold confusion
                    by davetg
                    Thanks for the reply - both flats have separate 999 year leases so i guess the freehold is of little value. I will look in to TR1.

                    I have always insured my flat separately and assumed the other flat was doing the same - is this a problem?...
                    24-05-2022, 14:48 PM
                  • Reply to Old managing agents accounts
                    by jazzythumper
                    Thanks, I’m not sure that has been provided, if it hasn’t can we force them to produce this?

                    Would it be a simple case of sending a letter with a timescale to respond and if not received followed by the magistrates route?...
                    24-05-2022, 14:39 PM
                  • Reply to Freehold confusion
                    by Section20z
                    1.He will need to sign a TR1 and transfer title to you but it really needs to be done through a solicitor or land registry won't be happy with his ID.
                    2. If you have a separate lease on your flat then freehold is not worth much, if not then it's worth what the flats worth at least .
                    3. Cost...
                    24-05-2022, 14:37 PM
                  • Reply to Share of feehold/shared service charges?
                    by Stu1020
                    Thank you for the response Macromia this is a useful conversation.

                    I can see why the current proportion might be justified, I have been paying 38% towards the buildings insurance the last 4/5 years. However, my dispute is now arising because we are unable to move forward with existing covenants,...
                    24-05-2022, 08:55 AM