Reserves not ring fenced to specific purposes

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Reserves not ring fenced to specific purposes


    My property is managed by an RMC, who is doing a very poor job (and has selected and kept the worst Property Manager around).

    They keep including in service charges demands some provision for reserves against the various schedules, but they don't state their purpose (e.g. redecoration).

    In the annual budgets, they also use existing reserves for whatever they want, including gardening or just balancing out the budgets (meaning a short-term perception that things are managed properly and stay on budget, while depleting the funds for their intended purpose).

    My understanding is that reserves have to be accrued for specific stated purposes, and then only used for those purposes (else it's unfair for long term owners), and that a yearly statement should be showing what reserves were used for (specific expenditure).

    Is that correct?


    A reserve fund can only be created if it is permitted by the lease, which should also set out the purposes for which it may be used. Gardening would not normally be a permitted purpose.

    Sometimes the lease will permit surpluses to be added to the reserve fund, again it depends on the wording of the lease.

    Deficits should not be deducted from the reserve fund but managing agents sometimes do to save issuing demands with covering notices. They also argue sometimes that if a balancing charge has not been made to the leaseholder, the leaseholder is unable to challenge that charge.

    The lease will also state whether or not the reserve fund must be kept in a separate bank account.

    The annual service charge accounts should summarise the movements on the reserve fund balance,

    Agents often use reserve fund monies for other purposes and argue that it is temporary and the funds will be replenished. Whether or not they can do so again depends on the wording of the lease.

    The main problem is if service charge expenditure is disallowed by a Tribunal, it is usually the reserve fund which suffers.

    There are many contenders for the worst managing agent award.


      Technically, I think, reserve funds can be used for any purpose for which the service charge can be used; it is sinking funds that have a specific purpose. However, for the demands to be reasonable, there must have been a proper budget, which would have had to identify a provisional purpose for the reserves.

      Most leaseholders would rather reserves were used that that there were mid-year calls for extra payments.


        The terms reserve fund and sinking fund have become interchangeable


        Latest Activity


        • Restitution for overpaid service charges
          by Lorimer
          I have just had a First Tier Tribunal hearing for a service charge challenge spanning the years 2014-2016. The FTT confirmed what I suspected - that I had overpaid 10K of service charges and that although the FTT is not in a position to order repayment to me, I might consider making a county court claim...
          18-04-2019, 09:01 AM
        • Reply to Restitution for overpaid service charges
          by CANADA576
          Hi Lorimer,would love to know the outcome as I have a very similar problem with a persistent leak plus wrongly apportioned and exaggerate Buildings Insurance premiums from a landlord that owns 8 properties in a row, including mine.
          09-12-2019, 10:08 AM
        • Reply to Council or housing association as freeholder
          by propertyboy
          Will I have the same statutory right to extend after 2 years like another leaseholder regardless of the fact that the freeholder is the council?

          Does it matter if you are a non-resident landlord? Can you extend your lease after 2 years if you are based overseas?...
          08-12-2019, 17:49 PM
        • Council or housing association as freeholder
          by propertyboy
          Hi all,

          I do not have any appetite to buy ex-local stock and look to buy period property in London.

          This is personal preference (lots of ex local supply and prefer victorian stock in a period property with 2-3 flats in the block).

          Recently I have been looking at...
          24-11-2019, 21:28 PM
        • Correct Accounting report for an RMC
          by Libra
          I am wondering what is the correct accounting report for an RMC, that is owned by the leaseholders / freeholders and also owns the freehold.
          Has the Tec/03/11 been superseded? Is the Financial reporting standard 102 section 1A appropriate?
          Is it correct to report that the reserve fund...
          07-12-2019, 16:49 PM
        • Reply to Correct Accounting report for an RMC
          by Gordon999
          The unspent service charge money including "reserve fund/sinking fund " belongs to the leaseholders. The RMC has to keep the service charge money in separate bank accounts called "client account" for which the bank will issue a letter to acknowledge the "client account"...
          08-12-2019, 14:00 PM
        • Reply to Correct Accounting report for an RMC
          by Gordon999
          The RMC has to file its own "RMC company accounts" to Companies House and if it has no ground rent income, it will be filing dormant accounts.

          The RMC has responsibility under the lease to collect the service charge money from leaseholders and arrange maintenance of the building...
          08-12-2019, 13:44 PM
        • Reply to Correct Accounting report for an RMC
          by Libra
          Thank you Leaseholder 64. I
          07-12-2019, 20:05 PM
        • Reporting the directors of a RMC to be unfit
          by Libra
          Hello...and thank you for listening
          I am wondering if one could report the RMC directors to be unfit - several breaches of Companies Act - blackmailing / coercing the residents / misleading statements regarding the right to acquire the freehold - probably false accounting ( still investigating...
          07-12-2019, 16:39 PM
        • Reply to Reporting the directors of a RMC to be unfit
          by Libra
          Hello Leaseholder 64,
          Thank your for your reply. I didn't think that they are the same issues ...that's why I started another post. I can now see how they can have a common point. To my mind, whether I can report the directors was different to what is the correct account report for a RMC. My apologies....
          07-12-2019, 20:00 PM