Fixed service charges

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Fixed service charges

    I have some long leases with fixed service charge. The impact of these leases limits my ability to recover all the management costs on the building. I am considering lease variation will this work? What options do I really have to overcome the financial risk?

    From a legal point of view, they are not service charges if they are fixed! Being variable is an essential part of the definition of service charge in the Landlord and Tenant legislation.

    If the leases fail to provide for all costs to be recovered, they are legally defective and the FTT can rule in favour of a change in the lease at the request of just one party.

    There is a grey area if the lease could possibly be interpreted as requiring the freeholder to pay the shortfall.


      Thanks for your comments, it looks like an application to FTT then.


        We'd need to see more of the exact lease wording..ground rent is often fixed and it maybe a very low amount (if for example the lease was made in 1800), but in that case..its was upto the FH to read the lease before purchase, Im not sure how it would work in your case, as mentioned, it maybe that its simply not deemed t be a "service charge"..its not clear if a FTT would allow a variation, leases can of course be varied with consent between the parties.
        Advice given is based on my experience representing myself as a leaseholder both in the County Court and at Leasehold Valuation Tribunals.

        I do not accept any liability to you in relation to the advice given.

        It is always recommended you seek further advice from a solicitor or legal expert.

        Always read your lease first, it is the legally binding contract between leaseholder and freeholder.


          In a situation where the administration charge is fixed by the lease which makes it difficult to recover all the actual management cost, what options do i have to cushion or reduce the financial impact or risk?


            Administration charges don't pay for things like upkeep of the property. Did you really mean administration charges. If specific administration charges are specified, and they don't cover costs, that is your hard luck.


              Originally posted by leaseholder64 View Post
              From a legal point of view, they are not service charges if they are fixed!
              That would depend on the exact wording within the lease.
              If there is anything at all in the lease that could indicate that there was an intention to link the payments to the cost of services, and allow some possibility of varying the amount, it could potentially be a considered to be a service charge.

              If the payments really are fixed it is likely to not be considered a service charge payment, but a tribunal might still find that the leases don't adequately allow for the recovery of costs and allow them to be altered - it depends what the lease says the fixed payments are for.


                Could these definitions be relevant here?

                Fixed Service Charge: Those where the landlord fixes the charge according to the landlord’s own estimates and costs. The Landlord bears responsibility for any deficit between the cost of services and the amount of money collected in charges. Similarly, the Landlord is entitled to retain any surplus that accrues if the Landlord collects charges in excess of the cost of providing the services.

                Variable Service Charges: Those that can be changed, increased or decreased, in accordance with the provisions of the tenancy agreement or licence. The main effect of variable service charges is that it allows surpluses and deficits to carry forward to the next accounting year.

                This is from the Peabody Service Charges Policy.


                  Those sound good definitions to me. Only the variable ones are covered by the statute on service charges, as service charges are specifically defined as charges that vary with costs.


                  Latest Activity


                  • Reply to AGM cancelled.
                    by Andrea Cunningham
                    Call an EGM. Make sure you give proper notice and that it is legal (download a boilerplate notice off the internet). In that EGM you can vote new directors in, or even vote the old directors out.
                    26-01-2022, 07:14 AM
                  • AGM cancelled.
                    by Grumio
                    Is this legal?

                    A bit of background, we currently have three directors, we are allowed to have up to a maximum of eight directors according to the articles of association. We are all leaseholders. Last summer the three directors decided to hire a managing agent who is now in charge of the...
                    26-01-2022, 00:46 AM
                  • What can I do about my right of way.
                    by Trevor62
                    I live in the upper flat of a maisonette, I have a right of way that goes around the back of the building from the side entrance, there are only two flats in the building.

                    Anyway for years there has been a gate with a lock to go through the right of way, now for the past year the flat has...
                    23-01-2022, 23:01 PM
                  • Reply to What can I do about my right of way.
                    by Trevor62

                    This is the ROW as it is in the land registry.

                    Can I ask another question?

                    As you can read it says Boundary determined by edge of pavings. Before the other party moved out they built a fence along the boundary though they build it on my side of the...
                    25-01-2022, 20:58 PM
                  • Enfranchising from a company I'm already a member of.
                    by Andrea Cunningham
                    The estate I live on has 2 blocks. All the leaseholders are members of the company which owns the freehold and manages the block ("Share of freehold").

                    Suppose one of the 2 blocks decides to go it alone - so in other words gain the freehold from a company they are already a member...
                    04-10-2021, 12:07 PM
                  • Reply to Enfranchising from a company I'm already a member of.
                    by Andrea Cunningham
                    As I said right at the beginning, there are some very sound reasons to do this which I wasn't going to go into. Suffice it to say that the current situation is one where the building I live in suffers under the tyranny of the majority of the larger building. So what is being sought is genuine control...
                    25-01-2022, 20:24 PM
                  • Reply to Enfranchising from a company I'm already a member of.
                    by Andrea Cunningham
                    There is already no ground rent collected - so as I understand it the value of the freehold might be quite low anyway.

                    If this is all done by negotiation then it is a moot point regardless, and it brings me back to what I was actually asking about, which is how to fairly and equitably split...
                    25-01-2022, 20:10 PM
                  • Reply to Enfranchising from a company I'm already a member of.
                    by Macromia
                    That potentially raises an interesting question about what happens to any money that needs to be paid for the enfranchisement.
                    At the moment payment is handed over, all those in the block being enfranchised would presumably cease to be members of the company - so wouldn't be entitled to any share...
                    25-01-2022, 19:40 PM
                  • Reply to Enfranchising from a company I'm already a member of.
                    by Macromia
                    That may not be your intention, but it definitely seems like you haven't given proper consideration to what enfranchisement would involve.

                    What do the leases specifically say about what is included within service charge/maintenance costs and how service charge costs are to be split?...
                    25-01-2022, 19:25 PM
                  • Who owns the windows in a flat above a commercial premises
                    by andyg1
                    I am the landlord of a 2 bedroom 2nd floor flat above a commercial premises ( car showroom ) . The showroom is run by the Freeholder and they own 8 flats of the 12 in the building . A few years ago without my knowledge they erected scaffolding and replaced the old single glazed metal windows in their...
                    25-01-2022, 14:52 PM