Leaseholder had balcony 'stolen'.

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Leaseholder had balcony 'stolen'.

    This situation has come to me via a local community forum,

    Mr A buys a leasehold 1 bed conversion flat in 1996 on 99 year lease for £43,000. Mr B buys upstairs 2 bed flat and rents it out. The freeholder Mr H also owns the ground floor shop part of which he gets consent on to create a 1 bed dwelling.

    Whilst Mr A is away Mr H extends part of the back shop and creates the dwelling with roof lights but not quite what he got planning consent for. During the works A's balcony is removed and cannot be replaced due to the angle of the new roof/lights and the skimpy materials used on the roof.

    Suddenly Mr H becomes ill and incapacitated. The balcony dispute business is put on hold and Ms M sends out demands for payment of ground rent and repairs to herself saying she has Power of Attorney. A and B are suspicious and pay nothing and are now 3 years in arrears. The building in general is in a poor state of repair.

    Mr H died just before Christmas and a solicitor's letter to Mr A and B says the freehold is for sale for £60,000 by Ms M who has inherited the freehold etc.

    What is the best way for Mr A to go on? Mr B does not want to buy the freehold. He does not have much in the way of funds, is retired and does not really want to move. Re-sale on Mr A's flat is around £130,000.

    Thanks for reading so far.

    Freedom at the point of zero............

    This is a freehold that comes with a dwelling, not just ground rents.

    There cannot be too many areas of the country where a 1 bed dwelling is worth less than 60K, if this is such a place, snap it up.

    You could create a lease for the dwelling downstairs and sell it, after sorting out your balcony of course.


      I think you have missed the point here paulamis. Elderly gent, no cash, lease running out, building falling to bits.

      Mr A does not have £60,000 to buy the freehold (not that it is worth that) and the shop cannot be converted to a flat under planning rules in that street.

      Any experienced lease experts with sensible ideas please?

      Freedom at the point of zero............


        Sorry, thought you were representing A and B was a retired 3rd party.

        You said they had permission to create a dwelling, so I guess you mean there is a shop with a dwelling out the back somewhere. If the dwelling had permission then someone must be allowed to live in it, it must be worth something.

        If A cannot afford the FH it is moot anyway, just has to hope for a good new FH.

        If the bldg is in poor condition, a new FH may/should decide to fix it up, could be a large bill, if A will struggle with that, then maybe sell now.

        Ideas beyond that would get into financial advice for which you have to ask a pro.


        Latest Activity


        • VAT charged twice on work?
          If a one-off service charge has already had 20% VAT applied by the contractor, can an additional 20% VAT be charged on this total by the managing agent in the service charge schedule (before the fee % has been applied)?

          I am wondering if this is normal practice or an error.
          23-05-2019, 15:44 PM
        • Reply to VAT charged twice on work?
          Thank you for your response - this is useful information.
          23-05-2019, 21:24 PM
        • Reply to VAT charged twice on work?
          An error; they can only charge VAT on their markup.
          23-05-2019, 20:31 PM
        • Freehold sale with 2 leases
          Hello - I own a property that includes the entire freehold and leasehold to one of the 2 flats in the building. (I own the freehold my husband owns the leasehold).

          I am selling the property with the freehold.

          My buyer is getting nervous - and so am I about the transfer of the...
          23-05-2019, 14:33 PM
        • Reply to Freehold sale with 2 leases
          Thank you so much for your reply. yes we live in the building and have done so for the past 5 years. This is very reassuring.

          So we don't even have to inflate the cost of the freehold it can be 100£....
          23-05-2019, 17:55 PM
        • Reply to Freehold sale with 2 leases
          Your understanding is correct, the other leaseholder will never be able to accept the offer.

          Do you live in the property as your main residence and have done for more than 12 months? If so you don’t have to offer the right to first refusal anyway.

          Having said that your solicitor...
          23-05-2019, 17:02 PM
        • Right to Manage - Process Questions
          Hello forum,

          Very brief summary of my situation. I own a flat (110 years left on the lease) in a big old Victorian house in London. 11 flats in total, all leasehold. Fairly standard stuff.

          The guy who owns the freehold also does the property management via his own company....
          23-05-2019, 10:33 AM
        • Reply to Right to Manage - Process Questions
          Companies Act 2006 section 303. If they fail to call it, proceed with the following sections.

          You need 28 days notice for any motion to remove an existing director.
          23-05-2019, 13:52 PM
        • Reply to Right to Manage - Process Questions
          Thank you.

          Re: number of directors. I may be able to persuade some other leaseholders to do this (or not!). Articles of RMC say "number of directors may be any number not exceeding the number of issued shares" ie any number from 1 to 11. So having 1 director seems to be permissible...
          23-05-2019, 12:25 PM
        • Reply to Right to Manage - Process Questions
          If you actually had an RTM, the freeholder would also have a vote, so your current arrangement gives you more power.

          A shareholder who cannot attend a meeting can appoint a proxy. It is a criminal offence for the calling notice for the meeting not to point this out.

          The majority...
          23-05-2019, 11:11 AM