Musical instrument covenant question, please help!

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Musical instrument covenant question, please help!

    Hi experts,

    We're buying a leasehold flat
    I play cello (never after 8pm) -

    One proposed lease Regulation for a flat we're buying reads as below -

    "Not to sing or dance or play any musical instrument or equipment for making or reproducing sound or to act in such a manner so as to be audible outside the Property so as to cause annoyance to the Flat Tenants or any other occupiers of the Building"

    . Does this mean a) I can't play cello at all, or b) I can't cause annoyance if playing is audible to other tenants?

    Please help as this is a showstopper for us buying this flat. can anything be done about this covenant if the answer is a?

    thanks


    #2
    I suspect that if someone else hears it and makes a complaint it will be classed as an annoyance.

    I can almost guarantee that this will happen, i used to live in a downstairs corner flat and on occasions used to play keyboards not particularly loud. I was served notice due to "the loudness of my organ". This was considered a nuisance however the fact that i could hear the TV's and the tenants moving around in the adjacent flats was not.

    Musical taste is an amazingly diverse thing. I regularly hear young lads playing the latest chart music from terrible sound systems in their cars in the communal car park next to my property which annoys me immensely. If it was Nivana or Rage against the machine i wouldnt have an issue i'd actually like it to be a bit louder, i dont think everyone else would agree though!

    Comment


      #3
      Cellos have a spike that rests on the floor, don't they? Definitely going to treat the neighbours to cello music if you buy that place.

      Comment


        #4
        That seems to rule out TVs and radios barely audible outside the property. Bonkers.
        I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...

        Comment


          #5
          Unless the flat has good sound proofing or you can live without your Cello playing I would consider it a deal breaker.

          Comment


            #6
            The answer is B. It is a common clause in lh flats.

            Comment


              #7
              Word. My reading of the clause is that it's two parts - a) not to make noise that is b) annoying to other residents. Both have to be in play for the clause to be broken. I think you're fine, OP.

              Comment


                #8
                Thanks this makes a lot of sense. We just want to be cautious and make sure Lease regulations therein are fair.
                thanks all for your help

                Comment


                  #9
                  Don't underestimate the value of talking to your neighbours either. The Lease is there to provide clarity on covenants to help resolve disputes but it's by far the better option to ensure no disputes occur in the first place. A quick knock at your immediate neighbours to say hello and let them know that you never play after 8pm but if they have sleeping babies or are doing nightwork and need other considerations to feel free to ask - that'll go a long way to ensuring your neighbours never have to look at their lease in the first place. In my experience, it's the feeling that they can't ask you to keep it down that results in complaints to the managing agents.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Thank you for the kind advice. Yes we do that, and we'll be doing precisely that.
                    Best
                    M.

                    Comment

                    Latest Activity

                    Collapse

                    • Homeless living in flats hallways
                      RosieB
                      Hello,

                      My first time here - I'm lucky I've managed 8 years of land-lording without serious issue! Until now...

                      My tenanted flat is on the 2nd floor of a block. There are 3 blocks in total on the estate. In the past 2 to 3 weeks my tenants have reported homeless people sleeping,...
                      18-02-2019, 13:57 PM
                    • Reply to Homeless living in flats hallways
                      sam_cat
                      Fire brigade have decent bolt cutters. 2 seconds is probably overstating it!...
                      20-02-2019, 11:31 AM
                    • Share of freehold disputes
                      Outnumbered
                      Hello,
                      I own the 1/4 share of freehold of a house, we are 4 flats in total. We arrange meetings on an adhoc basis when we feel there are issues to discuss, and we have email conversations about fixing things etc.
                      At our last meeting things got heated and I felt ganged up upon by the 3 other...
                      18-02-2019, 20:50 PM
                    • Reply to Share of freehold disputes
                      Brooks15
                      Hi everyone, I hope that I have managed to click on the relevant button for a new post. Question..... I live in a period property split into two flats. I own the Freehold of the building. When I purchased the property I inherited a management company that was dormant and consisted as just the management...
                      20-02-2019, 11:22 AM
                    • Section 20 works notification - help needed as leaseholder
                      ricoeliso
                      I am a leaseholder in a block of flats in London. I have recently received a postal letter from our Managing Agent regarding Section 20 works being carried out on our building. This letter appears to be a Notice of Estimates, and references a previous letter, which i presume was a Notice of Intention...
                      20-02-2019, 07:18 AM
                    • Reply to Section 20 works notification - help needed as leaseholder
                      leaseholder64
                      Surveyor type fees are generally quoted as a percentage of the contract price, not as set sums of money. I would expect the Health and Safety (CDM) element to be about 3-5%.

                      I suspect your S20 fees are actually two things, The larger part will be the project management fees for specifying...
                      20-02-2019, 09:55 AM
                    • Reply to Homeless living in flats hallways
                      boletus
                      There are thousands of blocks of flats in the UK that do not have a fire brigade lock override.

                      Honestly, which is the higher risk, homeless people living in the communal hallways or a lock that can be overcome by a firefighter in 2 seconds?

                      (Incidentally, I've done similar...
                      20-02-2019, 09:45 AM
                    • Reply to Section 20 works notification - help needed as leaseholder
                      ricoeliso
                      thank your detail response. The lease is from 2007 - not sure about referenced form of communication, though I find it strange that they communicate all other correspondence (notifications, fee payment requests, updates and newsletters) via email, but choose to notify this by letter only.
                      ...
                      20-02-2019, 09:33 AM
                    • Reply to Section 20 works notification - help needed as leaseholder
                      leaseholder64
                      Any form of communication allowed by the lease is going to be acceptable. I'd actually suggest that paper delivery is the gold standard. Is the lease recent enough to actually allow for electronic communications as a valid form of notice? How would you deal with a formal notice from the council, e.g....
                      20-02-2019, 09:25 AM
                    • Reply to Homeless living in flats hallways
                      leaseholder64
                      Safety legislation is not prescriptive in the way that some people would like it to be. You are not going to find legislation that is more specific than providing adequate means for fire fighting.
                      20-02-2019, 08:52 AM
                    Working...
                    X