Service Charge Percentage Wrong

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #16
    I believe statutory interest on debts is simple interest, not compound interest.

    Comment


      #17
      Capping sounds like something previously mentioned in regard to housing association property. I seem to remember that the conclusion in that case was that the capping had been voided by subsequent assignments of the freehold.

      Comment


        #18
        Originally posted by leaseholder64 View Post
        I believe statutory interest on debts is simple interest, not compound interest.
        Ok fine , I can take simple interest

        Comment


          #19
          If the percentage changes for any reason am I not supposed to be informed? Or it should be added on to the Lease. None of that had taken place.

          Comment


            #20
            The important question is is this housing association property?

            Comment


              #21
              No, it’s not, it’s independent, just leasehold

              Comment


                #22
                In that case none of this makes much sense. Are you sure you are reading your lease? -- leases are not worded that way -- you are paraphrasing it out of existence. 1% of what? 1.1% of what. How does the lease define service charges? How does lease define the building. The EXACT words would be helpful not your interpretation of them. What is this capping business in your lease exactly? - why would any lease include that? - exact words please.

                Comment


                  #23
                  Here it is - have edited some of it

                  COUNTERPART L E A S E
                  of Apartment Number xxxx


                  LESSEE'S PROPORTION OF MAINTENANCE EXPENSES
                  Block Costs - Part A Proportion -1.11 % Estate Costs - Part B Proportion - 0.99%

                  Block costs includes- Repairing re-building re-pointing,Painting,Keeping the Gardens and Grounds in good condition, the provision maintenance and renewal of any other equipment,Insuring the Buildings, Cleaning the Common Parts and the Storage Areas, Cleaning as necessary the external and internal faces of all windows in the Common Parts, Providing operating maintaining and (if necessary) renewing and adding toThe fixtures fittings and any furnishings provided in the Common Parts and the Storage Areas,Any electronic security system in the Common Parts,Maintaining the Bin Stores and providing and arranging for the emptying of receptacles for normal household rubbish within the Bin Stores for the use of the lessees of the Apartments,Providing operating maintaining and (if necessary) renewing and adding to the fire­ fighting appliances communal television aerials and such other equipment,Generally managing and administering the Maintained Property and the Apartments and the Amenity Areas (excluding the Access Areas and Parking Spaces)

                  Part B - Estate Costs
                  Generally managing and administering the Access Areas and Parking Spaces,Inspecting repairing maintaining and resurfacing or replacing (where necessary) the Parking Spaces and the Access Areas and all Service Installations forming part of the Access Areas and Parking Spaces and clearing snow fi'om the Parking Spaces and Access Areas

                  The Lessee shall pay the Lessee’s Proportion of the Maintenance Expenses shown in the heading to this Lease.

                  If the Lessee shall at any time during the Term object to any item of the Maintenance Expenses as being unreasonable or to the insurances mentioned being insufficient then after the Lessee has paid to the Management Company the Lessee’s Proportion of the Maintenance Expenses in accordance with paragraph x of this Schedule the matter in dispute shall be determined by arbitration in accordance with Clause x The costs of the arbitrator appointed shall be borne equally by the parties unless he otherwise directs. After the decision of the appointed arbitrator any overpayment by the Lessee shall be credited against future payments due from the Lessee to the Management Company under this Schedule or (if the Lessee so requires) repaid to the Lessee.



                  (Apologies capping was used out of context by me)

                  Comment


                    #24
                    This is what is in my lease. However I have been paying an extra !% for INTERNAL AREAS, which includes maintenance of internal communal area, Lift and its operations- all of which my flat doesn't use

                    the % is calculated from the - Total anticipated expenditure of the entire apartment blocks

                    Comment


                      #25
                      Nothing in what you have quoted excludes the internal common parts.

                      Comment


                        #26
                        Paying less than 1.11% of the internal costs doesn't make sense, as you seem to be saying that cost is spread over a smaller number of flats. I.E. it would imply that of the 90 flats paying block costs, 100 have to pay the internal charges!

                        Comment


                          #27
                          Originally posted by leaseholder64 View Post
                          Nothing in what you have quoted excludes the internal common parts.
                          INTERNAL AREAS- includes maintenance of internal communal area, Lift and its operations

                          Why should I be paying for these? Even if I have to, should it not be in the 1.11% Block cost

                          Comment


                            #28
                            leaseholder64,

                            block cost is 1.11% for all flats, say 100, internal area cost is an extra 1% paid by say 96; some- 4 do not use internal areas and do not pay this extra 1% ( I have found one such flat owner with same configuration as my flat, he doesnt pay this extra 1%).

                            Comment


                              #29
                              The lease says that you pay 1.11% of the Block Costs (as defined) and 0.99% of the Estate Costs (as defined). It does not say any different. What your friend pays is irrelevant. Your usage of lifts (or otherwise) is totally irrelevant.

                              You are on to a loser arguing that you do not pay what the lease says you are to pay.

                              Comment


                                #30
                                AndrewDod,

                                You seemed to have missed the point of extra charges:
                                I am paying Block cost 1.1%, ( in the lease) and Estate cost 0.99% ( in the lease) and Internal apartment cost 1%( NOT in the lease)
                                why am I paying this extra 1%- which a similar apartment is Not paying !!

                                Comment

                                Latest Activity

                                Collapse

                                • Reply to Applying to Tribunal
                                  by Paulsen
                                  “Following the expiry of this letter and neither a response nor payment being made, we will continue to collect the arrears in full” this is what it states at the end of the letter. £100 ground rent and £250 fees.

                                  They are acting on behalf of the freeholders, but the managing agent...
                                  21-01-2020, 00:34 AM
                                • Applying to Tribunal
                                  by Paulsen
                                  I have a complicated history with my managing agent and I have written a few times on here. They have issued debt collecting for “unpaid” ground rent and I don’t think I have an option but to apply to the Tribunal.
                                  They issued a letter suggesting to use my insurance payment of £3997 against...
                                  17-01-2020, 15:14 PM
                                • Reply to Applying to Tribunal
                                  by fos333
                                  If they have put your account on hold again it should not be a problem.

                                  Did the letter not contain 'Following the expiry of this letter and neither a response nor payment being made, we will (where applicable) notify the parties with a registered financial interest on HM Land Registry of...
                                  21-01-2020, 00:04 AM
                                • Reply to Applying to Tribunal
                                  by leaseholder64
                                  Lenders often ask to be informed at an early stage, so I would say they can, and if they are in the habit of it, will do so early.
                                  20-01-2020, 23:52 PM
                                • Reply to Applying to Tribunal
                                  by Paulsen
                                  Yes the letter from DCA did say to only communicate with them which I have done and they have put the account on hold. I received an email today saying I need to pay them, but I rang again and forwarded the letter from the agent where they are suggesting using my insurance money towards costs. I also...
                                  20-01-2020, 23:30 PM
                                • Reply to Applying to Tribunal
                                  by fos333
                                  ARMA will not be the redress scheme for your MA, it will be either The Property Ombudsman or Property Redress Scheme.

                                  Google 'leasehold redress schemes' and the information you require is there.

                                  The old MA will be regulated by ARMA who may look at your issues as you already...
                                  20-01-2020, 22:47 PM
                                • Being removed as a director from freeholder company
                                  by surreygirl
                                  I have just had a notification that I and the rest of the Directors have been removed as Directors from the Company. We have a Managing Agent now and he sent out an email a week ago to say he is now ready to "Manage" the property and has called a meeting for next month to discuss the work...
                                  20-01-2020, 14:42 PM
                                • Reply to Being removed as a director from freeholder company
                                  by surreygirl
                                  Yes I am. I have checked thank you!!...
                                  20-01-2020, 21:57 PM
                                • Reply to Being removed as a director from freeholder company
                                  by surreygirl
                                  Thank you all for your comments. Very interesting. The Agent did come back to me and say that we had been put down as owning more the 25% and that was incorrect and so we have been removed as "a person with significant control".

                                  But thank you all for your interest and comments....
                                  20-01-2020, 21:57 PM
                                • Reply to Law Commission's suggested schemes For Leasehold reform
                                  by TruthLedger
                                  The doubling of ground rent over a certain period REALLY needs to done away with and so is marriage value and hope value. I also like the idea of not having to pay future ground rent. Of course, it's down to the government to pick and choose from the Law Commission's suggestions and hope for our best...
                                  20-01-2020, 19:45 PM
                                Working...
                                X