Leaseholders Asking to replace windows previously installed without permission

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Leaseholders Asking to replace windows previously installed without permission

    Many years ago ( over 12 years) my leaseholders installed 2windows and double doors under a flat roof creating a porch / gallery in front of the front door of an upstairs flat.

    there has been a water leak in the porch ever since they fitted the windows which I have refused to contribute towards fixing as the area was previously open to the elements
    no prior request was made for permission to install the windows

    Last year they tried to sell the property and as part of the LPE 1 questionnaire I pointed out the unauthorized alterations and requested retrospective consent, requesting the leak to be fixed, a guarantee / indemnity for future leaks as I felt a new leaseholder would expect me to contribute to its maintenance
    i also requested a fee in respect of the uplift in property value.
    the prospective buyer, who was renting the flat from the leaseholder changed their minds and bought somewhere else.

    i have today recd an email asking for permission to replace the windows with new ones.

    my thoughts are either refusal, as I never gave permission in the first place, a fee for retrospective consent, increase in ground rent.?
    i believe the property could be unmortgageable due to the unauthorized conversion?
    by allowing replacement of the windows I think I’m giving retrospective consent?

    I agree. If you gave consent, but then strangely they weren't replaced, then who is to say whether they are the replacements you consented to, or the originals you didn't?


    Latest Activity


    • ownership of loft space
      Hello,I own a long leasehold purpose built edwardian maisonette on the first floor of a 2 storey building.There is a similar flat below me.The attic is directly above my flat and only accesible from my flat.
      my lease includes the roof and i have to maintain the roof and can recover 50% of any...
      19-10-2018, 10:17 AM
    • Reply to ownership of loft space
      If you read this thread: you will see I refer to section 62 of the Law of Property Act 1925. In many cases section 62(2)...
      19-10-2018, 11:23 AM
    • Management fees
      Hi our lease states the FH can take 15% of total expenditure for management fees.
      They have set up a separate company and have charged ££3.5k on £16k expenditure.
      Is this allowed within the clause in our lease below.

      "To pay the cost of any managing agents...
      07-09-2018, 10:21 AM
    • Reply to Management fees
      Yes, it is better to separate the request for recognition from the request for information, If you expect to apply to the FTT, it is better to have clean correspondence without other issues complicating the matter.
      19-10-2018, 11:21 AM
    • Reply to Management fees
      Will do that Eagle, if it helps move thing on.
      19-10-2018, 10:54 AM
    • Reply to Management fees
      The request was made alongside the request for formal recognition of the newly formed RTA, that 83% of leaseholders have signed up to, 5 of the 6 flats, There are long running disputes mainly maintenance Issues and fees overcharging on the FH part, that they dismiss but its there in black and white....
      19-10-2018, 10:52 AM
    • Reply to Management fees
      If that is the case, it is a simple matter to send 2 separate emails, one asking for the RTA to be recognised and a second one from a leaseholder asking for the information
      19-10-2018, 10:47 AM
    • Reply to Management fees
      He wasn't making the request as a leaseholder, but as an RTA. I don't know why he didn't make a request as an individual leaseholder, but as an RTA, the RTA has to be be recognized by the freeholder, and the freeholder can withdraw that recognition at any time, except if an FTT has ruled that the TA...
      19-10-2018, 10:32 AM
    • Reply to Management fees
      Their response is absurd, as a leaseholder you are entitled to receive the information requested. A separate legal entity appears to manage the property and a reasonable management fee for the service provided may be recovered under the service charge provisions. The freeholder is not entitled to charge...
      19-10-2018, 10:08 AM
    • Reply to Management fees
      Thanks Gordon999 we are aware the FH MA are one and the same, I made that point in my first post. What we cant understand is that they think they can do as they please, and to comment we are not fit to be involved in the RTA without is ludicrous....
      19-10-2018, 09:26 AM