Breach of the Lease where does company law state they cant be directors in this case?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Breach of the Lease where does company law state they cant be directors in this case?

    Hello, Hope you all had a lovely Easter! My question is....can directors who are in breach of their own Lease and are not following the Lease be removed and what company or Landlord and Tenant law would support this?

    #2
    If a director of a big conglomerate is in breach of a lease for their private home, it is totally irrelevant. I believe you mean directors of an RTM or RMC, for which they are also leaseholders.

    This is not a matter of statute of law. Landlord and tenant law doesn't really address companies, except for RTMs, and Company Law does address leaseholds. They can only be removed if the company articles say they can be removed, and I suspect such clauses are rare, especially given that most leaseholders are probably in breach on minor issues.

    Some RMCs have a condition that the director must be a leaseholder (RTMs cannot). In that case successful forfeiture of lease would remove them as directors. If the breach was in relation to payment and the director was made bankrupt, that would also remove them form all directorships. As RTM directors don't have to be leaseholders, there will be a lot of them who could not breach the lease, anyway.

    I'm guessing this isn't really a new thread but part of a series trying to get round the basic problem that the only way of dealing with bad directors is for a majority of shareholders to vote them out and replace them with good ones.

    Comment


      #3
      No I mean Directors of a limited company acting on behalf of the company as its agents and the shareholders? The directors are using the company for their own benefit and not following the Lease, their argument is we own the freehold, we are the directors we do what the majority agree with, however when I try to point out we have a Lease and we need to follow the Lease they dont agree with me.

      Comment


        #4
        So this isn't an RMC or RTM, then?

        Company law says nothing about obeying leases. Companies can and do breach contracts, which is all a lease would amount to.

        Section 175 onwards of the 2006 Companies Act deals with conflicts of interest, although they can be overridden by the company's articles, for example to allow the sort of conflict of interest that is inevitable because of the nature of the company.

        If I understand section 178 correctly, they can only be enforced by civil actions taken by the company itself, so you will need control of the company first. Once you have control, it is unlikely that it will be worth suing the (ex-)directors.

        I cannot find any relevant criminal offences in schedule A.

        Back to RMCs and RTMs, unfortunately a lo lot of people seem to advise such companies that they can ignore the lease. Breaching a lease is not a criminal offence.

        Comment


          #5
          You need to enforce the lease against the company, not the directors. If it involves misuse of service charges, start with the FTT. Otherwise you will probably need to go to the County Court using the standard track and seek an injunction. If the directors breach an injunction the courts may decide to disqualify them.

          Comment


            #6
            Thank you leaseholder 64, I appreciate your help.

            Comment


              #7
              Breaching a lease is not a crime but it is breach of contract and contrary to common law. It depends on what the breach is as to what powers the FTT has.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Sarah B View Post
                Breaching a lease is not a crime but it is breach of contract and contrary to common law. It depends on what the breach is as to what powers the FTT has.
                Thank you Sarah..my directors breach as much as they like!

                Comment

                Latest Activity

                Collapse

                • Bullying from a joint freeholder
                  by goodgirlLondon
                  Hey, I would really like some advice about this as I am a female who lives alone and I am getting worried. The couple who I share the freehold with (just 2 flats in the house), dont get along and we have had problems agreeing over maintenance. I avoid them as much as possible but a neighbour told me...
                  23-11-2021, 17:13 PM
                • Reply to Bullying from a joint freeholder
                  by Stew
                  That seems like a great idea letting out a spare room. Make sure its someone who would not feel intimidated. Also agree with Xmas cards every bit helps. Also tell all contractors not to engage with them at all and ignore them....
                  26-11-2021, 15:05 PM
                • Reply to Bullying from a joint freeholder
                  by goodgirlLondon
                  Hey, I have thought about renting but I love my flat and had expensive new kitchen put in. Not sure I would be happy if tenants damaged. Also, I think that my mortgage restricts letting out my flat. I love the area and was happy until the couple took over the joint freehold. I might get a tenant to...
                  26-11-2021, 10:31 AM
                • Reply to Service charge arrears
                  by lampshade
                  Yes of course I do not need to know any details other than the current situation. So I will ask and see if I get a reply....
                  26-11-2021, 10:02 AM
                • Service charge arrears
                  by lampshade
                  If I asked the managing agents for a situation report regarding overall arrears of service charge, are they duty bound to let me know. not by flat,of course, but as a % of total invoiced, with info regarding length of arrears?
                  26-11-2021, 07:54 AM
                • Reply to Service charge arrears
                  by eagle2
                  There is no reason why you cannot request and no reason why the managing agent cannot supply general information regarding the level of service charge arrears. It would only become an issue if any personal information was supplied or could be identified,
                  26-11-2021, 09:24 AM
                • Reply to Service charge arrears
                  by lampshade
                  OK....no i am not one of those........ but seems odd then that the managing agent was very quick to tell all leaseholders in writing that a certain % of leaseholders had paid in advance of a large section 20, by way of coercion to those who had not paid.
                  26-11-2021, 08:39 AM
                • Reply to Service charge arrears
                  by Section20z
                  Only if you're the freeholder or employer (RMC etc), not if you are just a flat owner...
                  26-11-2021, 08:10 AM
                • Reply to Bullying from a joint freeholder
                  by Stew
                  Have you thought about renting the place and just giving the old neighbour an email address for communication with an auto response saying I only pick up email from this account once a month. Not ideal but another option.
                  25-11-2021, 22:45 PM
                • Access to my garden for upstairs neighbour's loft conversion
                  by sampsam
                  Would appreciate any thoughts or advice from the forum on this matter.

                  I own the garden flat in block of 4, share of freehold equally split. Top floor neighbour wants to do loft conversion and build an extra floor on closet wing (roof terrace belongs to freehold).

                  I am not...
                  19-11-2021, 01:16 AM
                Working...
                X