S168

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #16
    If the lease owned by the leaseholder who won't pay out for repairs requires them to keep their property properly maintained, and work with the other leaseholders to maintain common parts (including contributing a share of the costs), and also contains a forfeiture clause, then you could, as a co-freeholder, apply to a tribunal as a litigant in person to ask for a determination of a breach of lease.

    The tribunal would consider precisely what the leaseholder's obligations are under the lease, and whether or not they are meeting them.
    Things that you have to be aware of are that 'repair/maintain' obligations don't usually include any obligation to pay for improvements to a property (so, for example, if the solution for damp problems is to install some type of damp-proofing that wasn't in the original building, there may be no obligation to contribute to this), and the tribunal might not consider the lease to require the leaseholder to contribute to all repairs (some repairs might not be adequately covered in the lease, and may therefore be determined to be the responsibility of the freeholders without any opportunity for costs to be recouped from leaseholders).

    Comment


      #17
      Macromia , thank you. We were already talking in another thread. I'm just reviewing all options prior taking action.

      By lease leaseholders to maintain the property in good repair , the lease is self repairing and the freeholder has no obligations to maintain the property.

      Comment


        #18
        Originally posted by Anna1985 View Post
        [
        By lease leaseholders to maintain the property in good repair , the lease is self repairing and the freeholder has no obligations to maintain the property.
        The precise wording of the leases can still be important.

        If the wording can be interpreted to refer only to the demised premises, the lessee can legitimately argue that they are not obliged to contribute anything towards the maintenance of communal areas.
        If this is the case, and the freeholder has no repair obligations, a tribunal would have to be asked to determine who should pay for maintenance of communal areas on the basis that the lease is defective. There would be no guarantee that they would agree that the leaseholder had any obligation, and may rule that the cost of repairing any parts not specifically mentioned as being the responsibility of the leaseholders falls on the freeholders.

        Comment


          #19
          That is interesting point you made Macromia, does anyone else have any experience of applying to the FTT as a freeholder (share I mean) for a determination that there is a breach of the lease?

          Comment


            #20
            I think I would be soon, although the application would be made in joint freeholder names

            Comment


              #21
              When you make the application under Section 168 (4) the Tribunal will request that you notify any mortgagee who has an interest in the flat to which you are taking action against.

              Needless to say the mortgagee will take the matter very seriously indeed and will appoint solicitors to protect their interest and may well exert the pressure you are looking to exert

              Comment


                #22
                sgclacy , thank you - very helpful.
                Is my understanding correct that I would need to contact mortgagee after I made an application to tribunal? And it would be done prior/post hearing?

                Also, does anybody knows how long would it be for tribunal to process a case?

                Currently small claims court is saying like end of 2021...

                Comment


                  #23
                  Originally posted by Anna1985 View Post
                  Also, does anybody knows how long would it be for tribunal to process a case?

                  Currently small claims court is saying like end of 2021...
                  I suspect that even the relevant local tribunal can't answer that.
                  It will depend on how many cases they already have waiting, and what restrictions are imposed between now and the date of any potential hearing.

                  Comment

                  Latest Activity

                  Collapse

                  • Lease variation
                    by bazann
                    Hi,
                    My elderly mother [99 years+] owns a flat in a residential block under a 125 year Lease dated 24th May 1989. The Lessor is a housing association. My mother purchased the flat in early 2011 with the benefit of said Lease.
                    There is the usual monthly service charge which includes e.g. maintenance...
                    26-11-2020, 16:28 PM
                  • Reply to Lease variation
                    by Lawcruncher
                    Whilst "resident warden" is clear, I am not sure that in the context of sheltered accommodation "residential warden" can be taken to mean something other than a resident warden. "Residential" is not a word I would use to describe a person. If the warden has until recently...
                    27-11-2020, 08:43 AM
                  • Insulation - necessity or improvement?
                    by bethy
                    We are L/H on a top floor flat. Roof is responsibility of F/H to maintain through service charge.

                    A loft hatch was installed last year to give access to the roof space for roof repairs. This has shown that there is no insulation whatsoever in the roof space - the property was converted...
                    26-11-2020, 12:37 PM
                  • Reply to Insulation - necessity or improvement?
                    by bethy
                    It's a bit of a mess really, and a long story... They owned the whole building and ran a restaurant downstairs. Then converted upstairs into two flats to rent out. Then got into money problems and sold leaseholds to the flats. Service charges are split between restaurant and two flats. It's a terrace...
                    27-11-2020, 00:03 AM
                  • Reply to Insulation - necessity or improvement?
                    by Macromia
                    If there has never been any loft insulation, putting it in now would technically be an improvement, so the I suspect that the freeholder would be under no obligation to arrange for insulation to be installed.

                    If the building was converted into flats "just over ten years ago",...
                    26-11-2020, 21:56 PM
                  • Reply to Yet more 'notice to underlet fees' £135 and going up!!
                    by Macromia
                    This information is crucial.

                    If your lease states that underletting is allowed but you need to pay "notice to underlet" fees of £xxx biannually, and these fees are to be increased in line with inflation, there is unlikely to be any legal argument that helps you.

                    ...
                    26-11-2020, 21:32 PM
                  • Yet more 'notice to underlet fees' £135 and going up!!
                    by November26
                    Hi

                    I have been trawling the internet for updates to challenges around 'notice of underletting fees' and I'm not sure of the current position. My landlord is still playing ignorant and deeming their extortionate bi-annual amount 'reasonable'. Are there county court judgements or upper tribunal...
                    25-11-2020, 18:02 PM
                  • Reply to Forfeiture Procedure and Costs
                    by Aboosimbel
                    Dear FlyingFeehold,
                    Thanks for the reply. You're quite right First Tier Tribunal not Land Tribunal !!!. I take your point with the analogy of the barking dog, and I do agree. However I like to be in a position to have an informed conversation with Lawyers, and I think getting the opinion of people...
                    26-11-2020, 19:35 PM
                  • Forfeiture Procedure and Costs
                    by Aboosimbel
                    Dear Landlordzoners,

                    This problem requires the advice of an experienced freeholder to help, as its a little complicated.

                    I own a freehold of a house split into three flats (I also own one of the flats). One flat had been used as a brother since 2014 until the police finally...
                    27-10-2020, 21:39 PM
                  • Reply to Insulation - necessity or improvement?
                    by bethy
                    Porgie,

                    That's my understanding. Then really comes down to whose responsibility to do it/pay for it.
                    26-11-2020, 16:45 PM
                  Working...
                  X